6 ms·
I've never understood why out of all the things broken in the US and in education specifically people get so worked up over this one issue. Evolution is one of
by Alex3917 14y ago
I've never understood why out of all the things broken in the US and in education specifically people get so worked up over this one issue. Evolution is one of the easiest concepts to understand in all of science. Literally all it takes is a ten minute YouTube video to explain it to a fourth grader.
As such, while clearly evolution should be taught in schools, I fail to see how students are significantly harmed if it isn't. The fact that these kids come communities where most of the parents are really dumb has to be hundreds of times more damaging than not getting a day or two worth of lecture.
(And as an aside, I would bet money that the percentage of religious folks who have a good understanding of the main arguments in favor of evolution is about 10x as high as the percentage of 'science-oriented' folks who have a good understanding of all the philosophical concepts referenced in the wiki article on intelligent design.)
- pat2man 14y agoClaiming that evolution is wrong implies that all science is wrong. If you don't teach the basic scientific principles to young students it gets harder and harder to convince them of more complicated topics. You get into a science vs religion debate where no one wins and the students always loose.
- PakG1 14y agoWhoah, whoah, whoah. Newtonian physics can be easily explained and understood without knowing anything about evolution. The same for basic chemical reactions. The same for mitochondria. And the same for various more complicated topics. Let's not debate the debate well, but let's not get hyperbolic.
- derleth 14y ago> Newtonian physics can be easily explained and understood without knowing anything about evolution. As a set of equations handed down from On High, yes. As a living field that's part of modern physics and has relevance to becoming a productive member of the society we're trying to build, no. Science isn't dogma. It's all connected by the spirit of questioning and challenging authority.
- stephenhuey 14y agoYou can say science isn't dogma, but it has real people playing the part of the scientists, and those real people often sound as biased as you just did. In other words, everyone doing the science sees the world through their own lenses and you just have to try as hard as possible to observe and analyze objectively.
- derleth 14y agoAt least with science there's a chance to be undogmatic.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think perhaps what he means to imply is that the mental gymnastics necessary to deny evolution also, if taken to their logical conclusion and not kept contained to biology, take out pretty much all of physics and chemistry as well. This said, people in the business of denying evolution are pretty good at containment. It is far from unheard of for people to live "dual lives". There are no rules forcing people to keep their own beliefs self-consistent.
- Alex3917 14y ago"If you don't teach the basic scientific principles to young students it gets harder and harder to convince them of more complicated topics." First of all, the vast majority of US students aren't even proficient enough in reading and math to understand science regardless of what the curriculum consists of. Debating what the science curriculum should consist of is like rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic. But the fact that you hear 10x as much about this issue than about the shameful lack of reading ability in students suggests that this debate is as much about ideology as it is about pedagogy. That was kind of my point. Yes, it's important, but the fact that people are spending so much time worrying about optimizing something that's largely irrelevant in the grand scheme of things says a lot about them.
- jlgreco 14y agoNot understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science. The issue you see isn't merely that they don't understand evolution, but that the people preventing them from being exposed to it are also teaching them to be opposed to it. The style of "creationism" in America that is seen as the opposition of evolution (versions of creationism that appear compatible with evolution exist. See: the RCC) is not defined merely by the absence of evolution but also by it's warped and twisted "versions" of it (strawmen) and often some healthy dose of conspiracy theory (evil scientist conspiracies). This basically 'immunizes' children against what would normally be a trivial education in evolution. I say this from personal experience. In retrospect evolution is embarrassingly simple and obvious, but it took years for it to truly sink in for me. A quick 10 minute youtube video can explain it great, but once a certain degree of damage has been done it can suddenly take a lot more.
- anamax 14y ago> Not understanding Evolution effectively locks students out from large swaths of science. Large in what way? How much of physics depends on evolution? How about chemistry? How about materials science? I can go on and on. In fact, much of biology doesn't depend on evolution. (Who do you think did all the work on selective breeding pre-darwin?) I don't know Knuth's views on evolution, but he is Christian. Can you tell me if he believes in evolution? As someone else pointed out in this thread, evolution is being used as a tribal signal. And no, believers in evolution are NOT more rational.
- jlgreco 14y agoBiology is large, and you cannot seriously study modern biology if you flat out deny evolution. Suggestions to the contrary are simply absurd. Knuth is Lutheran iirc, he could fall either way, I don't know which. Lutherans are a coin flip.
- anamax 14y ago> Biology is large, and you cannot seriously study modern biology if you flat out deny evolution. Suggestions to the contrary are simply absurd. If that was true, we could identify the intelligent design people by their scientific output. Instead, we find that evolutionists have to look at other evidence to purge them from the ranks of scientists. Evolution is a big deal so how about using valid arguments? > Knuth is Lutheran iirc, he could fall either way, I don't know which. The claim was that creationists can't do any valid science. If you can't look at Knuth's "work product" and tell us whether he's a creationist, the claim is clerly false. I agree that creationists can't do some types of science, but the actual instances are fairly small.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI was going to respond, but this video highlights the issue better: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9QBv2CFTSWU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9QBv2CFTSWU
- derleth 14y ago> Literally all it takes is a ten minute YouTube video to explain ... and the destruction of a lot of carefully-laid religious indoctrination that claims Humans Are Special and therefore could not possibly be related to animals and plants. That's it, really: Being able to teach evolution means being able to directly contradict religious dogma. Conversely, if you can't teach evolution, you are hamstrung because you cannot contradict religious dogma on any subject. So winning the ability to teach evolution will be a victory against religion's hold on education, and religious groups obviously do not want to relinquish that hold. Hence the battle. > The fact that these kids come communities where most of the parents are really dumb has to be hundreds of times more damaging than not getting a day or two worth of lecture. We're, as a society, unable to make these kids parents not be dumb, or to give kids new parents who are not dumb. The most we can do is educate them. > I would bet money that the percentage of born again Christians who have a good understanding of the arguments in favor of evolution is about 10x as high as the percentage of 'science-oriented' folks who have a good understanding of all the philosophical concepts referenced in the wiki article on intelligent design. This is because the philosophical arguments in favor of ID are not relevant to anyone who isn't in a religious group that favors ID. Also, I personally doubt most born-again Christians have any real idea of what the evidence in favor of evolution is, given how popular the "If apes turned into man why are there still apes?" argument is.
- maqr 14y ago> The fact that these kids come communities where most of the parents are really dumb has to be hundreds of times more damaging than not getting a day or two worth of lecture. I think that's what the debate is actually about. The thing that needs to be "taught" isn't really evolution, it's that their parents/teachers/pastors/authorities can have very basic facts about the world very wrong, and as such kids should learn to think independently. This is why things like evolution and climate change are so threatening. What's always confused me is that it seems like it would be a lot easier to change religious beliefs to be consistent with facts, instead of the other way around. I don't understand why people are choosing to fight evolution rather than just doing the usual hand-waving magic to explain what science told us, but with a bit of gods and fairies mixed in.
- mbell 14y agoEvolution vs Creationism is just a symptom of a deeper issue. It just happens to be the most easily and directly attackable symptom which is why it gets the most attention. The underlying issue (religious fundamentalism that rejects science) is far scarier and leads to crap like this: http://articles.nydailynews.com/2012-09-19/news/33957266_1_medical-care-faith-safety-plan http://articles.nydailynews.com/2012-09-19/news/33957266_1_m...
- sbochins 14y agoBasically all of modern biology is based on evolution. If you don't understand or believe in evolution, then you don't understand biology. I don't think it's ok for kids not to have a basic science education. Additionally, you draw a false equivalence between intelligent design and evolution. Evolution is a scientific theory and intelligent design is a philosophy, usually pushed by religious people.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoIt is precisely because evolution is such an easy concept to teach and understand that it is so troubling that there is this huge effort to not teach it. Let us step back for just a moment from the pinhole view of this one subject and realize that the primary job of educators is to teach students how to think. If a student is shown pictures (or, better yet, up-close-and-personal on a field trip!) of geological strata, and shown how the processes work that formed those features, and then they are given a counter-argument by other authority figures that everything that they've seen there is wrong because faith says so, what is that doing to those students' ability to reason? Do you not think that a widespread disregard for the easy-to-understand concept of evolution would also spill over into a widespread disregard for other fields of study? Creationism is the color guard of anti-intellectualism; shame on anyone who would try to rationally argue that we should not run it out of our educational institutions with the broadswords of critical thinking and rational curiosity. [1] Do you think that people who grow up believing that a religious book written nearly 3,000 years ago is more informative on the topic of natural sciences than all of the scientific efforts since will really have any opportunity in the world's science & technology arena? I don't. Why should we not argue instead in favor of the principles of enlightenment? In the late 1600s, in an effort to defend its religion, the Scottish Kirk established schools around the country that would teach anybody -- no matter their social standing -- the basics of reading and writing. What followed soon after was a period of industrial and technological and economic development in Scotland that rivals any other enlightenment period in Europe. It takes a remarkable ignorance of human history to argue against education. If you want to change the communities that these kids come from, you have to teach them how to do it. And that includes teaching them evolution, and making sure that they understand why creationism is bad thinking. [1]: Nothing personal; I'm not attacking you specifically here, but it is frustrating to see so many "what's the big deal?" comments -- this is precisely the sort of intellectual atmosphere created when 46% of the population rejects basic scientific principles.