3 ms·
The Internet has been around for fifteen years, and PayPal has been around for more than ten. I don't think either of them qualify as "new" anymore. Most people
by enraged_camel 14y ago
The Internet has been around for fifteen years, and PayPal has been around for more than ten. I don't think either of them qualify as "new" anymore. Most people get scammed not because the technologies are new, but because they have been using those technologies irresponsibly, i.e. without educating themselves about their dangers first. They simply want to reap the benefits, and end up losing their money.
- DanBC 14y ago> The Internet has been around for fifteen years WWW has been around for 20 years. But it's only recently that people have always on cable modems and active content. > without educating themselves about their dangers first. HN is full of stories of well funded, international businesses, with considerable sums of cash at risk, who do stupid insecure things. If they can't get it right why should Joe Sixpack be expected to do any better? Email inboxes are full of hoaxes about supposed dangers - most of them are garbage. I'm interested to see what kind of help there is for people who want to learn how to protect themselves on the Internet. (http://www.usa.gov/Citizen/Topics/Internet-Fraud.shtml http://www.usa.gov/Citizen/Topics/Internet-Fraud.shtml) That site has comprehensive information. It's lousy. Look how much stuff people have to wade through.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>I'm interested to see what kind of help there is for people who want to learn how to protect themselves on the Internet. What kind of help is there for people who want to learn to protect themselves in real life? Does the fact that there is no comprehensive resource somehow remove one's burden to learn anyway?
- RegEx 14y agoYou're extremely grumpy. Blaming the victim is not some brave, heroic concept. People can imagine what it looks like to be in physical danger, and instinct can help them avoid the situations to some degree. It's hard to imagine what it's like being in an unsafe situation on the internet.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>Blaming the victim is not some brave, heroic concept. Blaming the victim is bad only if you believe that blame is a zero sum game. Unfortunately, it is not. If you walk down a dark alleyway in New York at night alone and get mugged, the mugger is guilty of mugging you, but you're also guilty of being a silly goose. You don't gain immunity to blame simply because you were the victim.
- sliverstorm 14y agoHow 'bout if you just moved to New York from backcountry Idaho?
- jlgreco 14y agoI would say that a criminal is equally guilty if they commit a crime in a dark alley NYC or if they commit a crime in backcountry Idaho. If I replace my bicycle u-lock with a nice hefty rope and start lashing my bike to whatever object seems solid at the time (this is a concept that actually appeals to me), then I should receive some blame when my bike gets inevitably stolen. However the bicycle thief is no more nor less a thief.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI was talking about the guy who got mugged. What if he had never lived in the city.
- jlgreco 14y agoWhat I was trying to say is that your hypothetical does a good job of showing why blame is not zero sum. Obviously in either case the criminal receives the same blame, but I think it is fairly clear that the victim who took drastic measures to reduce risk is less to blame than the one who did not. The important thing to remember is that the blame of the victim, while present, has no relation to the blame of the criminal and should never be relevant in, for example, a criminal trial for the criminal. I really feel like I can't emphasis that enough.
- DanBC 14y agoIn real life I have my parents to keep a watch on me for most of the early part of my life. This takes years of intense involvement, with a lot of teaching about risk and safety. I have Public Information Films on a variety of subjects: Tables are dangerous (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icbYf_aR91o http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=icbYf_aR91o) A collection of terrifying ads (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0xmSV6aq0g http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m0xmSV6aq0g) There are a variety of crime prevention and community safety websites. There are radio and tv programmes with advice about avoiding scams. There are magazine articles (even a well respected consumer law advice magazine "Which?") about scams and consumer law. All of this is built up over many years and modified when needed. How are people expected to learn how to keep themselves safe on the WWW? What search terms are they expected to use? (This is when I need Matt Cutts or some other Googler to give us useful stats about the words people use to find information about scams)
- RegEx 14y agoHow would you know that responsibility is needed without proper education about the dangers?