7 ms·
Why Apple will move away from Intel and towards ARM 64 bit
- eckyptang 14y agoI disagree. They will either hang themselves with x86-64 or make it a success as it is now. They won't go near ARM as a mainstream CPU.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoI'm sure that Apple has a plan in place to do this, but whether they pull the trigger on this plan is another question. It's quite likely that Clover Trail is faster than A6, and Clover Trail is Intel's low end chip. Ivy Bridge is almost an order of magnitude faster than Clover Trail. Most of the PA Semi guys at Apple will be working on chips for the next iPads and iPhones, but I'd be willing to bet lots of money there's a skunk works project to design a chip that could go into the Air. Apple loves squeezing the margin out of their suppliers, and Intel's margin is very juicy.
- mtgx 14y agoUnlikely, especially on the GPU side. But let's say Clover Trail is slightly faster than A6. That's not really relevant, because Apple would care much more about using their own chip. It's not like Apple hasn't used slower CPU's than the competition. Heck, for the entirety of the iPhone 4S' and iPad 3's life, both had slower CPU's than the competition. And they didn't care. Plus, Clover Trail is not used in smartphones for a reason - it uses too much power. That's why they are only using it for $800 Windows 8 tablets with big batteries. So for this chip, the A6X, or whatever they call the chip inside the next iPad, will be its competition anyway. As for "ARMbooks", I'm pretty sure Apple will wait until they have an 64 bit ARM chip first, but I also wonder if they will make a "higher-end" chip, that uses say 5-10W of power and is specifically made for those ARMbooks - not for iPads or iPhones, while in parallel continuing the development of A7, A8, etc.
- Zenst 14y agoInteresting read with some good points albiet biased towards the aspect they will move. But does show that it is not impossible, though nothing soon and I'd agree that laptops would be there first target area. I also liked the aspect that OSX is becomming more and more phone OS like and that could indeed also be said of the upcomming win8 due to metro. Overall I see both Apple and Microsoft going for consumer level devices, remember calculators are computers as well, only biased for the application and in that both apple and microsoft are transitioning towards a unified interface and standard making computers more and more consumerised. Thats ok as there will always be Linux and many other operating systems to play with if you need that level of interaction and in that whilst its a change I don't like, I can understand it. One aspect not touched upon in this article is the whole area of a server, one which apple walked away from and is a whole empty cavity that could become one which a 64bit version of ARM chips down the line could end up making that area viable for Apple again. Though it would probably be a solid white cube called iPortal j/k. Either way, even if they do move they can still brow beat Intel for even better prices milking every avenue of options along the way. Though any move to a ARM base for OSX would at the earliest be 2 years away and relisticaly 4-5. Though for servers and processing farms it does become a whole new avenue.
- xradionut 14y ago"Overall I see both Apple and Microsoft going for consumer level devices, remember calculators are computers as well, only biased for the application and in that both apple and microsoft are transitioning towards a unified interface and standard making computers more and more consumerised. Thats ok as there will always be Linux and many other operating systems to play with if you need that level of interaction and in that whilst its a change I don't like, I can understand it." A huge chunk of Microsoft revenue comes from business customers, pros and the ilk, who run applications that can't all be distilled down to a touch interface. There's still a CLI in Windows 8 and much of the MS new server products are driven with CLI in the form of Powershell. You can pick your level of interaction that you need.
- buster 14y agoYay, great. Apple go. The day Apple moves to ARM on the Macbook will be the start of the downfall of Apple. Also, when is Apple moving to Intel on the iPhone? Actually, i can imagine running a server farm on ARMs, that'd be great (and there is ARM server hardware available). BUt for the desktop? nope.
- hfs 14y agoTheir downfall began when they moved away from PPC. It's been a long time coming.
- dochtman 14y agoWhy not? They've done ppc to x86 before.
- rbanffy 14y agoAnd what is now called OSX started on 68K processors
- rbanffy 14y agoARM started as a desktop platform and, at the time, it was much faster clock for clock than what Intel offered. I believe you can find benchmarks of that time comparing the Archimedes to high end PCs. Current ARMs are designed to save power, but there is nothing preventing Apple (or anyone else) from designing one for speed.
- majormajor 14y agoWhat makes you think Apple would have more luck competing with Intel on speed this time around than they+IBM/Moto did in the past, or than AMD has had?
- leoc 14y agoWell, it depends on what you mean by 'competing with Intel on speed'. If you mean having higher-performance CPUs than the Intel equivalents then Apple probably won't achieve that. If you mean having CPUs close enough to Intel's in overall performance that few potential Apple buyers will be put off by speed issues, then that seems very possible. If Apple had to use AMD processors from now on they'd manage fine (potential supply/vendor relations problems aside).
- bluthru 14y agoWill Windows 8 be able to run on that chipset as well?
- freehunter 14y agoOne thing about ARM is generally ARM chips need SoC specific drivers. If Windows 8 has drivers for this chip, Windows 8 will run. Chances are, if Apple does this and wishes for Boot Camp to continue, they will package the drivers for Windows 8. If they wish to discontinue Boot Camp, they won't.
- recoiledsnake 14y agoNot going to happen, Windows RT will ship only with devices just like Windows phone, there will be no standalone software that you can buy and install.
- trotsky 14y agoYou can't license WinRT unless you're selling the hardware.
- agpen 14y agoA lot of discussion on the hardware side and none on the software. The modern mac has benefited enormously in terms of software availability and compatibility from being nix based and on x86 hardware. Does it really make sense to completely throw away that by moving to a non-x86 platform? The iphone/ipad are one thing, because those devices are built around the universal web just as much as native apps, but when you're talking about the pc market and being used for serious productivity, multimedia creation and software development and such, going backwards to the days of hoping there are specific mac ports of the tools you need sounds like a losing proposition.
- archgrove 14y agoI don't necessarily disagree with the conclusions, but "Next up is the OS. Have you noticed that OSX releases of late, well, to be blunt, suck? It’s not that they suck as a stand alone OS, but they take away a lot of the freedoms and flexibility that the Mac desktop OS user has come to expect. Bit by bit Apple is removing all of the parts that make OSX something other than a phone class OS" Is nonsense. "Suck" is a matter of opinion, but there's nothing you can do on a 5 year old Mac that you can't do on a new Mac (and several things more). People keep confusing attempts to make the OS easier to use with "closing" it. When I can't run my own software, and drop to a terminal with the standard UNIX tool chain, I'll but the argument. But there's no sign of this so far.
- maratd 14y ago> When I can't run my own software, and drop to a terminal with the standard UNIX tool chain, I'll but the argument. But there's no sign of this so far. You can run your own software and drop to a terminal with the standard UNIX tool chain on your iPhone, too. You just have to jailbreak it first. So Apple is really one flip of the switch away ...
- archgrove 14y agoThat's true of every computational device in the world. Windows, Ubuntu, Android, etc. Everyone could flip that switch, and lockout non-jailbreakers (or Kernel recompilers). It's not an argument for it happening.
- batista 14y ago>So Apple is really one flip of the switch away ... And how is that different from OS X 10.1?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- awj 14y ago> So Apple is really one flip of the switch away ... ... in much the same way that Ubuntu is really one flip of the switch away.
- programminggeek 14y agoIt reminds me of this: http://apc.io/ http://apc.io/ At some point, we have enough power in a small space that the hardware powering your computer or laptop is basically the size of a credit card and it doesn't matter if it's ARM or Intel. Apple can save money and get better battery life by making their own chips (as they do in phones now) so why not move that up the hardware food chain once the performance is "good enough". Apple is about selling mobile devices to consumers and probably the #1 thing the average buyer wants is longer battery life, even at the expense of performance. Also, Apple knows the power of controlling their own destiny and inevitably when they partner with a company, the same company tends to turn around and resell the innovation as their own products - Microsoft Windows, Google Android, and Intel Ultrabooks. Apple is big enough now they might not need to partner for such innovations much longer. That could lead to an even bigger and more sustainable competitive advantage.
- nilsbunger 14y agoBeing able to run Windows applications with Fusion or Bootcamp was one of the big draws for me for the Mac. Not sure if I'm ready to give up running x86 applications yet (or ever?).
- pooriaazimi 14y agoA valid point. However, Microsoft is betting heavily on ARM too, with Win8 RT (if I'm not mistaken and RT is the ARM one). So, Win8 and a lot of Win8 apps are going to support ARM, and those who don't can be virtualized! (Note that I'm not saying it's a good plan)
- trotsky 14y agoWait, you're suggesting that you're going to be running an x86 emulator on winrt for apps access? That is pretty unlikely to be a realistic solution unless you're only looking for very old apps - try running an arm emulator on x86 to get a taste, and then slow it down by 5x or more.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoYou're right :) It probably would be unusably slow.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoThey're moving away from x86 - maybe. I remember Intel's XScale ARM processors were the best around at the time. But Apple without x86 = suicide...
- protomyth 14y agoBootcamp sells a lot of Macintoshes.
- sswezey 14y agoOS X sells more.
- protomyth 14y agoMaybe, but the ability to flip to Windows is a huge advantage that makes buyers feel safe about the leap. I cannot see them giving up without good reason or an alternative (WinRT).
- dagw 14y agoI was at a talk recently about some C#/.Net framework aimed at .Net developers and half the laptops in the room where Macs running Windows. Even the lead developer giving the presentation had a Mac.
- uvTwitch 14y agoApple are arrogant enough to believe that cutting bootcamp won't significantly affect sales.
- protomyth 14y agoI'm pretty sure they have a rough estimate of the number of copies of VMWare and Parallels sold, plus know the number of bootcamp downloads. They are a very profitable business and do things for business reasons.
- uvTwitch 14y agoSuch as declaring thermonuclear war on android, that's a business decision which was made for business reasons, and has been great for business.
- digitalengineer 14y agoNobody here's a wee bit worried about the direction Apple is going with Gatekeeper? Only signed and sandboxed apps in a few years? Only to be dl and purchased in the App Store with Apple receiving 30%?
- jimktrains2 14y agoAs long as the user can disable it, it's not a problem. Android does the exact same thing.
- trotsky 14y agoIt seems like Apple would be a pretty good candidate for the "Heterogeneous System Architecture" work AMD has been doing, x86_64 and ARM on the same SOC. Leave the x86 cores off when you don't need them.
- twoodfin 14y agoIf anyone has both the technical know how to come up with a "good enough" development scheme to make that work, and the leverage with their developers to ensure support, it's Apple. But yikes that sounds like a hard problem. How do you migrate a process from one ISA to the other? Some kind of compiler-enforced "safe points" where there's a sensible mapping of the IP and other instruction stream-sensitive state?
- geon 14y agoLots of systems have been buils with multiple processor architectures, including the early Macs, the Nintendo DS, the PS3, and every PC the last decade (cpu+gpu). You would usually write your code to use one specific cpu, rather than trying to balance the load automatically like on a heterogenous system.
- twoodfin 14y agoI thought trotsky was suggesting an ARM/x86 mix along the lines of ARM's big.LITTLE, which allows process migration between two very differently implemented (though ISA-compatible) cores.
- trotsky 14y agoWhile they haven't announced any of it in public, it does seem hard to believe they'd be migrating running applications. It's much more likely that they're targeting nx page sharing, you'd still have build the os for both isas, but it'd allow you to run many tasks on the low poer cores and only spin up the hot ones when the application required the performance or binary compatibility. Think more like switchable graphics than big.little, though the low power architecture would stay usable all the time.
- lbcadden3 14y agoMaybe. Based on the current revenue breakdown I think the only reason Apple still makes computers is the margins they get. If they got the margins a lot of other pc makers get they would have killed the computer side already.
- nachteilig 14y agoSeems pretty silly to claim it's "obvious" as this guy does repeatedly. I'm not sure you can claim that the move from being able to upgrade and service computers to not being able to is a move toward being an iOS device. Seems more likely that Apple just makes those sacrifices because they're required to make thin and light products, and at today's speeds few people need to upgrade things anymore. (Not that it wouldn't be _nice_ to be able to upgrade things, but we've seemingly moved to a time when a lot of people don't mind the lack of this as a feature)
- onetwothreefour 14y agoAnyone who says something like this deserves to be laughed at and shown the door out of technology. Intel is light years ahead of ARM for desktop CPUs, where power usage is irrelevant. Do you really think Apple is going to run ALL THE APPS EVER WRITTEN FOR OS X on an x86 to ARM emulation layer? Really? Well, then I have a bridge to sell you.
- sp332 14y agoThey've done it before, more than once. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_68K_emulator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_68K_emulator and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_%28software%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosetta_%28software%29
- wmf 14y agoApple already dropped Rosetta, abandoning PPC apps. Gatekeeper is doing away with apps compiled before 2012. 10.9 may drop 32-bit. Perhaps 10.10 will be App Store only with fat x86-64/ARM apps. Then 10.11 can drop x86-64.