5 ms·
Modeling Others' Minds as Code
- joaquincabezas 1y agowhen someone behaves in a very predictable way I use to say "I could code you in C!". Well, turns out is Python!
- ryandv 1y ago[flagged]
- qsort 1y agoThere's the old joke that many people who fear they could be replaced by AI are in fact too self-aggrandizing, they could be replaced by a 12-line python script. If you want to get a bit meaner, you could profitably replace some people with the empty python script.
- bgwalter 1y agoI remember the joke differently. I heard it first way before the "AI" craze from an Italian philosopher (the original program must have been recorded in the 1980s and then rebroadcast): "People who think they can be replaced by AI will be replaced." In other words, the cheerleaders are so dumb that they probably could be replaced.
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe classic book Remember me to God https://www.amazon.com/Remember-Me-to-God/dp/B000LQ2SHG https://www.amazon.com/Remember-Me-to-God/dp/B000LQ2SHG talks about how people in low social positions (say a Bank Teller) have no opportunities to distinguish themself but have opportunities to make mistakes that they'll be held accountable for. Whereas if you are in a high social position you get to grade your own paper, get credit for your successes, and "fail up" when you screw up. Given that neural networks get it wrong some of the kind they might be better to fill the high status positions (make up crazy stuff to say for Satya Nadella and Eric Schmidt for instance)
- emp17344 1y agoWeirdly misanthropic. Jobs exist for a reason - people who could be replaced by a python script already have been.
- keybored 1y ago- I could program a person in C - They could be replaced by a 12-line Python script Predictably HN-misanthropic is more like it.
- constantcrying 1y agoIf you work in any large organization you know that there are people who exists so that other people can not do their jobs.
- saagarjha 1y agoYou’re assuming that companies are efficient at discovering which jobs these are.
- qsort 1y agoI'm joking, that wasn't meant to be serious commentary. I don't actually agree with the idea that most jobs are bullshit.
- more_corn 1y ago
- deadbabe 1y agoSome people could be replaced with nothing at all.
- palmotea 1y ago> Some people could be replaced with nothing at all. The kicker is it's often not the guy you think it is.
- shagie 1y agoLong ago... Think Geek T-shirt: "Go away or I will replace you with a very small shell script" https://web.archive.org/web/20081204045017/http://www.thinkgeek.com/tshirts-apparel/unisex/frustrations/374d/ https://web.archive.org/web/20081204045017/http://www.thinkg...
- palmotea 1y ago> Long ago... Think Geek T-shirt: "Go away or I will replace you with a very small shell script" Whoever bought that shirt could probably use some social skills coaching. It's not a good idea to wear a shirt that indiscriminately broadcasts contempt in all directions. I get the purchasers probably confused it for humor, but there's an important difference between humor that works on a viewer TV show and and humor embedded in the interaction of you with another real person. I had this though recently at Walmart, after seeing the third such shirt (a visual pun meaning "fuck you"). Geeks often have the same attitude problems.
- saagarjha 1y agoIdeally you pair the shirt with a personality that never leaves any doubt that it is a joke.
- palmotea 1y ago> Ideally you pair the shirt with a personality that never leaves any doubt that it is a joke. Ideally, but that still doesn't really solve the problem. It's not really practical to counter an indiscriminate broadcast of contempt with point to point interactions. People who don't know you or don't know you well will always see your shirt, if you wear it out. You want to do the opposite: indiscriminately broadcast a kind personality, then deploy the sarcasm in point to point contexts "that never [leave] any doubt that it is a joke".
- saagarjha 1y agoI think this is pretty unreasonable, though. Are you against the husband/wife “I’m with stupid/I’m stupid” shirts? Generally it’s pretty obvious this is meant as a joke and not that one spouse genuinely degrades the other in public.
- atoav 1y agoIf someone pissed off our sysadmin he would say something among the lines of: "Quiet, you are aware I could replace you with a simple script?"
- palmotea 1y ago> Our key insight is that many everyday social interactions may follow predictable patterns; efficient "scripts" that minimize cognitive load for actors and observers, e.g., "wait for the green light, then go." We propose modeling these routines as behavioral programs instantiated in computer code rather than policies conditioned on beliefs and desires. Aren't there already materials (made for people with autism) that catalog these scripts and make them explicit? Edit: e.g. https://suelarkey.com.au/promoting-social-understanding-social-scripts/ https://suelarkey.com.au/promoting-social-understanding-soci...
- ryandv 1y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 1y agoNot sure how you expect to accurately modeling existing social norms and end up with something that doesn’t... do exactly that.
- fellowniusmonk 1y agoLooks like you may have missed it, but that user is mocking what they consider to be a liberal perspective. They are attempting to lower the level of humanity and discourse on the site.
- ryandv 1y ago[flagged]
- gaul_bladder 1y ago[dead]
- ryandv 1y ago
- FrustratedMonky 1y agoIs this basically the "Fidelity" testing in Westworld?
- alganet 1y agoI think this has applications in virtual fences. For example, if you want to restrict someone's behavior to a certain pattern. Also, you can think of it as the subject (or subjects) programming the modeling agent: if the modeled mind is able to recognize it's being modeled, it's reasonable to consider the possibility that it can influence how those inferred scripts are created just by shaping its own behavior. It can't be like an EEG, right? "Please be quiet and predictable while I model you, sir". Of course, what humans think of predictability might not hold water. One could think he's behaving in a random way but in reality following well-known patterns (unknown to him). It's an interesting problem. Absolutely terrifying stuff.
- truelson 1y agoMost automatic human behavior uses very simple logic. I spend a lot of time "not present" as my conscious part is often lost in something complicated. My automatic, unconscious actions are, well, pretty simple and subject to failure when I'm not "present." I really really want this other part of my unconscious behavior modeled well. Would be very useful.
- more_corn 1y agoOne good way to model your unconscious behavior is to examine the ways adversaries exploit your unconscious behavior. By examining the common attacks on distracted people you can build a simple rule set that accounts for a large part of unconscious behavior. The attack I love to hate is the “subscribe now” popup. It inserts into your OODA loop at exactly the moment when your mind is engaged with important or interesting concepts. It is designed to compromise your decision making. I would use that as the foundation of my model because it sets out not only the behavior but the conditions under which the behavior is active. Another set of rules can be inferred from ways phishing tricks people. (Activating urgency, fear, irritation, authority, avarice) A third source of rules might be inferred from the practices of illusionists and cup and ball scams. Attention is finite, I’ve got it here so it’s not available in the important direction.
- sarreph 1y agoI've been thinking a lot recently about how much we'd be able to model the human existence as a foundation model (or multiple models representing each core part of the brain) hooked up to a load of sensors (such as 'optic nerve feed', 'temperature', 'cortisol levels') as input and as a response to tool calls -- and have all of this stream out as structured output controlling speech, motor movement, and other physiological functions. I don't know if anyone is working on modelling the human existence (via LMMs) in this way... It feels like a Frankensteinian and eccentric project idea, but certainly a fun one!
- SubiculumCode 1y agoIf you AI folks would spend more time reading actual semantic/episodic/working memory literatures, you wouldn't have to "invent" all these old ideas from scratch, over and over. Scripts are mental templates for routine situations. They are super important construct supporting memory and learning.
- naasking 1y agoWhy would AI researchers assume that AI models are like human brains? Sleep is also super important for brains, but AI models don't need it. Unless you're asserting that AI models and brains do share some things in common?
- obeseneocortex 1y agowell, they speak the same language for one thing
- Darmani 1y agoAu contraire. DreamCoder is a stupendous work. https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3453483.3454080 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3453483.3454080
- SubiculumCode 1y ago'''Our key insight is that many everyday social interactions may follow predictable patterns; efficient "scripts" that minimize cognitive load for actors and observers, e.g., "wait for the green light, then go." We propose modeling these routines as behavioral programs instantiated in computer code rather than policies conditioned on beliefs and desires. ''' yet, as far as I can tell, did not cite the relevant literature.