3 ms·
You don't know how any of these could be developed in good conscience? How about: anti-proliferation intelligence work is going to happen whether it requires hu
by tptacek 1y ago
You don't know how any of these could be developed in good conscience? How about: anti-proliferation intelligence work is going to happen whether it requires human intelligence or CNE, and CNE is less costly and harmful?
I get where you're probably coming from: this same technology is used all over the world to target journalists and dissidents in countries with and without the rule of law. A very real concern. I wouldn't do this kind of work either (also, it's been over a decade since I had the chops even to apprentice at it).
But there are very coherent reasons people are comfortable doing this work for NATO countries. Our reflexive distrust of law enforcement and intelligence work is a fringe belief: a lot of families are very proud to include people working in these fields.
The most important thing I guess I'd have to say here is: our opinion of this stuff doesn't matter. At current market rates every country in the world can afford CNE technology, and it's a market well served by vendors outside of NATO.
- Ms-J 1y ago"our opinion of this stuff doesn't matter." It very much does matter. If more people refuse to do this type of work, it eventually won't be done to the required standard. People would cut family ties and this would stop fast.
- tptacek 1y agoThat's an incredibly blinkered view of the ecosystem that assumes that the only talent capable of delivering this work is people you talk to or share cultural ties with. There are ultra-skilled people in developing countries who could not give less of a fuck about how uncomfortable this stuff makes people in the west.
- GauntletWizard 1y agoThere are tons of people in the West who have no qualms about doing this for pure crime purposes; many of them are the ones who espouse most ardently that doing this work for the government is immoral.
- philipallstar 1y ago> many of them are the ones who espouse most ardently that doing this work for the government is immoral How do you know this?
- GauntletWizard 1y agoAn opinion, based on meeting people like https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/capital-one-hacking-suspect-allegedly-boasted-online-despite-warnings-don-n1036111 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/capital-one-hacking-sus...
- fruitworks 1y agoso what? As GP suggests, they are not nessisary for the development of exploits.
- pixl97 1y ago>If more people refuse to do this type of work This is kind of like saying "if people wouldn't murder other people then..." "Bad" kind of work always finds bodies to fill it's spots. Boycotts of a particular business might work, but a type of work won't, especially when there is decent money on the table. And then when you start adding in people that had previous run ins with law enforcement and find it hard to get a "legit" job and get a decent offer from a place like this, they'll have no problem taking it.
- diffeomorphism 1y agoIt would stop in your country but not globally. That means your country loses all expertise and will be much worse off to defend itself. Case in point: In 2007 Germany passed a "hacking law" (§202c). On its face, it was supposed to prevent black hat work. Except it very predictably also did enormous damage to security research.
- bigyabai 1y ago> At current market rates every country in the world can afford CNE technology Slippery slopes don't justify anything. You might not care enough to make a difference, but many people do and your justification rings hollow to everyone that's potentially a victim. You wouldn't say this about nuclear proliferation, so why make a carveout for digital mercenary work? Because it's "harmless"? I don't know what your goal is with this statement but it certainly doesn't make me feel any better. If you're this emotionally invested in the topic, it might be best for your own optics to not chime in.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm not justifying anything. I'm saying a very large number of people don't share the premise in the parent comment. It's one thing to disagree with a practice; it's another thing to suggest that disagreement with it is universal. It is not.
- fruitworks 1y agoThe difference is that it's completely plausible to protect against a cyberattack, but completely implausible to protect against a nuclear attack. The onus is on Apple and their userbase to protect their own computers, not the rest of society to patrol and regulate unstoppable "information crime" against them
- sakisv 1y agoI think I agree with what I think you're trying to say. However I don't agree with the repercussions of this, which are the same ones that make all reasonable people, security experts included, oppose EU's ChatControl or the UK's backdoor requests: There is no way to ensure and protect the people that need protection, as there is no way to ensure that only "the good guys" have it. We tend to bullshit ourselves into believing that because spyware software like Predator are weapons, meaning that only countries would be allowed to buy them and use them (same way that Jeff Bezos cannot buy and use an F-35 for example). We see though, that certain individuals _can_ get their hands on these things and use them however they want. For example, 3 years ago someone adjacent to the greek government bought and used Predator against MEPs, journalists, army generals, mafia bosses, MPs of opposing parties and even MPs of their own, ruling, party. The greek government of course denied that they did it, and they said that this individual did not act under the instructions of the government (though they then changed the law to prevent anyone for learning details about it, but that's a different story). So, apart from adopting the same approach as with ChatControl and encryption backdoors, i.e. banning them, I don't know how we could protect ourselves against them.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm an American and am glad of my personal belief that the American system would not allow something like ChatControl by state mandate. I also wouldn't participate in commercial exploit development (even if I was capable of doing so competitively). But I don't think the two things are at all comparable.
- 1659447091 1y ago> You don't know how any of these could be developed in good conscience? The OP did say "...for resale in good conscience." I personally read that as the commercial companies that allows anyone to buy the product off the shelf for the right price -- including governments, but also rogue elements. Bad actors, groups, or even people engaged in abusive domestic practices (customers without the time, experience, or resources to do it in-house). Not the people who work directly under government agencies developing these things for State level intelligence/ops
- 1oooqooq 1y agohumans create myths which shape their world. you, sadly, internalized a state humanity adopted after wwii, were the anti red propaganda told everyone that of you could illegally burn a forest down to then buy a Ferrari, it was the best course of action because if you didn't do it, someone would. thankfully people like you are being ostracized, albeit too slow, and pointed out as what you really are: agentless weak oportunists.