5 ms·
The arguments in this thread are amusing to say at the least. 30 minute charging times, high prices of Tesla cars. Yes all that is true. But this was never abou
by kamaal 14y ago
The arguments in this thread are amusing to say at the least. 30 minute charging times, high prices of Tesla cars. Yes all that is true. But this was never about 'Electric cars are awesome now'.
I'm pretty sure cars during and before pre Henry Ford times were not very great in terms of their overall affordability, total cost of ownership and availability of fuel all around the country. You could trust your horse to drive you back home on any day more than a car. Similar to that, the IBM computers during their early days. You mobile phone is likely to have more computing power than all the computers IBM sold a few decades back, they were highly painful to use, maintain and use. Needless to say all these things had huge maintenance issues.
But these things have caught on. So have automation, productivity and so many other new things that eventually people show friction towards but later take them to be fate accompli and learn to move forward.
Electric cars, self driving cars, wearable computing(like Google glasses) well these really might look to be unfeasible at this time. But please, these are just ideas which are waiting for their time to come, with a little push they will eventually catch on.
- justincormack 14y agoElectric cars are 100 years old and have not improved much, bizarrely http://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2010/05/the-status-quo-of-electric-cars-better-batteries-same-range.html http://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2010/05/the-status-quo-of-ele...
- kamaal 14y agoWell mechanical engines were there from a couple of centuries in fact. The steam engine was invented a ton lot of years before fuel driven cars caught on.
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoElectric cars have improved immensely. - Better battery performance and lifespan. - Improved charging time and technology. - Distance cars can travel in a single charge. - Increased torque and horsepower. - Affordability and increases is mass production. And most importantly, increases in the necessary infrastructure to support long-distance travel (exactly the topic at hand) Your comment is very uninformed.
- sien 14y agoDid you read his link? The point the guy makes is completely correct. Let's say tomorrow some grad student gets fusion going at a very low price. The best way to use this to power cars would be to use it to create a fuel with a high energy density. If you had 'free energy' you'd extract C02 from the atmosphere and turn it into a hydrocarbon. For more info look at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density and this interview with Nobel Prize winning Physicist Robert Laughlin http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2010/08/laughlin_on_the.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2010/08/laughlin_on_the.htm... the key quote is: "The ones that are technically trained get it right away: hydrocarbons, which we burned today have the greatest energy density possible of all fuels. Things that have carbon in them. Will people fly airplanes? Usually people say yes for the same reasons. Well, how are you going to make the airplanes fly? Battery. Batteries are pretty heavy. Oh--you can't have airplanes unless you have hydrocarbon fuels. You could in theory do it with hydrogen, but it's highly dangerous, noxious fuel. Quantum-mechanically, we know the energy content of those fuels is optimal. There will never be anything that beats them." A massive breakthrough in energy density for batteries might be possible but it's unlikely. Huge resources have been put into improving batteries and while they have improved it's not been enough to get near the energy density of hydrocarbons.
- kamaal 14y ago>>Well, how are you going to make the airplanes fly? Battery. Batteries are pretty heavy. "Heavier than air flying machines are impossible" -Lord Kevin. Yet we have them today, thanks to a phenomenon in physics called Bernoulli's principle- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernoulli%27s_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernoulli%27s_principle "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them" - Albert Einstein. Why, O why do we think that problems have to, must be and will be solved at the same level and direction of thought the problems were framed in? Besides the whole point of a disruptive technology is that the solutions generally come as a bolt from the blue, completely surprising even the biggest experts in those areas. Directions from which those solutions come from are so radically different paths than originally they would come from. And this has not happened once, twice but many times. Over confidence in science especially with regards to the negative aspects is not a good direction to begin with.
- Retric 14y agoThey have twice the range, are more than twice as fast, charge in 1/10th the time, AC, power steering, etc. But, yea then again by your estimation internal combustion cars have not improved either as they still use fire.
- aidenn0 14y agoHmm The lowest end Model S vs. Fritchle Victoria Phaeton * Similar cost, adjusted for inflation (49k vs 48k) * 1.6x range compared to Fritchle (160mi vs 100) * At more than 2x the speed (25max vs 55(speed for quoted range)) * With climate control
- mtgx 14y agoThis is obviously a very "disruptive" technology and/or business model, from every point of view, both positive and negative. Just think about how all disruptive innovations come to be. They are awesome and game-changing from a certain point of view (free charging/"gas"!) but can also have some big downsides (30 minute charging, only half a charge - at first). But the part you should be focusing on is the first one, the positive one. Because that will change everything and to some people, the second part, the negative one, will be irrelevant just long enough for Tesla to work on improving it and years later making it "good enough" for most people. Remember how the iPhone was awesome at user interface and interaction? But sucked at battery life (compared to other smartphones), had only a 2 MP camera, no video recording, only 2G connection and no MMS? That may not have been good enough for 90% of Nokia or Blackberry users back then, but the iPhone is good enough for almost everyone today, and the iPhone changed the entire industry. That's how disruptive innovations work, and I believe that's exactly how Tesla's new model will work. Also, do you know how everyone says I wish I would've bought Apple stock when the iPhone first appeared? Well, if I was into stock, I'd probably start buying Tesla stock just about now.
- loceng 14y agoThe positives are enough of an incentive to have people change their behaviours in order to compensate for the 'negatives' of using such technology. If you know you'll have 30 minutes minimum to kill then you'll plan for it. Lunch time, work time, walk around a park time, meetup and chat with other people who are waiting time, walk your dog time, mini-yoga class time, etc.. Throw in self-driving cars into the mix and the break activities will likely be more social and physical things, and less high mental activity time - unless you're a workaholic.
- Swizec 14y agoFrom what I understand 30 minute charging is amazing. To paraphrase Richard Hammond: "Forgetting something at home when I go to work would be a 2 day round-trip because it's so far no electric car has the range. I would have to spend one night recharging the car somewhere in the middle" His problem has just been solved. Sure, it might take him 3.5 hours (random number) instead of just 3. But that's insanely better than having to stay the night to recharge your car.
- jaggederest 14y agoHonestly, electric cars are never going to be completely practical for people with a daily commute beyond 150 miles or so. But if you're commuting 3 hours a day total, you have bigger issues with your life, to be honest. Move closer to where you commute!
- madisp 14y agoI'd say a 150+ mile daily commute isn't practical :)
- SudarshanP 14y agoMaybe with the hyperloop even 150 miles will be "nearby" someday. See http://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musks-hyper-loop-2012-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musks-hyper-loop-2012-9
- adriand 14y agoFrankly, if I can't get there in less than 1/2 an hour on my bicycle, I don't think I'm interested.
- freehunter 14y agoTry doing that in the midwest. Finding jobs gets hard and apartments are rare and low quality, so it's not uncommon to have to settle on a 20 minute (or much more) commute by car on the freeway. There are also no bike lanes. Commuting long distances isn't great, but moving more people into the city isn't always the best option either. We learned that in the 1900's
- stcredzero 14y ago> friction towards but later take them to be fate accompli Two malapropisms in a row, or an iOS autocorrect?