5 ms·
Democracy and the open internet die in daylight
- bariumbitmap 1y agohttps://archive.ph/pr2ca https://archive.ph/pr2ca
- oldpersonintx2 1y ago[dead]
- echelon 1y ago> Journalism (or what’s left of it now) is in the state it’s in because of the adtech funding model. I don’t know what the solution is. A P2P [1] social media swarm where identities are signed pseudoanonymous hashes optionally tied to identity proofs. Reputation can be gained in the peer and interest graphs. Advertisers and attention seekers can still exist in such a system without being obtrusive - they can flag their messages by signing them with proof that they burned funds contributing to a charity (or deposited funds to my personal inbox). Eg., "this message from xyz recruiter deposited $1 in your account - read?", or "this MrBeast video provably donated $1M to the EFF - watch?" Journalists can make money on the graph by soliciting donors or publishing content to certain nodes early for a fee. [1] not federated, apart from proxy publishing or relay nodes
- gmuslera 1y agoWhuffies from Doctorow's In and Out in the Magic Kingdom? Bitcoin could had derived into this 15 years ago, but it turned into another shackle in our chains. If it can be attributed some value, then it probably will end in a similar way.
- echelon 1y agoI don't care for crypto at all, but if you burn money to talk to me or send me information, I might pick up. I would prefer to be paid for attention rather than have a third party be paid. Nostr is starting to look something like P2P social, but it's still got a long way to go and isn't mainstream friendly enough. This needs kid-friendly coating. It should just work out of the box and have Meta-caliber product leadership.
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoThere are plenty of outlets creating and reporting original news that are not dependent on adtech. They just aren't traditionally "mainstream" and so a lot of people don't like them
- t274hKba1 1y agoPerplexity browser marketing is everywhere. Glenn Greenwald promotes Comet while talking about Snowden, privacy and security. And they tell us that revenue growth is organic. When Google was new, you didn't need a single ad.
- etiennebausson 1y agoLooking forward to this venture going up in flames honestly. There is only so much malfeasance I can swallow, and Perplexity tick a few too many boxes.
- Arainach 1y agoWhen Google Chrome was new it was advertised a ton of places. All sorts of applications and plugins would by default install Chrome at the same time unless you opted out. Not that that makes this any less bad, but it seems the more fair comparison.
- Flamingoat 1y agoI had totally forgotten about a Chrome download being sneaked into applications. It used a number of dark patterns like having the "install chrome" tickbox being light grey on top of white or it being hidden in "customise install" options.
- SoftTalker 1y agoWas commonplace for a while. Oracle even installed the Ask browser toolbar when you installed their database, with the same easy-to-miss opt-out checkbox. Pretty crazy.
- Flamingoat 1y agoYes it was really annoying. I was using one of the Chromium forks and Chrome used to sneak onto the machine unless you vigilante. It felt like the bad old days of shareware and bonzi-buddy had returned.
- Telemakhos 1y agoI don't think I agree with equating the scribblings of the Washington Post with "democracy" as a whole. I feel like those are two different things.
- kzrdude 1y agoWP has the tagline "Democracy Dies in Darkness" and I think the blog post title is a spoof of that.
- BoredPositron 1y agoThey don't have that tagline anymore.
- pm90 1y agoUmmm they absolutely still do https://www.washingtonpost.com/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/
- mananaysiempre 1y agoStill visible on desktop but not anymore on mobile, it seems. Grey on white (provided your browser requests light mode) is also less easy to spot than their earlier white on black. So I for example was sure it had disappeared until you prompted me to recheck.
- kzrdude 1y agoI've heard that too, but it's visible in the blog post.
- input_sh 1y agoIf you visit their homepage from a desktop, it's right below their logo.
- mr_important 1y ago
- thaumasiotes 1y ago> Leaving aside the idea of access to any form of content being conditional on the use of a proprietary browser, which is a particularly horrid 1990s throwback This concept is far more popular now than it might ever have been in the 1990s. Look at Discord.
- Forgeties79 1y agoCan’t blame communities for putting up their drawbridges and filling in moats either on an increasingly hostile internet. Unfortunately many don’t realize that discord is its own prison of sorts.
- nxor 1y agoWhat is meant by this ?
- Forgeties79 1y agoAI scraping, online harassment, etc. makes people like me want to build more of a “fort” than an open community because I feel a responsibility to protect the community we’ve already built. Discord makes it somewhat easy to keep folks/entities out that you don’t want around, hence so many hobbies and such moving into the space off traditional forums and social media. But it also silos off knowledge which means other folks can’t find it. It’s a real catch 22
- nxor 1y agoOkay, I think I understand, but Discord users typically use other apps too. So I wonder about the extent of this
- Forgeties79 1y agoIt’s just something I have observed both with professional and hobby communities I participate in. I can’t say it with any sort of real numbers behind it. Just ~vibes~ or whatever we want to call it haha
- pm90 1y agoWashington post has been becoming increasingly irrelevant. They went from 500-800k paid subscribers to less than 100k after Bezos started interfering editorially. Some of the most respected journalists left the paper. So I wouldn’t take WaPo as an indicator of anything; its a Bozos Vanity Project and nothing else.
- quantummagic 1y agoYour post is worthy of a rap song by Ad Homeminem.
- cluckindan 1y ago”Bozos Vanity” by Ad Homeminem: Yeah, they preach about truth, but the ink ran dry, Bought the headlines, thought clout could buy the sky. Bezos in the lobby, pullin’ strings, that’s the show, Turned the Post into a post nobody wants to know. Five hundred K deep, now it’s tumbleweed clicks, Writers jump ship while the suits play tricks. Never trust the press when it’s built on a throne, Every page now reads like a PR zone. Ad Homeminem, I don’t bow, I expose, I talk numbers, they talk prose. Media’s a mirror, cracked and vain, You can’t buy truth with billionaire pain. Generated using Perplexity for maximum irony.
- skeeter2020 1y agoIs posting the prompt today's equivalent of liner notes?
- skeledrew 1y agoI can actually feel this. Very slick rhymes.
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoWhat do you mean? A source says wapo has 130K print and 2.5M online subs.[1] Compare NYT with 660K print and 9.7M online[2] which I imagine have fallen off proportionally in line with wapo.[3] [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Post https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Washington_Post [2]https://www.niemanlab.org/2024/02/the-new-york-times-made-more-than-1-billion-from-digital-subscriptions-in-2023/ https://www.niemanlab.org/2024/02/the-new-york-times-made-mo... [3]https://fourweekmba.com/the-new-york-times-print-subscribers/ https://fourweekmba.com/the-new-york-times-print-subscribers...
- keiferski 1y agoThis is just the bundling of one product with another. Personally I get the Financial Times as a benefit of another service I pay for. It’s worth it to me, but I don’t really interpret a newspaper as being the arbiter of democracy in the first place. But if we interpreted the headline as if the article was actually about the idea: I do think there is an interesting idea (which I first read in Byung-Chul Han‘a The Transparency Society) which is that trust and transparency are functionally opposites. We tend to treat transparency as an automatically good thing in democratic systems, but I think you can make the argument that the call for transparency only comes after trust has already been lost. So it’s not really a solution to a more democratic system that results in more trust between constituents and representatives, but rather just a way to deal with the loss of trust in an ostensibly practical way.
- guerrilla 1y ago> Personally I get the Financial Times as a benefit of another service I pay for. What service is that?
- keiferski 1y agohttps://help.revolut.com/en-US/help/profile-and-plan/my-plan-benefits/ https://help.revolut.com/en-US/help/profile-and-plan/my-plan...
- astroflection 1y agoTrust/faith in "democracy" is a fools religion. 100% transparency is the only way out of the pit of feces we find ourselves in election after election.
- keiferski 1y agoI have a hard time believing that you can build a truly democratic culture without a level of shared trust and values. In the sense of it being “rule of the people” rather than rule of the elite, monarchy, etc. In a properly functioning democracy, I think you’d want leaders to want to be a part of the political process. The more hostile and demanding that becomes, the less likely you’ll get those people in positions of power.
- apgwoz 1y agoWe’re going to see a bigger rise up of independent media, and that means that Substack, Patreon, and other platforms that exist to spread a message to paid subscribers are vulnerable to the same buy and squash tactics as traditional media. We certainly need a more P2P, version of this type of platform and a way to fund and scale it such that it can’t be messed with by billionaire hacks. The odds of this being wildly successful are pretty slim, I’d say…
- mr_important 1y agoThere's some kind of missing link here between p2p and "I write for a living" that I don't think is going to be bridged any time soon. Funding and p2p / independent might not be compatible organisms in today's social and economic environment. We've had the tools for this for decades and it's never been achieved at scale and sustainably. I don't think it ever will.
- p2detar 1y ago> in today's social and economic environment. True. I don’t think it was ever successful, because it requires a strong ideological point of view from the people who are supposed to support this idea. With so much distraction in the digital world today, this seems close to impossible.
- squigz 1y agoWouldn't any system that enables funding be susceptible to influence by the rich? Why would any sort of P2P/decentralized/etc system be impervious to that?
- terminalshort 1y agoBecause there is no "the rich." There are millions of them and they have many competing interests.
- mr_important 1y ago> class war isn't the driving force of society wrong
- Noaidi 1y agoMy take: AI Investors are forcing us all into their pyramid scheme to make AI seem relevant.
- skeeter2020 1y agoyour retirement fund is probably already loaded up with investment in PE that owns these AI plays most of which will be worthless, so it's already too late; you ARE own of the AI investors.
- walkabout 1y agoThe good news for our collective investments in stupid technology is we’ve apparently decided never to let the market drop significantly in absolute terms ever again, even to let the air out of an obvious bubble. The bad news is we’re accomplishing that via high levels of inflation, so pretty soon $5m will be the new $1m.
- Noaidi 1y agoI have no retirement fund for exactly this reason. I gave up on stocks and capitalism in 1999. I live off of social security now, socialism at its' finest.
- lunias 1y agoI understand the frustration, but this is everywhere. I went to McDonald's and saw that they were running their Monopoly game again. I peeled the sticker off of my fries nostalgically, but in order to even see what I may have won I need to download the app and manually enter the code. Why even print a physical Monopoly piece sticker? I'm definitely not installing your app. We used to just walk up to the counter and redeem the reward. This change you've made, it's not for me, is it? The solution is the same as it has always been, stop spending time and money on things that are frustrating. If enough people do it in aggregate, then things will change; but I'll be damned if people aren't slow to catch on.
- imglorp 1y agoIt's back to this modern business problem: shareholders demand multiple revenue streams now. You can't just sell food, now you also have to surveil your customers and sell their data, show them ads, and get them into a subscription.
- SirFatty 1y ago"show them ads" Gas station at 6a, nothing like blaring ads across 20 pumps. What a time to be alive!
- scruple 1y agoSecond button from the top on the right shuts most of those things up in my experience. If not hit every button, usually one of them will work.
- SirFatty 1y agoNice! I'll give it a go next time. Thanks for that. edit: speedway has gone touchscreen, so I wonder if there are ghost buttons then?
- NietzscheanNull 1y agoUnfortunately, my local stations are deep enough into the Enshittification Cycle™ that the formerly-functional pump mute buttons have all been disabled. That seems to be the trend among several of the newer gas stations I've visited lately. That's the line which, when crossed, I immediately boycott and use another gas station indefinitely, but I get the feeling that it's only a matter of time before they all follow suit. But surely, “all is for the best in the best of all possible worlds” that our late-stage capitalism has so benevolently bequeathed us.
- lkrubner 1y agoI don't think this is a great article, as I think it focuses too much on the Washington Post, but there are some issues that will have to be addressed in American democracy. National democracy is built on top of local democracy, in the sense of local self-rule -- if local democracy is dying then national democracy will tend to die, but if local democracy is thriving, national democracy is largely guaranteed. About local democracy: 1. Local city government is now less accountable because of the death of local newspapers. The public must have some idea what politicians are doing, but without local newspapers there is no one to report what is happening at the local level. 2. This is related to people (since the 1960s) losing interest in local government. When I was a child my parents both served in the local government, I remember being 7 years old and getting taken to meetings where the room was packed. But when I was 42 I drove my mom to a town meeting and I was shocked to see that the room was empty, literally, there was not a single citizen who had come out for the meeting that evening. The only people in the room were the politicians (all of whom were volunteers, as it was an unpaid position -- they were civically minded citizens). 3. Local democracy worked best when families stayed in one town for generations, and so had a long-term commitment to the health of the town. But the modern life-style, even for the middle class who are the most likely to serve in government, involves buying a starter home in one town, then a bigger home for a family (in another town), then a retirement home, possibly in another state. Most families now assume they will only be in a given town for 10 or 20 years, so their focus tends to be on minimal taxes, rather than long-term investments in the town. 4. For local government, possible solutions include abolishing local democracy and making the positions appointed (most roles are already appointed, of course) from the state level, or making the towns much larger (a large percentage of a given state) or limiting voting to those who pass some test, or who demonstrate citizenship by volunteering some time, or by having frequent elections to a staggered city council (as frequent voting tends to reward the few citizens who are highly active). Anyone who thinks these moves are anti-democratic should remember that local government elections tend to only get 15% to 20% participation rates, so most of the public has already voluntarily disenfranchised itself. Any democracy will automatically be the democracy of those who show up. There is no democracy for the truly apathetic. But local and regional self-rule can remain strong so long as citizens who are active in civic affairs can continue to exercise rule at the local level, without being blocked those who are non-active. There remains a controversy whether "democracy" means "the right to vote" or "a population engaged in self-government." That is, does "democracy" refer to "self expression via voting" or does it refer to actual government arising from the local population? Those who feel that "democracy" means "self expression" tend to think of themselves as consumers rather than citizens, they see themselves as buying government services (with taxes) rather than the producers of government. But local self-rule does not survive for long in areas where people see themselves mostly as consumers of government services. Local self-rule survives thanks to the civically minded citizens who are willing to volunteer their time to creating governance.
- 1970-01-01 1y agoSeems as if they die in *open daylight. *paywalled
- culebron21 1y agoI can't open the article. > We're sorry, but access from your location is not allowed. If you are a user with administrative privilege please enter your email below to receive instructions on how to unblock yourself. How ironic.