4 ms·
It's a really thoughtful article, worth reading all the way through. But while I trust the author is right, I wonder how much is a "grass is greener" phenomeno
by nkurz 14y ago
It's a really thoughtful article, worth reading all the way through. But while I trust the author is right, I wonder how much is a "grass is greener" phenomenon.
Cadets hooahing in raucous agreement, in what amounted to a collective high-five between current and future Army leaders. The faculty briefings weren’t much different, as we were informed that West Point is the “best liberal arts school in the country” ad nauseam, according to a methodologically dubious 2009 Forbes college rankings report.
...
These cadets all report the same thing: their intellectual curiosity was stifled at USMA in myriad ways. Even while the Dean brags that “we’re better than Harvard, better than Princeton,” most cadets learn to “beat the Dean,” or do just enough to get by academically, with a wink and a nod.
I went to one of the schools that trades off with a few others the top slot as "Top Liberal Arts College", and I felt much the same. It was a wonderful school, with bright students and talented professors, but I too felt that it stifled intellectual curiosity in myriad ways and that the "wink and nod" were the real values instilled. Eventually I left, disappointed with it and with myself.
Did anyone manage to find a place where this was not the case?
- sopooneo 14y agoSomeone close to me went to the "honors college" inside a large state university. From her accounts, it was the real thing.
- ritchiea 14y agoI went to liberal arts school and I thought it was great. I took a lot of philosophy, psychology and lit classes that honed my analytical thinking. And a computer science course I took to satisfy a math requirement got me started learning to program (that and a digital art class that focused on Processing). I also found my classmates to be some of the most interesting and intellectually curious people I've ever met. But I know this varies school to school. I've also met plenty of people who were disappointed with their liberal arts experience. For what it's worth I went to Reed.
- ims 14y agoIt sounds like you may have read it, but you would probably enjoy this essay by William Deresiewicz: http://theamericanscholar.org/the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-education/ http://theamericanscholar.org/the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-...