4 ms·
Yes, a challenge for major structural alterations to the American system is that the median American family is probably better off under this system than they w
by tptacek 1y ago
Yes, a challenge for major structural alterations to the American system is that the median American family is probably better off under this system than they would be under any of the European-style systems: the wage premium enjoyed by many Americans and the lower tax level offsets the cost of insurance and copays.
So when you're talking about how bad the American system is, you're really talking about a minority of its users. That doesn't make everything OK, but does highlight the political difficulty of enacting seemingly-popular changes.
- wing-_-nuts 1y ago>the median American family is probably better off under this system than they would be under any of the European-style systems: the wage premium enjoyed by many Americans and the lower tax level offsets the cost of insurance and copays. If you had said the median tech worker? I might have believed you, but the median family? No way.
- tptacek 1y agoThe median family of 4 with private health insurance has a household income of around $115k not counting the gross cost of their employer-provided health care. Remember: being on private insurance puts you in a cohort that: * Excludes everybody on Medicaid * Excludes fixed-income seniors on Medicare * Makes it overwhelmingly likely you have subsidized employer-covered health insurance. Figure your employer "covers" half the gross cost of your $24k/yr health insurance (they aren't, really: that's money they'd be paying you directly without the distortion of employer-provided health care). Do the take-home pay math. Put them in, like, Ohio, or Iowa, or Colorado; just not SFBA or NYC. Now move that same family to Manchester, take the wage hit for moving to the UK labor market, and work out the take-home pay. They'll of course pay $0 for the NHS. Are they better off or worse off? I'm not valorizing the arrangement, I'm making a point about how political tractable changing it is.
- linehedonist 1y agoYou’re moving the goalposts. How many families have private insurance? Considering both families with and without private insurance, is the median family better off in the US?
- Uehreka 1y agoIdk, speaking as a big Medicare-for-all supporter, this would definitely explain why MfA always polls well at first, until people start asking if they can keep their current plan. I know at this point in the debate we’re supposed to write those people off as either innumerate, a minority, or too risk-averse for their own good, but honestly if it turned out that that stat was true, that would explain a lot. And it would be exactly the kind of political engineering minmax scheme large corps in the US are great at: petition legislators to cut regulations so you can cut costs and maximize profits, but keep juuuust enough of the right perks in the right places so that a slim majority of people in Wisconsin, Michigan and Georgia oppose shaking things up.
- tptacek 1y agoThe people who want to keep their own plan are almost definitionally not innumerate! They would be worse off financially under M4A. That doesn't make M4A bad policy (I think it's bad policy for other reasons), but it does take "people are being irrational" off the table in a discussion like this.
- supertrope 1y agoEven if you keep your plan it's getting enshittified every year. It's that time of year again - enroll for 2026 benefits. My employer raised employee premiums by 10%, raised the deductible, added more administrative burden such as "step therapy" (the insurance company denies your claim for a drug until you've tried a cheaper but less effective drug, even if you've already done "step therapy" while on another health plan!) Your employer will change the plan premiums and structure every single year. They can lay you off, exclude expensive drugs, exclude doctors, etc. Some specialties like anesthesiology and psychiatry are usually not in network. In extreme cases an employer can change health administrators mid-year and your deductible will reset. https://www.pwc.com/us/en/industries/health-industries/library/behind-the-numbers.html https://www.pwc.com/us/en/industries/health-industries/libra... https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/workplace-health-insurance-premiums-family-plans-kff-survey/ https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/workplace-health-insu...
- fredophile 1y ago
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Yes, a challenge for major structural alterations to the American system is that the median American family is probably better off under this system than they would be under any of the European-style systems: the wage premium enjoyed by many Americans and the lower tax level offsets the cost of insurance and copays. The US spends nearly as much in taxpayer funds as a share of GDP as other developed countries (and vastly more on a per capita basis), with even more in private costs on top of it. It is simply dishonest to say that the "wage premium enjoyed by many Americans and the lower tax level offsets the cost of insurance and copays", because neither the US wage premium nor any lower tax burden are attributable to differences in healthcare systems, but rather are in spite of the far greater burden of the US healthcare system. OTOH, it is true that a major challenge is that people respond with this line to any proposed major structural changes to the US system.
- tptacek 1y agoAgain, you can just do the math on this. You're making an argument about the macro costs of our system --- I think those costs are fucked, too. But I'm not talking about that; I'm talking about the actual experience of an ordinary middle-income family with private health insurance. That family would likely (in fact, almost certainly) be worse off in a single-payer system. I'd appreciate if you'd avoid using language like "simply dishonest" with me in the future. It's easy to tell me I'm wrong about something without accusing me of commenting in bad faith. This is in the guidelines. Thanks in advance!
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Again, you can just do the math on this. You're making an argument about the macro costs of our system --- I think those costs are fucked, too. But I'm not talking about that; I'm talking about the actual experience of an ordinary middle-income family with private health insurance. Yes, you can just do the math, and changing nothing about the US except transition to a European style universal system, the median family would face lower aggregate tax, out-of-paycheck, and out-of-pocket costs than they do now, with less health insecurity around unexpected events (either health or employment), unless the tax increases necessary were deliberately and perversely targeted to avoid that. That’s a direct consequence of the difference in the macro-level costs: they aren’t separate, orthogonal concerns. People just have a hard time accepting that the US health care system is structurally constructed right now to waste vast hordes of money preventing people from accessing health care, but that’s exactly what it does.
- teaearlgraycold 1y agoI don’t know if the median American would be worse off with a European style system. Certainly the 1% don’t need it. I’ve been on the Google health insurance before and it made me feel like I had $10 million in the bank.
- arjvik 1y agoCan I ask what the Google health insurance is like?
- teaearlgraycold 1y agoI've been lucky with my health so I don't have a huge list of interactions: * Free tele psycho-therapy. Not sure what the limit is but it's >= 2 hours per week. I even cancelled same-day once with no fee. The quality of the care was also very high. * I developed wrist pain from typing, holding a Steam Deck, starting pull ups. I was able to see a physical therapist at the Google office (through an embedded One Medical) after 1 week. No referral needed. Saw them once per week for 5 weeks paying $20 co-pay each time. They fixed my issues permanently. * I also occasionally used the Google One Medical locations (and public ones) for injuries from a low speed bike crash, vaccines, etc. Don't think I ever paid more than $20 for anything. On a Google income that amount is completely inconsequential.
- ilegitmadethisn 1y ago[flagged]
- egorfine 1y ago> about how bad the American system is, you're really talking about a minority of its users It sure seems that way if a wealth family with top level insurance can still get bankrupt by medical bills. Examples of that are right here in comments.
- tptacek 1y agoAre you referring to the comment that roots this thread?
- TheOtherHobbes 1y agoNo need. It's a known phenomenon. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/06/16/1104969627/medical-debt-upended-their-lives-heres-what-it-took-from-them https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/06/16/1104969... https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/medical-debt/ https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/medical-debt/ https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/03/27/health-and-wealth-why-americans-are-drowning-in-medical-debt https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/03/27/health-and-weal... As for income distribution https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gini-coefficient-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gini-coef... State GDP figures are skewed by high earners. The US is massively and systemically unequal, with far less economic mobility than the EU.
- tptacek 1y agoI asked a question about the comments on this thread. This isn't responsive to that question.