5 ms·
OpenMaxIO: Forked UI for MinIO Object Storage
- stronglikedan 1y agoI feel sorry for the OMIO maintainer community considering how entitled the MinIO community revealed themselves to be.
- Spivak 1y agoStep 1: I made this thing and am freely giving it away for the benefit of everyone. Come join the party! Step 2: Wow, because this is a community project I can depend on it continuing to exist freely thanks to a large base of diverse parties invested in its continued growth and availability. Step 3: Just kidding, I'm taking back the thing I made. Sorry if you were depending on it, migrate to something else or pay me. Step 4: WTF dude?! Step 5: Why are you all so entitled?
- michaelgiba 1y agoThey stopped publishing images, not like they changed anything significant about the product itself. Frankly the whole thing is not newsworthy
- JokerDan 1y ago> not like they changed anything significant about the product itself They had already done this months ago, they changed the licence and stripped a lot of the code of their admin UI/object browser. So a lot of the features vanished for people overnight if they updated. This is what the OP is linked to - a fork at the point that they did this. This was work already done, feature already widely in use, they decided to take it out of what was available to the community. So the product has significantly changed and offering had been reduced. That in addition to the stopping of publishing images - both without notice - caused a decent bit off community 'wtf'.
- 0x457 1y agohttps://github.com/minio/object-browser/issues/3546 https://github.com/minio/object-browser/issues/3546
- ianbutler 1y agoWhat is so hard about the idea that you are not perpetually entitled to the free labor of other people? The only thing they owed people here was a 60 day notice imo. That would better respect the social contract.
- Spivak 1y agoI'm not. If they had simply said, "Hey this is getting to be too much work and I don't want to continue anymore. Let me know if you're interested in taking over maintainership of the project." then that's fine. Hell even if they just archived the project and ghosted never to be seen again that's also fine. It's (yet another) example of a company donning the trappings of an open source project as a "growth hack" or to secure VC funding and then rug pulling when they decide they want to try and squeeze their user base for cash. They're the corporate stooges that insert themselves into high-trust communities and subcultures to make a buck and ruin it for everyone.
- ianbutler 1y agoI mean is it though? They've been open source for over a decade thats a really long con I guess. It’s more likely circumstances have changed. Which is why forking is a thing and you dont have to be oss forever. I stand by my assertion that this would have been fine if they didn’t communicate like garbage. They should have said what you said and gave a good off ramp period.
- ekjhgkejhgk 1y agoI agree with you. But people are allowed to complain, so they're complaining. And the maintainers are allowed to ignore the complaining. Everything is according to the process.
- ianbutler 1y agoYeah I suppose you’re right
- evilduck 1y ago
- binarymax 1y agoHey I know picking names is hard, but this is the first time I've ever been on the other end of a collision like this.
- ekjhgkejhgk 1y agoWhy "open". The point here is freedom. You're going to give RMS an ulcer poor fellow.
- bdcravens 1y agoI'll take it over "libre"
- ekjhgkejhgk 1y agoYeah I hate libre too, but wouldn't FreeMaxIO be better?
- PedroBatista 1y agoWhat's up with the naming of rage forked projects? OpenMaxIO, Forgejo, Valkey, OpenTofu.. Some worse than the others, but still.. Btw, MinIO making these not "open open-source" moves should not be a surprise. Since the beginning, YEARS ago their own CEO, lead people talked in a way it was clear they wanted to follow the Hashicorp book, a few years later they've taken quite a few hundreds of millions in investment. So let's not be childish, adopt it for what it is and when it happens adapt it for what it is.
- mholt 1y agoWait'll you hear about: - https://github.com/WedgeServer/wedge https://github.com/WedgeServer/wedge - https://github.com/tmpim/casket https://github.com/tmpim/casket Both forks of Caddy...
- snug 1y agoI don't get your point about naming. What would you have them named? OpenMaxIO seems different than any of the other ones you listed. They wouldn't have been able to name it OpenMinIO without some legal problems.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nunez 1y agoOpenTofu is a "best of a bad situation" kind of thing. The project was originally called OpenTF, which makes sense since Terraform config code almost always ends in `.tf`, but HashiCorp sent out the lawyers, so they had to change names. Plus, it goes well with OpenBao, their Vault fork.
- dang 1y ago[stub for offtopicness] (submitted title was "OpenMaxIO is a community-maintained fork of MinIO"; we've replaced it with what the article says, per https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html)
- parliament32 1y ago> forked from minio/object-browser > This is a fork of MinIO Console. > JavaScript 75.2% It seems this is just a community-maintained fork of the minio UI, not minio itself.
- sprior 1y agoLooks like it's a clone of the browser UI, not the MinIO server (like I was expecting any minute now based on their recent news).
- bananadonkey 1y agoIsn't this just the UI and not the minio storage server itself? Title is misleading if so
- sreekanth850 1y agoThis is not minio. Its minio UI.
- 0xC0ncord 1y ago"Community-maintained" is quite a stretch considering the repository has had no activity since the fork and name change.
- pxc 1y agoThis hitting the front page made me do a web search review what's going on with MinIO, and... turns out it's still 100% F/OSS, released under the AGPLv3. This is absolutely not comparable to something like OpenTofu, OpenBao, Forgejo, etc. (I guess it's more like recent CentOS forks, like AlmaLinux and Rocky Linux, or whatever.) Personally, I think supporting it would be regrettable. MinIO is fine.
- mastax 1y agoMinIO has gotten rid of the admin UI from the OSS version and is erasing documentation. Even if they stop here that's enough to need a community fork, but I don't expect them to stop here. Their obvious intent is for the OSS version to only be useful as a trial version of the commercial paid product.
- avoutic 1y agoMinIO gutted the UI recently. Actually fully removed it from the codebase. So you either have to stick to a vulnerable version or have no een UI. This form seems to target just that. So for the UI kinda similar actually.
- max-privatevoid 1y agoMinIO has a CLA, so they're in the exact same situation as HashiCorp, just not as far ahead.
- dang 1y agoRecent and related: MinIO stops distributing free Docker images - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45665452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45665452 - Oct 2025 (499 comments)
- mbreese 1y agoI'm not entirely sure how their commercial offering works. It looks like it's a commercial fork of MinIO, but I wasn't able to find anything about assigning copyright for pull requests in their Github. (I didn't look that hard). But, if the main product is 100% F/OSS AGPL, how are they accepting code from outside contributors and still maintaining a private enterprise offering under (presumably) a different license?
- yencabulator 1y agoYou assume competence. Minio originally tried to argue AGPL infects client code over the network. Just let the company fade away..
- kevinastone 1y agoThis was in response to MinIO/AIStor removing the browser-console UI from the community offering (locking it behind enterprise licensing) a few months back. Unfortunately, this fork has not developed any traction. It's last commit was 4 months ago basically after the initial fork and instantly became dormant. You can see the list of 'Still alive?' issues: https://github.com/OpenMaxIO/openmaxio-object-browser/issues/29 https://github.com/OpenMaxIO/openmaxio-object-browser/issues...
- tempaccount420 1y agoThat's usually what happens to these type of forks.