2 ms·
Yes, Medicine is not performing as well as it could do. But it is a million times better than medicine circa 1263 AD I am reminded of the Google logo "Don't b
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
Yes, Medicine is not performing as well as it could do.
But it is a million times better than medicine circa 1263 AD
I am reminded of the Google logo "Don't be evil". I always heard that and wished that I really was living in a world where evil was defined as monopolistic business practises and bad UI, instead of rape, genocide and torture.
I respect Ben Goldacre, and I understand the need for a little hyperbole. But forcing pharma and regulators to publish all trials, and fund independant on-the-job training
will not lead to order of magnitude changes. Its an evolution not a revolution.
Some day someone will find cancer's penicillin. They will probably have been badly funded, and roundly ignored by the rest of Chinese medical establishment (!) and none of the prescriptions in Ben's book will have helped.
I would liken this to the car industry - If the world has not invented the internal combustion engine that is not something changing regulation will fix. Ensuring that after it is invented, the industry is honest, accountable and constantly pressured to improve - that is fixable.
Welcome to Nader-hood Dr Goldacre.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Some day someone will find cancer's penicillin. Quite unlikely, since "cancer" is simply a term we use for a great variety of different diseases.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI would like to claim poetic license, plus, lets face it, we labelled out of control bacterial growth as many different diseases till we had a single medicinal approach. As a tentative example, Mina Bissell's theory on micro-environment supporting cancer growth indicates a penicillin style solution would fit her category of cancer. Please don't take this as "all cancer researchers are fools looking in the wrong direction, I know better, join Scientologists" but my utterly uninformed gut reaction is that the different cancers all have such common and overlapping indicators (uncontrolled cell growth, basically) that there being multiple different root causes that all trigger the same feature seems, unlikely without other factors. We may spend a long time treating the different cancers differently according to which is most effective. But saying that such commonality does not or even cannot have a common cause seems too early. I will of course defer to anyone who knows of better (hell, any) evidence to tear down my layperson POV.
- mhax 14y ago>> But forcing pharma and regulators to publish all trials, and fund independant on-the-job training will not lead to order of magnitude changes. No, but it will allow people to make more informed decisions about what medicine they should take, and give a more realistic picture about its effectiveness. There is no justifiable reason to withhold trial data...
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI quite agree and beleive that we should have all trials published openly. I think Goldacreas book is a good salient point in a tidal change coming. I am hopeful. However my point was that the hyperbole was a little too much - Goldacre has a difficult tightrope to walk - to stir people up enough that he (sells books and) convinces them action is necessary, and yet does not actually go over the top and accuse a generally beneficial-to-society pharma industry of being one step above arms dealers. I think he will pull it off and look forward to putting it on my Xmas reading list.