3 ms·
> What is the point that you are trying to prove? I was arguing against the following statement: "But it's an exaggeration [...] to say that the enterprises th
by Alex3917 14y ago
> What is the point that you are trying to prove?
I was arguing against the following statement: "But it's an exaggeration [...] to say that the enterprises that develop new drugs for prescribed medical treatment are corrupt in general beyond what Goldacre claims with specific evidence."
Or, more generally, reminding people why it is that our infrastructure is falling apart and why the federal government is at risk of collapse in the next few years, which are both in large part due to the massive amounts of fraud in the medical system. At least a third of all medical spending is waste and fraud, and that's not even counting the damages from all the needless harm it inflicts on people. Even just fixing some of the low-hanging fruit would leave us with enough money to provide healthcare to all Americans, as well as build an entire nationwide highspeed rail network every single year.
> Your evidence seems to be that they do not talk about all of the corruption and problems that you would like them to talk about.
It's mostly the intellectual dishonesty in virtually every single post that bothers me. The entire point of the blog is to 'prove' that alternative medicine is inferior to mainstream medicine because it isn't supported by science. They do this by looking at all the ways alternative medicine isn't supported by science, while completely sweeping under the rug all of the ways that mainstream medicine isn't supported by science. My concern isn't that the authors aren't mentioning specific issues, but rather that they're going out of their way to mislead their readers about the issues and the state of medicine more generally.
> That's an 18 year old source, talking about life expectancy, which is a trailing indicator.
It's the most recent data available. The fact that a lot of the data about the medical system is 20+ years old is in fact one of the biggest problems.
Also, I'm not in any way dismissing the contributions of modern medicine. As you say, modern medicine has contributed an enormous amount to society. Which makes it all the more unfortunate that many of its most vocal supporters wildly exaggerate its benefits and stick their heads in the sand when confronted with its problems. Making an intellectually honest argument in favor of modern medicine has to be one of the easiest tasks in the world, so the fact that so many of its supporters can't even do this doesn't say much for the quality of their ideas.
> Trying to prove that modern medicine has a net negative value because of a few issues of systemic corruption is not the way to do it.
I'm not trying to prove that it has net negative value. However, it's definitely not just a 'few' issues with systemic corruption.