4 ms·
Problem is, that's not the way it actually works in practice. In practice, the American university system is financially upside-down. * Very expensive, very w
by eli_gottlieb 14y ago
Problem is, that's not the way it actually works in practice. In practice, the American university system is financially upside-down.
* Very expensive, very wealthy institutions like Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and MIT can afford extensive financial aid for almost every single admitted student. Students at these institutions usually receive enough tuition reductions and scholarships to bring the education into their affordable range before loans come into the picture.
* "Cheaper" public universities have all had their budgets cut by strapped state governments and their associated greedy taxpayers (see: Prop 13 in California). They also have much smaller endowments and little extra income. They've started biasing their admissions more towards out-of-state and international students as much as state law allows them to, because those students pay the full non-resident sticker-price (which includes little to no state subsidy defraying the cost). As a result, the average student at a "cheaper" public university will now pay or borrow a larger price, closer to the sticker-price, than a student attending an elite private university.
* (Of course, the worst-off remain those who went to very expensive private universities/colleges that aren't actually that rich or that good, and who therefore have tens of thousands of dollars of debt for very little education. But they were always screwed.)
- Evbn 14y agoBut out of state students are intentionally overpaying and don't deserve much sympathy. In state students get a pretty cheap deal still, only the ones who don't get admitted have cause to complain.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoBut out of state students are intentionally overpaying and don't deserve much sympathy. No, they are most definitely not intentionally overpaying. Not all public universities are educationally equivalent. UC Berkeley is just better than the University of Nevada, and I would not say that a student who chooses the former over the latter has justly chosen to hurt themselves financially. They've chosen the superior education, which is supposed to be what matters.