3 ms·
Why do LMMs overuse these patterns of speech that aren't overused in the wild?
Here's a quote:
> "That’s not neuroscience — that’s cargo-cult reasoning wrapped in academic buzzwords."
I think most of us who use ChatGPT would immediately recognize this as being AI-generated. It's perfectly valid English and we could all imagine a real human saying it, but ChatGPT (or maybe LLMs more broadly) seem to have landed on certain patterns like this one that they use constantly. Is it some kind of overfitting? Post training where a biased toward this pattern was introduced? Something else?
- A_D_E_P_T 1y ago"It's not X, it's Y" (or "it's not just X, it's Y") is one of the most common tells, but there are many others. Here's a partial list: > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Signs_of_AI_writing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Signs_of_AI_writing It's definitely post-training bias and reinforcement. This rhetorical structure isn't too common IRL. (Or wasn't, anyway, prior to LLMs...)
- incomingpain 1y agothe way they train the models is feeding it lots and lots of literature, and usually high quality. The way they write by default is thus going to be this weird hybrid of all english styles/dialects from the last ~500 years. The reason they are heavy with em dashes is that they were immensely popular in literature for a long time but not so much in modern times. So it stands out. If you tell it to write in a specific way though, it does a good job at it. Here's detroit english, no messin' around. The reason why AI's love the em dash so much is simple: it’s the most versatile and natural punctuation mark they can use to connect ideas and maintain flow. A large language model's primary goal is to sound human, and when people speak, they often pause, clarify, or insert a quick side-thought the dash captures that conversational stop-and-start rhythm better than a rigid comma or a full-stop period. Plus, in the enormous amount of text the AI studies (its data), the em dash is frequently used by skilled writers as an efficient tool to replace colons, parentheses, or strong commas, so the AI simply picked up that effective writing pattern and runs with it, seeing it as the clearest and most dynamic way to structure complex sentences. That's the real deal.
- whycome 1y agoI used to use the em dash a lot. I refrain from doing it now. I hate that outcome.
- incomingpain 1y ago>I used to use the em dash a lot. I refrain from doing it now. I hate that outcome. I dont think it ever got taught in my schooling; the semi-colon is what they taught to use.
- JohnFen 1y agoI refuse to let genAI determine what my writing style should be on principle. I may not be able to do much about the rest of the various degradations genAI brings, but I can at least stand my ground when it comes to my personal expression.
- gooodvibes 1y agoThis isn’t accurate - most of the style comes from the fine tuning and reinforcement learning, not from the original training data. At some point people got this idea that LLMs just repeat or imitate their training data, and that’s completely false for today’s models.
- bediger4000 1y agoSo LLMs have gotten creativity recently?
- gooodvibes 1y agoNo, my point has nothing to do with creativity. It's about the fact that their output is taylored to look and sound in a certain way in the later stages of model training, it's not representative of the original text data the base model was trained on.
- idonotknowwhy 1y agoAgreed. The pre-2025 base models don't write like this.
- jotux 1y agoI read some articles when openai was first getting popular about them using cheap labor from English-speaking African countries (like Kenya): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34426421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34426421 I remember other articles specifically talking about English language features of those regions(like "Okay" instead of "OK") getting into LLMs because of this.
- teunlao 1y agoHumans cut the phrase to avoid sounding like AI. AI copied it because humans used it. Style collapsed into feedback loop.
- muzani 1y agoChatGPT seems to use this most often. Claude uses similar data and training and has similar patterns. Gemini doesn't yet seem to have a consistent pattern, but it's quite different, and honestly, I find it even more disturbing; Gemini Flash is like chatting with an intelligent 9 year old. Grok feels unnaturally chirpy to me.
- fogzen 1y agoI wonder if it's intentional so that they can identify their model output in the wild using stylometry.
- raw_anon_1111 1y agoI recently re-read parts of this book thst I haven’t read in years. https://github.com/97-things/97-things-every-programmer-should-know https://github.com/97-things/97-things-every-programmer-shou... I think it originally came out in 2013. If I were just introduced to it today, I would think some of the articles were AI written with only slight prompting. It’s sad that if I write something from scratch, without any writing assistance besides spell checking, mostly for internal company consumption I now review it to see if it smells like AI. (Just like I would have used a dash above. But I don’t anymore because it has an AI smell and I had to get out of the habit)