3 ms·
Indian here, One of my uncle is a nephrologist in the US. He recently came to India for a vacation and my talks with him were all about these issues. About how
by kamaal 14y ago
Indian here,
One of my uncle is a nephrologist in the US. He recently came to India for a vacation and my talks with him were all about these issues. About how doctors work, their protocols, procedures and ethics etc and things like that. From what I could decipher doctors are not super humans how have miracle cures for every disease to exist on earth. What doctors are generally taught in medical school is to first learn about healthy bodies so that they can later to distinguish between a healthy and unhealthy body. Then they are taught pathology, stuff like dissecting dead humans and learning their internals. And then there are things like anatomy, metabolism, physiology etc. After all this they then go on to diseases and their cures.
In an ordinary medical school course. With all that heavy syllabus the actual disease-cure part is taught in a no more procedure than if-then-else decision tree scenarios. Its something like this, Imagine you are taught 100 different symptoms for fever. Combination of all those 100 scenarios in 'OR' and 'AND' conditions lead to various conditions of fever with various diseases. That's what we are talking about here. Imagine you having to remember all this, will it really possible? May be for an year or two but with time that sort of knowledge erodes quickly.
On top of this they are taught nothing much about the root cause of these diseases. Their cures. Are they addressing the root causes or just managing symptoms.
When they go on to their MD. Then comes little special training and details with investigation, practice and learning about a specific organ/part of the body. This is still understandable.
But in general most doctors work like a software cache. The diseases and cures they pull out are the ones cached with the recent patients they are treating.
So yes in general most doctors really work only like decision trees at the most abstract levels. Most don't have people skills, most just don't listen to patients completely. Its all working at the most abstract levels with guess work at times.
The break through stuff happening in medical science is not your physicians clinic. Its in things like vaccinations, surgical sciences, diagnosis and stuff like that.