4 ms·
Is It Time to Regulate React?
- reconnecting 1y agoI don't care who uses React, because when such websites don't run properly on my browser, I just close the tab. What really needs to be regulated are technologies that the government can use for its own digital services
- random3 1y agoDiagonally reading it seems like a rant with some lack of inspiration on the title. Had the author seen other frameworks (maybe not just web, public, etc) they’d realize none of those are React specific. No framework is perfect, but the diversity of capabilities combined with uneven (and lack of) skills can have these consequences.
- rk06 1y agoIs it time to regulate React? No, and it will never be. Is it time to regulate customer facing websites that are slow and suffer from accessibility issues? Isn't google search already doing it? Even if i were to agree to regulation, I don't think govt is the right entity to do the regulatuon
- ZvG_Bonjwa 1y agoThe negativity oozing out of this article undermines the main points (of which there’s some good ones). Belittling and admonishing an entire cohort of your peers because they like a tech you don’t is not helpful. I think React has some fundamental API issues (Solid/Svelte are better) and there’s way too many petabytes of JS out there for sure. But it pioneered some great concepts, and its ecosystem is robust. Building complex interactive web apps without a framework is still a disaster in 2025. React and friends are not going anywhere until that changes.
- 0x6c6f6c 1y agoIt definitely would be interesting to have proposed alternatives and even examples included as part of this piece.
- shermantanktop 1y agoNothing popular is clean, pure, efficient and self-consistent. The mere fact of popularity means that it will be misused, misrepresented, and influenced to include a kitchen sink of enablers for use cases that should really be solved another way. That’s life at the top of the charts, and pointing that out is no act of genius.
- jobs_throwaway 1y ago> wahwahwahwah
- almosthere 1y agoPeople complained for YEARS that FE development was changing every 4 months. Now it doesn't. win win.
- tanseydavid 1y ago>> Now it doesn't. Really? Serious question.
- flufluflufluffy 1y agoI never understand the whole “react websites are laggy and slow use another library” thing. 99% of the websites built using React I’ve used (and every website I’ve built using React myself) have been fine performance-wise. What are all these laggy vibe coded websites people are using?! And why are you using them lol
- beardbound 1y agoI don't have much of an opinion on React as a library, although they do use it for our web frontend at my work. However something I noticed in the past when I was doing some web dev work out of AUS was that some websites would have incredibly buggy behavior. Keep in mind this was around 10 years ago so some things might have changed. After doing some debugging it turned out that some of the libraries were fairly large, and they didn't have co-located CDN's in the area. The specific ones in that were jQuery. That caused some of the JS libraries to not fully download, or just some of them to time out. That's a mostly fixable problem with having something like a pipeline that minifies the libraries and has them being downloaded from somewhere closer to your users, or putting them on a better CDN, but a lot of people don't have the time/option/money to do that. It was pretty obvious in that instance since a lot of that was wordpress development at the time and things like plugins/extensions usually don't bother. When I was doing similar development in the US I never saw any of that kind of behavior since so many libraries at the time were hosted on the West Coast where I lived. Also most developers I know aren't super resource limited on their hardware (desktop/laptop or mobile), which might be a factor. I'm not sure if this is what people are referring to, but just something to consider.
- flufluflufluffy 1y agoThat’s a good point. I guess I am privileged to live in a well connected area in the states.
- reconnecting 1y agoOne example: once I tried to buy a train ticket and it was impossible due to my outdated iOS. I'm talking about 2-5 input forms, autocomplete, and calendars, things that can be done even with HTML 4.0, with zero front-end frameworks, and that will work this way for decades. However, there was React producing some error because of my old browser, and preventing me from buying the ticket. I believe vital services, such as public digital platforms, must have the lowest possible system/browser requirements and work on any possible device, even if I use a 10-year-old device.
- mediumsmart 1y agoI like the article and agree with it. I am confident those rocket scientists will eventually do the right thing and build real websites after trying everything else. No need to regulate.
- mortsnort 1y agoApparently learning HTML and CSS is how one becomes a real "web developer".
- sundbry 1y agoyes
- the_oh_of_ples 1y agoYes
- rhapsodic 1y ago[dead]
- terminatornet 1y agoReact should not be regulated, it should be banned outright.