5 ms·
Not understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science. The issue you see isn't merely that they don't understand evolution, b
by jlgreco 14y ago
Not understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science. The issue you see isn't merely that they don't understand evolution, but that the people preventing them from being exposed to it are also teaching them to be opposed to it.
The style of "creationism" in America that is seen as the opposition of evolution (versions of creationism that appear compatible with evolution exist. See: the RCC) is not defined merely by the absence of evolution but also by it's warped and twisted "versions" of it (strawmen) and often some healthy dose of conspiracy theory (evil scientist conspiracies).
This basically 'immunizes' children against what would normally be a trivial education in evolution. I say this from personal experience. In retrospect evolution is embarrassingly simple and obvious, but it took years for it to truly sink in for me. A quick 10 minute youtube video can explain it great, but once a certain degree of damage has been done it can suddenly take a lot more.
- anamax 14y ago> Not understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science. Large in what way? How much of physics depends on evolution? How about chemistry? How about materials science? I can go on and on. In fact, much of biology doesn't depend on evolution. (Who do you think did all the work on selective breeding pre-darwin?) I don't know Knuth's views on evolution, but he is Christian. Can you tell me if he believes in evolution? As someone else pointed out in this thread, evolution is being used as a tribal signal. And no, believers in evolution are NOT more rational.
- jlgreco 14y agoBiology is large, and you cannot seriously study modern biology if you flat out deny evolution. Suggestions to the contrary are simply absurd. Knuth is Lutheran iirc, he could fall either way, I don't know which. Lutherans are a coin flip.
- anamax 14y ago> Biology is large, and you cannot seriously study modern biology if you flat out deny evolution. Suggestions to the contrary are simply absurd. If that was true, we could identify the intelligent design people by their scientific output. Instead, we find that evolutionists have to look at other evidence to purge them from the ranks of scientists. Evolution is a big deal so how about using valid arguments? > Knuth is Lutheran iirc, he could fall either way, I don't know which. The claim was that creationists can't do any valid science. If you can't look at Knuth's "work product" and tell us whether he's a creationist, the claim is clerly false. I agree that creationists can't do some types of science, but the actual instances are fairly small.
- hermannj314 14y agoEvolution as a conceptual framework for understanding how complexity can emerge from simple feedback is relevant to many branches of science, including computer science. Maybe I am really stretching, but if evolution wasn't real, then many machine learning algorithms wouldn't work.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoAs a "science evangelist", you are really stretching. If you make arguments like that, you merely make it easier for others to dismiss you.
- anamax 14y ago> Maybe I am really stretching, but if evolution wasn't real, then many machine learning algorithms wouldn't work. You're really stretching. No one denies selective breeding. The evolution claim is much stronger, and isn't necessary for machine learning. Why would you make such an absurd claim?
- hermannj314 14y agoEvolutionary processes present themselves everywhere from political systems, social organization, genetic algorithms in computer science. If evolution doesn't exist, then why do we constantly see processes evolve based on a feedback cycle of constant experimentation, survival, failure, etc. Isn't that word evolution? Is there another word I am supposed to use? So I stand by what I said, if evolution isn't real (i.e. evolution doesn't happen) that all things are complex by-design, and never by uncontrolled processes of iteration and survival, if that is true, then evolutionary algorithms wouldn't work. Is that really absurd? What am I not getting?
- anamax 14y ago> If evolution doesn't exist, then why do we constantly see processes evolve based on a feedback cycle of constant experimentation, survival, failure, etc. > Isn't that word evolution? No. As I wrote, evolution is a stronger claim. Evolution involves feedback but not all feedback is evolution. Many stable amplifier designs use feedback. Would you claim that the signal being amplified is evolving? As to man-made entities, yes, their designs are affected by feedback. However, they're also created. As I said, creationists believe in selective breeding. Their argument wrt evolution is wrt something else, so if you don't understand that.... > So I stand by what I said, if evolution isn't real (i.e. evolution doesn't happen) that all things are complex by-design, and never by uncontrolled processes of iteration and survival, if that is true, then evolutionary algorithms wouldn't work. You do know that you didn't say that above, right? However, I'll play along. Your new claim is wrong because algorithms with feedback can work even if evolution doesn't occur in the wild. As to your suggestion that evolution is involved in every complex system, I'll ask how stars evolved. They're very complex systems. There are lots of complex systems. Evolution only applies to the biological ones.
- derleth 14y agoLarge in that evolution describes how complex systems can exist without a creator. This ties back to how we can explain how the universe functions without needing to invoke a deity keeping the gears turning; in short, evolution means life works based on the same physical laws rocks and stars do. And that ties back to what science does: Provides explanations with predictive power, as opposed to explanations like "The gods willed it" that provide no predictive power. If life works on the same laws as all other matter, and we have predictive models for matter in general, then we can better predict what living beings will do and how the world will affect them. That does, in fact, turn out to be the case.
- jlgreco 14y agoI am reminded of the apocryphal exchange between Napoleon Bonaparte and Pierre-Simon Laplace: Napoleon: M. Laplace, they tell me you have written this large book on the system of the universe, and have never even mentioned its Creator. Laplace: I had no need of that hypothesis.
- anamax 14y ago> Large in that evolution describes how complex systems can exist without a creator. Unless you're claiming that evolution is the only explanation for complex systems, that's not enough. And if you are, I'll ask where I can see animals with wheels for locomotion and animals that use internal combustion. I believe in evolution, but most arguments offered by evolutionists against creationism are crap.
- derleth 14y ago> Unless you're claiming that evolution is the only explanation for complex systems, that's not enough. You misunderstand me totally. > I believe in evolution, but most arguments offered by evolutionists against creationism are crap. Except for the part where evolution has all the evidence on its side, right?
- anamax 14y ago
- Alex3917 14y ago"Not understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science." The government, in their National Assessment of Adult Literacy, used to measure up to 'advanced literacy', which was roughly the level you would need to be able to read a scientific journal article. Such a small percentage of adults were able to read at this level (less than 3%) that they dropped it entirely, and now the literacy assessment scale only goes up to 'proficient'. This is the level of literacy you would need to compare and contrast two newspaper editorials, which are generally written at around an 8th grade reading level. 96% of high school graduates are unable to do this. If you're worried about not understanding evolution locking students out of science then I would suggest that your concerns, while noble, are about 95% misplaced.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think we can tackle more than one problem at once. Anti-science styled creationism concerns me because even very bright people are susceptible. Read about Kurt Wise for a very sad but great example of this. Of course getting students to read is also immensely important. If I thought efforts to teach evolution were hampering efforts to improve literacy, then I would immediately deprioritize evolution... but I do not. <cheeky-mode> Perhaps we can hit two birds with one stone though, and encourage people to read the bible.</cheeky-mode>
- Alex3917 14y ago"I think we can tackle more than one problem at once." Our track record on education, which basically shows that we're capable of tackling zero problems at once, suggests otherwise. Again, my argument isn't that we shouldn't put any effort into defending the teaching of evolution. I'm just pointing out that empirically there is a lot more effort being put into this than is being put into other areas that are demonstrably more important.
- jlgreco 14y agoIs there really effort being put into evolution education? In my experience public education only dedicates a quarter of one year of one class to it. My single required biology class in primary school was 50% "name the parts of the cell/plant/body", 25% "here is how you use a microscope", and 25% Mendel/Darwin history lessons. And I think that is being generous. Most of the real effort is in fighting school districts in court for trying to outright teach creationism (Such as at Dover, the school-district next to mine that made national news with their anti-science antics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitzmiller_v._Dover_Area_School_District http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitzmiller_v._Dover_Area_School...), and in minor science celebrities writing a few books and making a few youtube videos. Easing off evolution to work on literacy is like easing off NASA to work on world hunger. Find the players that are actually consuming the bulk of the resources.