4 ms·
This is a brilliant strategy on Google's part. Wait until enough people are unhappy, make them really miss Google, and then release it. Suddenly, it becomes t
by jedberg 14y ago
This is a brilliant strategy on Google's part. Wait until enough people are unhappy, make them really miss Google, and then release it. Suddenly, it becomes the number 1 app in the app store and really puts egg on Apple's face.
- cryptoz 14y ago> make them really miss Google Presumably this will also lead to a number of iOS to Android converts - it's not just about making Apple look bad, it's demonstrating on a large scale that "Android is better, see?".
- untog 14y agoI wonder how far Google would go for that, though. If they released a Google Maps iPhone app they'd have advertising and immense amounts of data on people's locations, search history, etc. etc. That might be worth more to them than x% more Android users.
- ajross 14y agoI'm not sure you can call that "strategy" if a prerequisite is that your competitors customers are unhappy. :) Apple's hubris (and a not inconsiderable amount of hype by the media, no doubt related to some PR misteps by Apple) gift wrapped this for Google. All they need to do is write an app.
- danieldk 14y agoBut why would they do that? If they do release an app, Apple maps will be mostly on par someday, and Google will lose those Google Maps users. If they never release a Google Maps app, that'll make iOS a subpar platform when it comes to maps for some time, and will be an additional incentive for some people to switch to Android. It could be Google's sweet revenge to the pain that Apple inflicts on the Android ecosystem. Google probably has some patents in that area is well...
- ajross 14y agoMaybe, but recognize that that's the kind of hardball that got Apple in trouble here. Maps are just maps. A few people might switch to Android because of it, but not all that many. The real value here is marketing: "Google has the best maps" is the message the public is getting. And the bit that Apple gift-wrapped is "iPhones have bad maps, use the Google ones". You can't buy that kind of spin. In the space of a week the public perception on this issue went from "iOS is the best at everything" to "Android has better maps". It's not in Google's interests to rock that boat by picking a fight and making themselves look like the bad guy to existing iOS users.
- mbesto 14y ago> Maps are just maps. Highly disagree. Maps are not just maps. It's one of the core solutions of the platform and I would argue one of the main reasons people buy smartphones over "dumb" phones. Have you ever listened to someone complain about Blackberry's? For me, that conversation usually starts with "I can't use google maps on my Blackberry".
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoExactly. I spent $50 just for a car dock for my phone because I could then use it for nav just like my old Nuvi (only waaay better). If the maps/nav sucked I never would have done that.
- semiquaver 14y ago
- KevinEldon 14y agoYes, and while Google is waiting to release Apple is having to invest in their mapping app just to quash some of the bad PR all the while knowing that as soon as their app fixes most of the glaring defects Google can release a superior product and overshadow them. It will be interesting to see if Apple can close the gap in the places that matter.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoThe kicker would be if Google put the app into the app store for like $1.99 or something.
- steevdave 14y agoIf they did I wouldn't hesitate one second to buy it. I posted a comment on here recently about all the steps I had to go through just to try to get bus directions now with the Apple Maps app. Even if it worked the number of times I have to tap something else just to get to the directions is silly. And not well integrated at all. With google maps its just get directions, where from, where to, what type of transportation, and then the arrow button (go). With apple it's get directions, then choose bus, then where from, where to, go, wait for the App Store to open, find the routing app you've purchased in the list, tap route, hope that the app got the directions correctly from the maps app (this step I've never completed successfully). And finally get the directions. There is a serious lack of integration.
- Achshar 14y agoIt would be a fun day if that happens but it is highly unlikely. All of google products are either free or ad supported. Ads (or all the other forms of revinue) are in the DNA of maps and they are definately not going to change the whole maps platform for a paid ios version of maps. Either that or release a paid maps that also has ads, make no sense.
- hrktb 14y agoAnd users for who Apple's app work good enough just forget about google maps, and the market for mobile maps benefits from the competition. Win-win for everyone.
- mullingitover 14y agoHaving used Google Maps in android and apple's maps in iOS 6, I have to say that Apple is doing a pretty good job. The UI in android can be very frustrating (the layers metaphor can feel very clunky), and the navigation never, ever worked as well in android as it has in iOS (ymmv, of course). They certainly need to work on their POI database, but apple has made a fairly good first iteration. If Google released a maps app that is only as good as their android version I probably wouldn't bother downloading it.
- 89a 14y agoWouldn't it be a better strategy to release it straight away so Apple doesn't get to harvest as much data from users potentially making Apple Maps better? If no one uses Apple Maps then there isn't much Apple can do to compete.