3 ms·
> Garbagemen are useful to society, too -- arguably more so than aerospace engineers. You may want to make that argument. No one else will. Garbage collection
by lutusp 14y ago
> Garbagemen are useful to society, too -- arguably more so than aerospace engineers.
You may want to make that argument. No one else will. Garbage collection can be automated. Aerospace design cannot be.
> Lawyers:
> Thomas Jefferson Abraham Lincoln Gandhi Thurgood Marshall
The fact that these people were lawyers is entirely coincidental to who they really were. None of them changed the world as lawyers.
> Philosophers: [...]
Same answer. The degree to which these people were effective can be measured by the fact that they abandoned philosophy and started doing something useful.
And Arisotle was wrong about nearly everything. He should somehow be historically recognized for holding humanity back all out of proportion to his actual standing.
Calling Jesus and Buddha philosophers is like calling a butterfly a caterpillar. Yes, but no.
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"You may want to make that argument. No one else will." I'm pretty sure that if all the garbagemen and all the aerospace engineers disappeared tomorrow, society would miss the garbagemen a lot sooner and a lot more. "The fact that these people were lawyers is entirely coincidental to who they really were." So you think they'd have be able to do what they did if they'd studied aerospace engineering? Or did, JUST MAYBE, the legal training have something to do with their abilities to make persuasive arguments? "And Arisotle was wrong about nearly everything." He wasn't wrong about logic. "The degree to which these people were effective can be measured by the fact that they abandoned philosophy and started doing something useful." Total bullshit. Their philosophy is the sole reason we've even heard of them today.
- thrill 14y agoSociety could also replace the garbage men overnight - engineers ... a little longer.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoGoogle "commercial driver's license shortage". Then reflect than in addition to a CDL, garbagemen need to know how to safely operate the specialized equipment on the truck. Then reflect that many CDL holders would rather not deal with garbage, especially when they can pick and choose their jobs. You're not going to "replace them overnight". Sorry. Even if you could, would you want want someone who's been "replaced overnight" operating a gigantic garbage truck near your house?
- lutusp 14y ago> I'm pretty sure that if all the garbagemen and all the aerospace engineers disappeared tomorrow, society would miss the garbagemen a lot sooner and a lot more. Yes, but this can't be used to argue that garbagemen are more important. In the short term we would miss the garbagemen, but in 90 days they would be replaced and forgotten. Not so for the engineers. >> "The fact that these people were lawyers is entirely coincidental to who they really were." > So you think they'd have be able to do what they did if they'd studied aerospace engineering? Straw man. The fact that Gandhi and Hitler were both vegetarians is entirely irrelevant to their true place in history. >> "And Arisotle was wrong about nearly everything." > He wasn't wrong about logic. He seemed unable to apply logic, only describe it, and he was antithetical to experimentation. Bertrand Russell on Aristotle: "Aristotle maintained that women have fewer teeth than men; although he was twice married, it never occurred to him to verify this statement by examining his wives' mouths." > Total bullshit. Their philosophy is the sole reason we've even heard of them today. First, that's not what I said, and second, it's false in each and every case. Try to argue that Thomas Jefferson's philosophical speculations put him in the history books, rather than his having penned the Declaration of Independence. The same for the others on your list -- each of them is remembered, not for having a philosophy, but for having acted on it.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoDon't give yourself a hernia shifting those goalposts, dude. First you defined worth to society in terms of pay, which would make, say, Snoop Dogg more valuable than, say, the guy who discovers a cancer cure. Now you're defining it in terms of "ability to be easily replaced" which would make, say, the Guinness record-holder for the longest sustained belch more valuable than, again, a cancer researcher. "He seemed unable to apply logic, only describe it" Wrong. He was, as you say, not into experimentation, but that doesn't make his logic invalid. Logic is independent of the truth of the premises. His premises were wrong, but the logic was 100% sound. "rather than his having penned the Declaration of Independence. " The Declaration of Independence is nothing more than a philosophical statement, pure and simple. "Acting on it" required going out in the field with guns, which Jefferson never did.