4 ms·
The community obfuscation mappings unrestrictively licensed. The Microsoft ones are not. It's a trap.
by 64718283661 1y ago
The community obfuscation mappings unrestrictively licensed. The Microsoft ones are not. It's a trap.
- poly2it 1y agoDoes copyright apply to variable names?
- jagged-chisel 1y agoGiven the Oracle v Google decision, the likely answer is yes. But then there’s a fair use argument to be made.
- Tyrannosaur 1y agoI was initially a little confused at your comment. I had thought the decision was against Oracle being able to sue for use of the Java API. Reading a little closer, the decision was that even assuming the API copyright claim was valid, Google's use of the API was fair use. > In April 2021, the Supreme Court ruled in a 6–2 decision that Google's use of the Java APIs served an organizing function and fell within the four factors of fair use, bypassing the question on the copyrightability of the APIs. The decision reversed the Federal Circuit ruling and remanded the case for further review. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_....
- einsteinx2 1y agoBut the whole point is there are no more mappings. I’m not sure what the trap is supposed to be?
- throwaway290 1y agoYour mod uses variable name FooBar in ways Microsoft don't like, Microsoft sues you for copyright before the judge would have to admit it was just coincident.
- rstat1 1y agoThey've had plenty of opportunity to do this and haven't, so would find it incredibly unlikely they would magically start to have a problem now Not to mention doing would basically kill game as one of the biggest reason people even still play Minecraft is the modding scene, not the minimum viable effort that have been the official updates for last number of years.
- throwaway290 1y agodon't think they could do it previously because the code is not open and any names are a result of deobfuscation so clashes are accidental
- circuit10 1y agoWouldn’t the structure of the code be be more copyrightable than the names?
- throwaway290 1y agocommunity makes mods, they don't duplicate game code structure, and if they do it's clearly by accident because the code is obfuscated
- circuit10 1y agoBut the mod relies on the code structure as much as it relies on the names, I think it could still be considered a derivative work, I don’t think this would be copyrightable but I find the code structure being copyrightable more plausible than the names
- einsteinx2 1y agoI’ll preface this by saying I’m not a lawyer, but let’s say Microsoft released an obfuscated version where the method FooBar is called FakeName instead. If I use FakeName in my mod, aren’t I hypothetically at risk of the same thing? How does the actual name matter for this argument? Or is the argument that only source code is copyrighted, but not binaries so it only matters if the name matches the original source code? That doesn’t seem possible because it’s copyright infringement to share a retail game binary, so they’re clearly copyrighted as well. So I’m really unclear how the risk here is any different regardless of obfuscation since the mod needs to use method names from the copyrighted binary either way.