5 ms·
I keep telling folks that Proton was a mistake and SteamDeck will suffer the same fate as netbooks. FOSS folks don't get that the gammer culture does not overl
by pjmlp 1y ago
I keep telling folks that Proton was a mistake and SteamDeck will suffer the same fate as netbooks.
FOSS folks don't get that the gammer culture does not overlap with FOSS, everyone is cool with NDAs and IP, it is all about the experience in that realm.
The call to migrate in droves to Linux has been happening since a unpopular Windows version comes out, since Windows XP, and still Valve had to come up with Proton, as even the game studios targeting Android/Linux with the NDK don't care about GNU/Linux.
XBox console is in a mess currently, however lets not forget XBox the business unit is part of Microsoft Games Studios, and Microsoft is one of the major publishers due to the amount of game studios that they own, beyond XBox.
- d3Xt3r 1y agoI hear you, but at the same time, you can't deny the amount of improvements the Linux ecosystem has seen due to Valve's involvement: tons of AMD-related improvements in the kernel, tons of mesa/radeon improvements, massive improvements in KDE, improvements to Arch etc. Not to mention lots of other contributors riding the wave and contributing things like drivers for gamepads and other bits, making power user tools like LACT/OCCT etc. Linux hardware compatibility has never been as good, and I suspect a lot of it is due to so many gamers trying Linux on a myriad of systems and submitting bug reports. I've also seen some folks in some communities go from complete Linux noobs to actually making FOSS software. We've also seen some very innovative distros being born as a result of all this hype (Bazzite, the uBlue family, CachyOS etc). So you can't deny the massive impact Valve has had on the overall ecosystem, and personally I think that's a good thing - even if Proton doesn't exactly sit well with FOSS ideals.
- pjmlp 1y agoGreat more distros, just what The Year of Linux Desktop needs.
- d3Xt3r 1y agoGreat more sarcasm, just want the HN community needs.
- pjmlp 1y agoYes, because many in the Linux community tend to focus on the wrong stuff, regarding adoption, and that is why one ends up with Proton.
- d3Xt3r 1y agoYou keep bringing up Proton but you forget that Proton is just Wine + a couple of other existing FOSS projects + some of Valve's patches. Wine is really what makes the magic happen, and Wine existed as far back as 1993, and there was barely a Linux community back then. So you can't really blame the community for Proton, it's just a natural result of things. Even before Proton came along, there were similar projects to make Wine gaming easier, such as PlayOnLinux, CrossOver etc. So Proton is nothing new, its just a natural evolution of an ecosystem that's been evolving over three decades.
- pjmlp 1y agoBecause that is ultimately what makes Windows games run on Linux, and represents Valve's failure to change the culture of game studios to consider GNU/Linux worth targeting, even when they have Android/NDK builds that they could easily use as starting point. Indeed nothing is new, rebooting the Linux Desktop every couple of years, and I still cannot buy a GNU/Linux powered desktop at the shopping mall, with 100% everything working, unless it comes packaged on a VM running on top of macOS or Windows. And when a problem is found in sleep modes, graphics, audio, fingerprint reader or whatever, there is always that person replying like being in some Linux forum powered by phpBB during the early 2000's. Windows games work on Linux, until Microsoft decides it is time to do something about it, ROG XBox Ally is only the first step, and lets not forget current Valve's management won't live forever. So it remains to be seen if the new owners when it comes to be, will be that willing to keep the same culture.
- oliwarner 1y agoThey've sold ~8 million units. Well past the technical argument and the devs who can't be told, that's 8 million Windows licenses they haven't bought. I thin they've more than paid off the salaries of the few people they've hired to make Proton a reality. Not sure I see your comparison to Netbooks; they failed because ultra-cheap laptops are inherently bad. You cut that many corners, you lose quality. They lost out to tablets, better phones, and Chromebooks, each doing something a netbook did but better. Steam Decks are a format that will persist.