5 ms·

We'd need a real breakthrough in physics to have such a technology that works at a scale even remotely comparable to what a low end digital CPU can do today. Th

We'd need a real breakthrough in physics to have such a technology that works at a scale even remotely comparable to what a low end digital CPU can do today. The thing is, there's not even any real evidence (at least to my knowledge) that there are useful threads that researchers know to pull on that could yield such a technology. Emulating analog hardware with digital hardware in anticipation of some kind of breakthrough isn't going to have any material benefits in the short to medium term.

marshfram 1y ago
You're thinking small, think about software first. Analoga of differentials. Spatial. Specifics. If you get trapped in emulation, you're trapped in counting.
- bastawhiz 1y ago
  What does that even mean
  - marshfram 1y ago
    Binary computers are toy prisons of counting that model in a reality that has no correct models, not even neuromorphic will gain validity here, leave them behind. Start over with the forms we know are valid in neural syntax and apply them to software.
    - bastawhiz 1y ago
      That's a great sentiment but without code that does what you're describing, that means nothing. Put some code out into the world that demonstrates the idea, because otherwise it's just inspirational words without substance.
      - marshfram 1y ago
        It's not a sentiment, it's real coding. Rhythms of the Brain by Buzsaki. Cinema is already a prototype of differences, using space, and coreelating topological states. It's analog software that's been running for 130 years. Binary was always a dead end alley, we knew this going in. How do we escape it?
        bastawhiz 1y ago
        It's not real coding if you can't point to code and show people how to do it. Where's the GitHub link? Where are the tutorials? Where are the YouTube videos explaining why it's important and how to do it right? You're just saying words, show me something tangible that's not just a vibe.
        marshfram 1y ago
        Closed to public view.
        bastawhiz 1y ago
        Sure, of course.
        marshfarm 1y ago
        You can start here, sports and cinema combined create the syntax of language as a code. https://www.routledge.com/The-Constraints-Led-Approach-Principles-for-Sports-Coaching-and-Practice-Design/Renshaw-Davids-Newcombe-Roberts/p/book/9781138104075 https://www.routledge.com/The-Constraints-Led-Approach-Princ...

marshfram 1y ago

You're thinking small, think about software first. Analoga of differentials. Spatial. Specifics. If you get trapped in emulation, you're trapped in counting.

bastawhiz 1y ago
What does that even mean
- marshfram 1y ago
  Binary computers are toy prisons of counting that model in a reality that has no correct models, not even neuromorphic will gain validity here, leave them behind. Start over with the forms we know are valid in neural syntax and apply them to software.
  - bastawhiz 1y ago
    That's a great sentiment but without code that does what you're describing, that means nothing. Put some code out into the world that demonstrates the idea, because otherwise it's just inspirational words without substance.
    - marshfram 1y ago
      It's not a sentiment, it's real coding. Rhythms of the Brain by Buzsaki. Cinema is already a prototype of differences, using space, and coreelating topological states. It's analog software that's been running for 130 years. Binary was always a dead end alley, we knew this going in. How do we escape it?
      - bastawhiz 1y ago
        It's not real coding if you can't point to code and show people how to do it. Where's the GitHub link? Where are the tutorials? Where are the YouTube videos explaining why it's important and how to do it right? You're just saying words, show me something tangible that's not just a vibe.
        marshfram 1y ago
        Closed to public view.
        bastawhiz 1y ago
        Sure, of course.
        marshfarm 1y ago
        You can start here, sports and cinema combined create the syntax of language as a code. https://www.routledge.com/The-Constraints-Led-Approach-Principles-for-Sports-Coaching-and-Practice-Design/Renshaw-Davids-Newcombe-Roberts/p/book/9781138104075 https://www.routledge.com/The-Constraints-Led-Approach-Princ...