3 ms·
"it looks like the ARM core blocks were laid out manually—as in, by hand"
by protomyth 14y ago
"it looks like the ARM core blocks were laid out manually—as in, by hand"
- freehunter 14y agoDoes anyone know why a chip put in by hand will be faster than a chip put in mechanically (or whatever other means they could use)?
- DIVx0 14y agoI think they mean that the layout of the die components were laid out and optimized by hand rather than letting an algorithm do it. I could be wrong though, I'm not an EE.
- Symmetry 14y agoYup, for the same reason that hand-crafted assembly is usually faster than compiled code. A human can just do more creative things to optimize a layout than our current algorithms can.
- protomyth 14y agoI just thought it was interesting given Apple's history: http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Nybbles.txt http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Nybbles.txt "The Apple II disk controller, designed six months after the Apple II itself was complete, was Steve Wozniak's crowning achievement. His five chip disk controller card out-performed competitive controllers that were four times as expensive by shifting most of the responsibilities from hardware to software. In Woz's approach, the software was responsible for doing all of the encoding and decoding, head stepping, etc. This allowed Woz to improve the capacity and performance over standard techniques." http://apple2history.org/history/ah05/ http://apple2history.org/history/ah05/ For two weeks, he worked late each night to make a satisfactory design. When he was finished, he found that if he moved a connector he could cut down on feedthroughs, making the board more reliable. To make that move, however, he had to start over in his design. This time it only took twenty hours. He then saw another feedthrough that could be eliminated, and again started over on his design. “The final design was generally recognized by computer engineers as brilliant and was by engineering aesthetics beautiful. Woz later said, ‘It’s something you can only do if you’re the engineer and the PC board layout person yourself. That was an artistic layout. The board has virtually no feedthroughs.’
- stordoff 14y agoIIRC, you can optimise the locations of sub-components to minimise on-chip communication delays. The automatic algorithms are pretty good, but can often be bettered (particularly if critical paths are identified and optimised).
- DigitalJack 14y agoIt won't always be faster. In fact, I'd argue if you had to lay out the whole thing by hand you would almost certainly do a worse job than "automatic" place&route. It's a matter of distance between components on the die, and transistor sizing. At the scale of complex integrated circuits, it's just about guaranteed that an automatic route will do a good job, but stands a good chance of messing a few hotspots up. I'm not an expert on the algorithms used for automatic routing, but there is some random guessing involved. You can even provide a seed for the random number generator. More often than not, a hybrid approach is used where the designer gives broad recommendations on where to place components and lets the autorouter go from there. Then at the end, the designer may go in and tweak some hot spots, or scrap it and start over with a new seed.
- X-Istence 14y agoAutomatic routing is still an NP complete problem, as in there is no perfect solution. This is the same issue with automatic routers for PCB's and the like, it is guess work along with some genetic sort of algorithm that steps through various options. I've had times where the auto router for a board gave up because it couldn't complete the routing, ripped everything up and did it by hand. Sure it took longer but the routes were shorter, and I finished routing the board with room to spare.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoChips, like printed circuit boards, are often laid out by algorithms. These algorithms try to optimize amongst a number of parameters such as active transistors per unit area, signal paths, power requirements, interference (things like electron tunnelling) and whatnot. As with a circuit board you can set the dial 'wide' and get a quick layout that is not optimal. You can dial it in and the algorithm will do most of the work and then stop on things it can't figure out (which an engineer then goes in and manually places). It's time consuming to do manual layout and the effects are not always immediately obvious [1]. So there is both a time component and a risk component to manual layout. It can however result in a smaller and more efficient chip. [1] When I was at Intel the 386 was the new hawtness. The first silicon samples powered up and ran which was awesome but at 'full speed' there were some issues that turned out to be related to a clock signal somewhere between the registers and the ALU. The design engineer replaced a metal feature (typical conductors were done in the metal layer) with a polysilicon version which had the effect of slowing down the propagation speed enough to line up the clocks. (it was fortunate it didn't need to go faster which is harder to do :-) These days the device geometries are so small as to require a lot of analysis which I would not enjoy trying to do by "hand".
- ajross 14y agoI don't think that's particularly notable. They certainly aren't saying someone manually drafted each of the (dozens of!) mask layers on paper. They're saying that the floorplanning (i.e. the positioning of individual subcomponents into rectangular regions of the die) looks like it was done by a human being instead of a synthesis algorithm. I'm not chip designer, but I'd expect that would be routine for the high level components of a big CPU. People can make better guesses at the gross level because they know what the design "means".
- slyn 14y agoNo offense, but you should probably read at least the sections you're commenting on. Your reasoning is pretty correct but your conclusion is opposite the truth. The full quote: "Generally, logic blocks are automagically laid out with the use of advanced computer software. However, it looks like the ARM core blocks were laid out manually—as in, by hand. A manual layout will usually result in faster processing speeds, but it is much more expensive and time consuming. The manual layout of the ARM processors lends much credence to the rumor that Apple designed a custom processor of the same caliber as the all-new Cortex-A15, and it just might be the only manual layout in a chip to hit the market in several years." (emphasis mine)
- ajross 14y agoIs "just might be" a measure of "truth"? Honestly I find that (unsourced) quote very hard to believe. There's zero manual floorplanning done on Ivy Bridge or Kepler? Really?
- slyn 14y agoI agree, the language is ambiguous as to what defines a "chip", but I assume given the context of the sentence and the technology that it is meant to be read as: the only manual layout of an ARM core to hit the market in several years. Even then "several years" is unspecific, and could mean practically anything from the iPhone classic release era (which is basically ancient history by smartphone technology years at this point) to the (not that old) iPhone 4 release era.
- Create 14y agonative Chinese processors are also laid out manually, by hand, ie. the Loongson.
- glhaynes 14y agoAny particular reason why Chinese processor makers prefer manual layout?
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoIt's interesting to note that the people designing that chip at apple used to work at PA Semi, and before that, a lot of them worked at AMD. Circa 2006 AMD decided that all it's future chips are going to be laid out automatically, and got rid off their expert chip designers who were responsible for the manual layout on the K8 (original Opteron) chips. As Apple A6 is one of the very few modern chips designed by hand, it's pretty much the latest argument by some of the best chip designers in the industry against automatic routing & layout. It will be interesting to see how it will fare against the machine-designed Cortex A15.