3 ms·
> Why is Musk allowed to be worth half a trillion dollars again? Because he founded a company that turned into PayPal, single-handedly launched the Western EV
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Why is Musk allowed to be worth half a trillion dollars again?
Because he founded a company that turned into PayPal, single-handedly launched the Western EV revolution and single-handedly secured American access to space. He's been a fuckup for the last few years. But he's "allowed" to be worth a lot because if he were doing what he's doing elsewhere, he'd facilitate a multi-trillion dollar wealth transfer from America to that place.
- suckler 1y agoPaypal kicked Musk out for being annoying and useless and wanting to implement bad ideas. He bought Tesla after it already put out its fan-favorite car. To say he contributed anything is questionable, and to say anything he has done is revolutionary is laughable.
- lotsofpulp 1y agoRepeated success along multiple businesses is an objective measure. There is a chance he lucked into paypal, tesla, spaceX, and starlink, but it seems reasonable to assume he is contributing (and detracting simultaneously) something to score 4 successess, even if that is just hiring the right people and making big bets. These are also hard businesses, dealing with physics, chemistry, and regulations. Unlike SaaS businesses one spins up on cloud services. Which lends some more credence to not just being lucky. Obviously, he has a reprehensible agenda, but there is clearly a case to be made about his ability to execute.
- pas 1y agothis is a bad framing. he did put in a lot of work, he did mercilessly churn through engineers to get results, cajoled various power-brokers to get subsidies and financing necessary to keep on keeping on. he is the ultimate right place right time person, managed to turn innovative historically doomed-to-fail ventures into very highly valued mature(ish) businesses. it's unlikely that someone without his micromanagerial madness could have done these. (and of course in a better world he would have gotten help, employees wouldn't have been fired on a whim, and the market wouldn't reward liars. not to mention that ideally the market would price in the consequences of enriching someone with so loose morals.)
- jhgb 1y ago> He bought Tesla after it already put out its fan-favorite car If you mean Tesla Roadster, that came out in 2008, 4 years after Musk's involvement. Or were you trying to say something else?
- hbarka 1y agoWhere’s my $15k deposit?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> let’s complete what we cede fuck-it-up worth to: Single-handedly secured the outcome of an election because he’s worth a lot, then, he’s allowed to be DOGE and fuck more shit up just because he’s worth a lot This strikes me as more of an indictment of money in politics. Musk didn't need half a trillion dollars to influence the election and trash our government. He needed a few hundred million. We should be able to create a system where a man, even a very rich man, cannot rent the most powerful position in the history of humanity with a few hundred million dollars.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> But he's "allowed" to be worth a lot because if he were doing what he's doing elsewhere, he'd facilitate a multi-trillion dollar wealth transfer from America to that place. That was the argument against Massachusetts taxing millionaires. Instead, it made double even the optimistic estimates. https://www.wgbh.org/news/politics/2024-05-21/millionaires-tax-revenue-reaches-1-8-billion-on-pace-to-double-estimates https://www.wgbh.org/news/politics/2024-05-21/millionaires-t... Turns out there's usually a good reason people settle in a place. (And the US government gets a big say if you try to move a critical national security asset out of the country, too.)
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoI’m not talking about taxes, I’m talking about raw wealth creation. Musk is rewarded in part so America stays attractive to the next potential Musk. We could double his taxes and that message would still hold.
- ceejayoz 1y agoHe's "allowed to be worth half a trillion dollars" because we don't tax him enough.
- s1artibartfast 1y agowould a 499 billion cap make you happy? 100 Billion? It would require substantial punitive taxes and penalties to prevent this accumulation. Would founders and investors still develop in the USA if their upside were curtailed? Would Musk Found spaceX if they were not allowed to profit from it? Also, it is not as simple as taxing profits. Almost all of this value is simply equity in controlled companies. What is the mechanism here? If you are too successful, the government seizes your company? Dont you think that would be disruptive to investment and growth?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Would founders and investors still develop in the USA if their upside were curtailed? Yes. Unified consumer market. Incumbency. Deep and international access to risk capital. China only has the first two. It's still got a thriving start-up ecosystem. > Almost all of this value is simply equity in controlled companies. What is the mechanism here? Selling equity. This is a theoretical question for e.g. a closely-held family business. It's not for a public or mature private company. > the government seizes your company? Guess who ushered in the administration that's embraced this option!
- ben_w 1y ago> But he's "allowed" to be worth a lot because if he were doing what he's doing elsewhere, he'd facilitate a multi-trillion dollar wealth transfer from America to that place. I think this is the critical point. It's kinda the foundation of why all extremely rich people are "allowed" to get so rich. For the rest, not so much. Partly: Much as I was impressed with him successfully turning the disaster that was Eberhard and Tarpenning's era into a viable business, I would not describe "noticing and fixing Eberhard and Tarpenning's mistakes" as "single-handedly" launching anything. The booster version is the opposite side of the same wrong coin as those who insist Musk was worthless because Eberhard and Tarpenning came first. SpaceX similarly, for all I'm impressed by how he's used his charisma and vision and drive to get people organised, he's definitely not "single handed" on this. But also, my understanding is that for valuations such as Tesla's share price, the "what it should be" is usually based on what they're likely to return in the next 20 years or so. Tesla's stock price is obviously disconnected from the business returns, at best speculation based on what Musk might be able to organise people to do eventually, and given he has been, as you say, "a fuckup for the last few years", the expected return for the Musk group should be lower, not higher.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- NickC25 1y ago>Because he founded a company that turned into PayPal No he didn't. He co-founded (with several other people) a company that merged with a company founded over a year before (that he had no involvement in) which eventually became PayPal. He didn't found jack shit on his own. > single-handedly launched the Western EV revolution Say what now? Are we talking about Tesla? You know Toyota had a working hybrid on the market in 2000, correct? The West was already well on its way to electric vehicles when Musk bought himself a board seat at Tesla. >single-handedly secured American access to space. Americans had not only already gone to space, but had landed on the moon over 2 years before Musk was born. Yes, you read that right - he was quite literally not even conceived when Americans had not only sent rockets into space, but literally went to and landed on a moon.
- jrflowers 1y agoI like that he didn’t do any of those things. Like you are mixing up “Elon Musk the guy that spends 18 hours a day tweeting and retweeting various race grievances” and “Elon Musk as envisioned by Marvel Studios in 2010’s superhero film Iron Man 2”. None of the characters or events in that movie were real. That was all made up by writers so they could sell DVDs and 1/6th scale limited edition figurines.