10 ms·
Developer interest in Windows 8 is stagnant, new line of worry for Microsoft
- TomFrost 14y agoClearly, the next logical step is to make a love song for developers.
- scrrr 14y agoOff topic: Am I the only one for whom the page doesn't scroll smoothly? It seems badly programmed.
- bradmccarty 14y agoGive us a couple days. We're undergoing some back-end changes and it's causing the pages to have a jerky scroll for some. Apologies for the inconvenience in the meantime.
- scrrr 14y agoGreat. Thought I'd mention it, as I can't be the only one. :)
- jbk 14y agoWell, there are a few good reasons for that: coding for WinRT is harder than it should be, and the developers are not fans of the WinRT UI (so they don't use it). I am in this very situation, with an app with has dozens of millions of users on Windows (and millions daily). The first reason is the most important. WinRT requires a lot of rewrites of your code. (and the rationale behind some limitation are often political), and Microsoft is not helping or making it easy for you Notably for networking and multimedia. Networking: everyone uses the BSD sockets, Win32, Linux, OSX, iOS, Android, Symbian, Bada, etc... And you cannot use them on WinRT. There is a very high chance that your code or one of your library uses it, of course. But the bad part is that Microsoft does not make easy with a wrapper exposing WinSock-like API based on their new API. Not even a wrapper than does 80% of the needs. Multimedia and Games: your videogame that works with a C++ engine and OpenGL ES for casual games that works on iOS, Android, Bada,... does not work under WinRT, because OpenGL is not allowed... And I don't even speak about Video acceleration. Yes, they need to do a massive change in their APIs, but helping the transition would have been a good idea... So yes, writing yet another Twitter client is easy on WinRT, for more complex applications, well, it is way too hard and difficult to do it this fast.
- bornhuetter 14y agoDo you think that WinRT will cause anything important to be broken in VLC, or is it just making your life harder to get it working?
- jbk 14y agoWell, outputting video and audio should not be too hard to adapt (almost work out of the box). Decoding does not do system calls, except for hardware decoding, so no worry. File input is worrying because of the sandbox, but should be doable with some work. But networking is a nightmare. 20 libraries are using WinSock2 (including some codecs like FLAC), plus libVLC's core. Sure HTTP access is fine, but RTP, RTSP, FTP, HTTPS, multicast UDP are weirder beasts... To add it to the pain, VLC is a mostly C99 project, but C99 is too new a standard for Microsoft to implement it :)
- chj 14y agoMissing c99 support is really a pain in the ass. I can't believe they don't care about it.
- stonemetal 14y agoI can't believe they don't care about it. Considering the last time MS released a C compiler I can fully believe it.
- pjmlp 14y agoMicrosoft cares about C++, which already includes most of the C99 changes. GCC has recently migrated to C++ and CLang is developed in C++. So Microsoft reasoning is that C89 is good enough for them, and you are free to buy a compiler from another vendor if you really want to use C99.
- pjmlp 14y agoOoops, I pissed off the C fanboys!
- bornhuetter 14y agoThere's not much comment in the article on the quality of the applications that are on there. Steam has less than 2,000 apps, and no-one would say that it feels empty. The Mac app store launched with only 1,000 apps. I don't think that the number of apps is particularly important as long as the quality stuff is there - can anyone who has used it comment?
- eckyptang 14y agoYes I've trialled Windows 8 heavily for our environment and installed about 50 "popular highly rated apps". They are all simply put: shit. Flakey, broken, hard to use, slow, huge, not useful and poorly integrated and nothing inbetween. Even the microsoft provided apps with Windows 8 are really shoddy. Seriously I'm a fan of Windows Phone 7.5 and own a handset with lots of apps installed but it doesn't scale up to the desktop at all. Not a single existing Windows user is going to bother with this crap - it'll end up going to way desktop gadgets went except you can't turn it off any more.
- bad_user 14y agoOS X is still allowing regular people to install apps from whatever source they want, by default. In Windows 8 you have to either check "Allow all trusted applications to install" in the Group Policy settings in Win Pro/Enterprise, or change a registry setting. This means users will have to go out of their way to install anything beyond what the App Store provides. Well, at least the option is still available. Steam is an app store for games. Games purchases are impulse driven. When buying from Steam, you either go for a big title that you know you'll find on Steam or you go searching for something that triggers your interest. On the other hand a large part of discovery on a regular app store is search-driven by actual needs of users that want to accomplish something very specific. Like, just the other day I searched for a way to view/manage my Picasa-stored photos on my iPad. The number of apps is important for one because this means the app store doesn't solve many specific problems users are having and because Microsoft is known to have a big developer ecosystem since forever (building platforms is what they do best) - and so this lack of enthusiasm reflects badly on them and on Windows 8.
- 14y ago
- jcromartie 14y agoSo what? 2000 is a huge number. I can't even imagine scratching the surface of those, in terms of actually using them. I know they fill different niches, but on my desktop I use maybe about 2 dozen applications on a regular basis. Those 2000 apps could be far better on average than the half-million-or-so in the App Store or Google Play. Or they could all be junk, and Windows Store is doomed. The numbers don't mean much.
- thejosh 14y agoYeah, it's not the quantity, it's the quality. If there is a large subset of quality Windows 8 applications that's good. Not everyone is going to put their applications on there straight away - how many put it onto the MacOS Store straight away (though there was A LOT of hype around the mac store). Mobile application numbers don't really compare to desktop apps, noone really needs a fart app on their PC.
- mtgx 14y agoThings don't really work like that. You don't want your platform to only have 1000-2000 apps. Why? Because you'll never get the "top 1000" apps in there. Plus, people have different needs for apps. On the real Windows you can find a program for just about anything. You won't be able to say that for the Windows store and Windows RT. It's not about having the "top 10 apps". It's about having "all the apps you could ever need". And if there are 2000 apps, it most likely doesn't mean that it contains "all the apps you'll ever need". And which platform would you go with? One that has and will have all the apps you'll need or one that has "2000 apps"?
- praptak 14y agoDisagree. First, the hypothesis that the quality distribution within the 2000 is substantially better than within the half-million-or-so is unlikely to be true, at least there's no evidence why it should be so. Second, the 2000 is absolutely certain not to cover the long tail. The 2 dozen applications you use are not the half a dozen applications I use. Those car engine bluetooth+OBD monitors and bike repair apps are definitely not in the 2000 pool. Not to mention the variety of games out there. 2000 is a really crappy number of apps to have.
- the_unknown 14y agoWholly to be expected at this point. Until Windows 8 hits the shelves and people start using it there is little incentive to build specifically for it - and since Win7 apps run perfectly well in Win8 there is little reason to focus on Windows 8 by itself at this point. Once the WinRT tablets get into peoples hands the call for RT-specific apps will increase. Plus, the WinRT dev environment really isn't as fully baked as we've grown accustomed to in the Windows world. So many things just simply don't exist at this point. I've been looking at building a Javascript-based WinRT project - one of the suggested app build paths suggested by MS and discovered that there is no touch-and-drag support built in yet. You can roll your own using JS-events but .... really, things like that dampen the enthusiasm.
- bradwestness 14y agoThis. People don't even have Windows 8 tablets yet, and the OS itself is still only available to MSDN subscribers. Once the OS and devices hit store shelves development will ramp up exponentially. Most iOS apps weren't developed before the iPhone was released. They were developed as a result of somebody getting an iPhone or an iPad, thinking "Why can't I do X with this?" and then building an app.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoYou couldn't even build apps when the iPhone was released. The web was our API, according to Jobs. The homebrew/jailbreak community started up almost immediately to fill that gap until iOS 2 was beta tested and released with 3rd party app support a year later. So yeah, by the time 3rd party devs were brought onboard, there were lots of devices in people's hands. The trick is to have killer first-party apps, which the web browser and maps very much were on the original iPhone. Nowadays, exclusive killer apps are a bit harder to come by.
- seanalltogether 14y agoI'm one of those developers who was ready to jump right in and go crazy on the platform...until I fully realized how the ecosystem would function. 1. The Windows app store is Metro only. 2. Developers as well as normal users are actively looking for ways to avoid having to interact with Metro. Developers have zero interest in personally using Metro, so they have less of an incentive to port their apps. Other desktop users will also not like being thrown into metro just to use a one-off application, maybe unless it's a game, so they'll continue looking for the desktop version of an app. The whole ecosystem is really a buzzkill for me.
- alexro 14y agoAdd to it that they had to abandon the Metro name due to trademark violation.
- bradwestness 14y agoThe internal name of the design style doesn't really have anything to do with whether people move to the new runtime API.
- alexro 14y agoIt was used in the marketing campaigns, so kind of was public reference to the style already. Now it has no easy reference.
- nhebb 14y ago> 1. The Windows app store is Metro only. They allow Desktop Apps as well.
- bunderbunder 14y agoBut they have to be written using WinRT. Microsoft muddied the waters a bit with this word that they aren't even allowed to use anymore. It's variously been used to describe a set of design principles, a UI development toolkit, and a particular subset of Windows software that is designed to run well on tablets and is put together using the aforementioned design principles and framework. Windows App store apps are Metro-only under one of those three definitions: The framework that we're now supposed to call WinRT. Which is, of course, not at all the same thing as Windows RT.
- Tichy 14y agoTo be honest, do we really need so many apps? Yesterday I prepared the new phone (Galaxy Nexus) for my mum. I don't think I installed more than 7 apps from the market: Chrome browser, Google Sky Map, Rail navigator (for German railway tickets), Google Authenticator, Kindle reader, Öffi (public transport for a lot of cities), Google Goggles. Did I miss anything important? Honest question - I'd like to prepare the phone as good as possible, it is her first smartphone. Perhaps some kind of news reader, but personally I don't use them, wouldn't know what news sources to set up. "We need 1000s of apps" is just something Apple marketing has installed in our brains. If Windows 8 comes with a decent browser, calendar and email app, they are good to go. As for desktop PCs - I think only few people are still interested in creating desktop apps? Not counting games.
- Nav_Panel 14y agoYeah, that's what I was thinking the whole time I was reading this article. "Only" 2000 apps? I'd rather have 200 well-designed and useful apps over 20,000 useless spam-ware ones any day of the week. I've owned an Android device for a year or two and I can say that I have under 30 apps installed on the thing from the app store (and probably 5 of those are superfluous, I'm just too lazy to get rid of them). Yet, it has all the functionality I require. As nice as it is to have thousands upon thousands to choose from, honestly I think fewer can be better in some cases, especially from a consumer's perspective: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/27/your-money/27shortcuts.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/27/your-money/27shortcuts.htm... Based on that article (I know it's NYT but it cites a good source or two), fewer apps might even result in more purchases overall.
- bradwestness 14y agoNo platform can survive without 300 different "Fart button" apps!
- gizmo686 14y agoHow many of your 30 apps do you think make the cut for 2,000 most popular apps.
- 14y ago
- rhengles 14y agoLowering the 30% tax would be a very good first step.
- rbanffy 14y agoIf they want to subsidize ARM devices, they'll need to make money off the app market. If they don't subsidize, their stance on UEFI secure boot will be seriously weakened and open an avenue for questioning by the DoJ or the EU.
- chj 14y agoMS doesn't give developers an option better than Apple's. Their platform (win RT) is as close as iOS. Oh, and that Metro. Do they really use this UI daily themselves? Or do they have a secret way to turn it off completely? Perhaps I am just too old to appreciate this new fashion.
- IanDrake 14y agoIt grows on you. The only thing I don't like about my windows phone is that it's on AT&T. I say this after having the first iPhone, the GS, and the 4.
- pmelendez 14y ago"MS doesn't give developers an option better than Apple's. Their platform (win RT) is as close as iOS." Sorry for disagree but between the other two (Android and WinRT) WinRT is fairly far away from iOS. Not mentioning that is way more comfortable to work on VS rather than Xcode.
- eckyptang 14y agoI work with a lot (80+ developers) in the Microsoft ecosystem. I haven't found a single one who is enthusiastic about Windows 8. Most are looking rather worried as yet again the rug has been pulled from underneath them. They got burned with Silverlight and the first drop of the Foundation series of products and Entity Framework. Another incompatible API is just more shit to deal with. They are not happy. I'm not either as I have to support these guys.
- trimbo 14y ago> Most are looking rather worried as yet again the rug has been pulled from underneath them. They got burned with Silverlight and the first drop of the Foundation series of products and Entity Framework. Not one dev saw that coming with those APIs? I don't believe it. Microsoft in the 2000s has been all about throwing APIs against the wall and then deprecating them. Anyone who has been around Microsoft knew this was a risk with Silverlight. I think the real reason these particular devs got burned is because is because Windows today is like Mac before MacOS X: it's all about incompatibility with the rest of the world, "doing it better", crap like that. MVPs are happy to go along with it and adopt these technologies because they can keep their position of being important in the ecosystem. It's like Apple fans in the 90s. WPF, Silverlight, EF, all this stuff is akin to Apple's OpenDoc, or Dylan, or even Newton. It's shiny technology in an incompatible vacuum. On the topic of the Windows app store. When Apple made iOS, they took components of MacOS X as the foundation of iOS. But when they released the Mac App Store, they didn't force developers on MacOS X develop to the iOS API. That's what Microsoft is trying to do here. Develop with RT or Metro or GTFO. Pure idiocy. The next step is predictable: Microsoft will have to step in like they have on WP7 and they'll start offering to pay for other people's development costs to do the port. I'd be surprised if they haven't already started offering that.
- ja27 14y agoThere would certainly be more apps in the store if they had opened the store up for more developers before now. They've only been accepting app submissions from most companies for about 45 days and individual developers were only allowed to submit apps 14 days ago.
- cooldeal 14y agoHow many tablet apps did Android have while launching tablets? How many are even tablet compatible now? Why should developers launch now instead of polishing their apps and launching at RTM? I think this is much ado about nothing, once the platform launches and people start buying laptops with touchscreens and tablets, the number of apps will also go up.
- axusgrad 14y agoMS has lots of employees that worked on Windows 8, maybe they can give them some "free time" for a month to write apps.
- IanDrake 14y ago> Thus, for Windows 8 to break the five-figure app threshold – in a world in which it’s six figures or bust – by launch If I remember correctly the iPhone launched with no app store. I realize the author's point, but it's offered as fact with little to back it.
- venomsnake 14y agoFirst - I think that the quality is more important than quantity and countless me too's. So it depends which these 2000 are - if 100 of them are good,polished and they cover wide spectrum of needed functionality its more than enough. The real problem is the lockdown of the system.
- candl 14y agoTo me, the biggest deal breaker is that having a Windows Phone developer account doesn't let you release applications for Windows 8. It's a shame because many people including me could at least port some of their apps. An additional 99$/year for the Windows 8 store simply isn't worth it. If there's one major reason why the interest is so low then it's probably it. I am definately going to stick with Windows Phone for the time being since it's been a great experience and the release of WP8 will bring some needed attention.
- steve_colton 14y agoIt's very expected situation. Developers don't like WinRT and will stick to Win32 forever because Win32 is open platform (anyone can develop for it without paying Microsoft) and WinRT is closed platform where Microsoft can apply censorship in their "app shop". No developer in the whole world wants to be thrown out of that "shop" and supply ideas for next version of Windows for free.
- wolfgke 14y agoAs long as * I can't write my own JIT compiler because of a lack of VirtualAlloc() and VirtualProtect() functions * I don't have access to some other lowlevel functions not available in WinRT that exist in WinAPI * I am forced to use Microsoft's App Store to provide my Metro applications I am not in the slightest interested in writing applications for WinRT. See http://www.freelists.org/post/luajit/FYI-No-JIT-on-Windows-8-for-ARM http://www.freelists.org/post/luajit/FYI-No-JIT-on-Windows-8... for explanations to the first point.
- pjmlp 14y agoIsn't C++, all .NET languages enough? Just use the tools the platform offers, instead of using the same hammer everywhere.
- wolfgke 14y agoI simply want to be able to build my own hammer if necessary. Microsoft - of course - does not have to build the hammer I want to use - but give me the possibilities to do so - in this case access to these API functions. The Javascript engine used for Metro applications (Chakra) also uses these API calls, so even Microsoft is (obviously) not able to relinquish using these API calls for writing a JIT compiler. So: I really only want to use the tools the platform offers - but in the same way Microsoft does; not in the limited way that Microsoft forces outside developers.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 14y ago> lack of VirtualAlloc() and VirtualProtect() functions While these API not be in the "modern" SDK, the system calls behind them still work just fine. (They have to: otherwise, malloc wouldn't work.) You can walk ntdll's export table manually and find NtProtectVirtualMemory and friends. Also, SYSENTER is a thing.
- wolfgke 14y ago
- jonaldomo 14y agoWhen Apple released the App Store there were only 900 apps [1]. Which I believe shows that the number of apps is not a good measure of success. What is a good measure of success is that Apple had 10 million downloads in three days... [1] http://www.macstories.net/stories/four-years-of-app-store-developers-weigh-in-on-search-discovery-and-curation/ http://www.macstories.net/stories/four-years-of-app-store-de...
- dclowd9901 14y agoHow about 5 free copies of Windows 8 for any developer who ports their app to it?
- herf 14y agoMicrosoft loses developers by ignoring the installed base. XP held up WPF adoption, and Win7 will hold up WinRT. That's assuming anybody enjoys using it. It's still easier to ship on Win32 and not worry about these fragmented versions of the OS. Also this is a tools question too: It's harder to make an app for two versions of Windows than it is to make an app for Windows and something else. The tools just don't make it easy to write conditional code.
- SunboX 14y agoThey should give away the professional version of visual studio for free. I think more people will start to write apps for Windows 8. They also should Webmatrix 2 IDE turn into a IDE for JavaScript developers compare able with visual studio. With all fancy auto completion, docs and helpers. And it should be super easy to "export" Windows 8 Apps with Webmatrix 2.
- Havoc 14y agoAfter using it fro ~3 months I can conclusively say that anybody writing apps for it should book an appointment with a shrink. Hell the only metro tile I use is the show desktop one.
- chaostheory 14y agoI'm even not a Windows guy but I feel it's too early to tell whether or not Windows 8 is stagnant. There's less than a month's worth of data. I think I'd be more interested in either a November or January update.
- JimmaDaRustla 14y agoFirst world problems: Launch day of a whole new operating system. Only 7000 apps to choose from. T______T
- thedeuce 14y agomy personal lack of interest stems from visual studio professional and ultimate costing hundreds of dollars, when on other platforms I receive free IDE's. VS express doesn't seem to cut it honestly.
- nhebb 14y agoOn a related note, the folks at LLBLGen wrote a post on getting a non-WinRT desktop app listed in the Windows Store: http://weblogs.asp.net/fbouma/archive/2012/09/12/the-windows-store-why-did-i-sign-up-with-this-mess-again.aspx http://weblogs.asp.net/fbouma/archive/2012/09/12/the-windows... The process looks completely messed up and will likely turn off many Windows developers (like myself).
- alpeb 14y agoAn OS that will soon be used by hundreds of millions of people, with a depleted app store. Seems to me like a huge opportunity for devs, as opposed to following the herd into the overcrowded iOS and android stores.
- bicknergseng 14y agoI mean... isn't developer interest in desktop platforms stagnant? I mean... what "apps" do desktop users buy aside from games and the MS Office suite and Adobe? Forgive me if this is massively ignorant of the giant world of desktop software I haven't installed.
- onetwothreefour 14y agoWhy give MS 30% of your revenue when you don't have to?
- kristianp 14y agoHow can they claim that developer interest is 'stagnant'? The number of apps is steadily increasing. What makes them think that Microsoft is worried? This story has almost no basis in fact. Another report of this story on another tech news site did point out that developers may be aiming their releases for the date when Win 8 is generally available. So we may see an increase in the rate of releases as that date approaches. This is just speculation, just like the story, but at least it brings some balance to the argument.