4 ms·

>Will you be a little outraged though when they use real women without their consent? Probably not. AI slop doesn't really "go viral" except when it is super r

by panny 1y ago

>Will you be a little outraged though when they use real women without their consent? Probably not. AI slop doesn't really "go viral" except when it is super ridiculous like shrimp Jesus. Most people generating AI slop porn are likely in the 10s of people who will see it. If someone generates porn with my face on it and I never even know, how does this harm me? Why should I care?

rafterydj 1y ago
This seems like you are not fully thinking this through, either intentionally or not. Benefit of the doubt, I will add to your question about why you should care with more questions: what if it's someone you know? what if they want to then sell the generated content? what if it was your political enemies? what if it was your boss? what if it was someone who was stalking you or made you feel unsafe?
- panny 1y ago
  >This seems like you are not fully thinking this through, either intentionally or not. Benefit of the doubt I am not, that is why I'm leaving it to replies to convince me otherwise. >what if it's someone you know? Why not start with what if it's me? If I don't know about it, implicitly, I don't care. But if I do and it bothers me, AI companies have already been given free reign over copyright law so I don't really have any recourse here. Can I sue Sam Altman? No, because if that was possible, someone like Studio Ghibli would have done it and made a billion dollars by now. >what if they want to then sell the generated content? If it's generated by AI, then the courts have already stated it can't be copyrighted, and is therefore unsellable. The first person you sell it to can redistribute it for free and there's no way you can stop them. >what if it was your political enemies? I'm not political, which upsets a lot of people. Just tell people "I'm not voting, it doesn't matter" and watch them lose their minds. >what if it was your boss? I'm not really sure why I should be fighting my boss's battles. >what if it was someone who was stalking you or made you feel unsafe? People can stalk me without AI. I'm not sure how AI changes this.
woodruffw 1y ago
> Most people generating AI slop porn are likely in the 10s of people who will see it. If someone generates porn with my face on it and I never even know, how does this harm me? Why should I care? You would presumably care if one of those "10s of people" was a family member or peer. Maybe not caring is enlightened of you, but it shouldn't stretch your imagination to consider why others would.
- panny 1y ago
  >You would presumably care if one of those "10s of people" was a family member or peer. This is an interesting angle. Maybe someone might try to blackmail me with AI porn of me cheating on my spouse? This could also be a great usecase for divorce attorneys. But it would be easy enough to do that without AI. There's the old joke: >Once a year I send out 1000 Valentine Day cards signed "Guess Who? XOXO". >Its a cheap and easy marketing plan for my divorce attorney law group.
portaouflop 1y ago
There are dozens of scenarios where this will completely ruin your life. One example is someone generating prom of you with underage children and sending it to everyone you know -> life ruined. You can already easily do this with open source models
- GaryBluto 1y ago
  What's stopping a really fucked up person from doing this with Photoshop already?
  - portaouflop 1y ago
    It’s a lot more to do it with photoshop.
UncleMeat 1y ago
Have you been in a high school in the past two years? "Your classmates will generate AI porn of you and share it amongst your other classmates" is rampant.

by panny 1y ago

rafterydj 1y ago

This seems like you are not fully thinking this through, either intentionally or not. Benefit of the doubt, I will add to your question about why you should care with more questions: what if it's someone you know? what if they want to then sell the generated content? what if it was your political enemies? what if it was your boss? what if it was someone who was stalking you or made you feel unsafe?

panny 1y ago
>This seems like you are not fully thinking this through, either intentionally or not. Benefit of the doubt I am not, that is why I'm leaving it to replies to convince me otherwise. >what if it's someone you know? Why not start with what if it's me? If I don't know about it, implicitly, I don't care. But if I do and it bothers me, AI companies have already been given free reign over copyright law so I don't really have any recourse here. Can I sue Sam Altman? No, because if that was possible, someone like Studio Ghibli would have done it and made a billion dollars by now. >what if they want to then sell the generated content? If it's generated by AI, then the courts have already stated it can't be copyrighted, and is therefore unsellable. The first person you sell it to can redistribute it for free and there's no way you can stop them. >what if it was your political enemies? I'm not political, which upsets a lot of people. Just tell people "I'm not voting, it doesn't matter" and watch them lose their minds. >what if it was your boss? I'm not really sure why I should be fighting my boss's battles. >what if it was someone who was stalking you or made you feel unsafe? People can stalk me without AI. I'm not sure how AI changes this.

woodruffw 1y ago

> Most people generating AI slop porn are likely in the 10s of people who will see it. If someone generates porn with my face on it and I never even know, how does this harm me? Why should I care? You would presumably care if one of those "10s of people" was a family member or peer. Maybe not caring is enlightened of you, but it shouldn't stretch your imagination to consider why others would.

panny 1y ago
>You would presumably care if one of those "10s of people" was a family member or peer. This is an interesting angle. Maybe someone might try to blackmail me with AI porn of me cheating on my spouse? This could also be a great usecase for divorce attorneys. But it would be easy enough to do that without AI. There's the old joke: >Once a year I send out 1000 Valentine Day cards signed "Guess Who? XOXO". >Its a cheap and easy marketing plan for my divorce attorney law group.

portaouflop 1y ago

There are dozens of scenarios where this will completely ruin your life. One example is someone generating prom of you with underage children and sending it to everyone you know -> life ruined. You can already easily do this with open source models

GaryBluto 1y ago
What's stopping a really fucked up person from doing this with Photoshop already?
- portaouflop 1y ago
  It’s a lot more to do it with photoshop.

UncleMeat 1y ago

Have you been in a high school in the past two years? "Your classmates will generate AI porn of you and share it amongst your other classmates" is rampant.