3 ms·
What is a "deep problem" and what was the cadence with which we addressed these kinds of "deep problems" prior to 2023, when ChatGPT first went mainstream?
by tptacek 1y ago
What is a "deep problem" and what was the cadence with which we addressed these kinds of "deep problems" prior to 2023, when ChatGPT first went mainstream?
- skydhash 1y agoFor a very tiny slice of these deep problems and how they were addressed, you can review the usenix conferences and the published papers there. https://www.usenix.org/publications/proceedings https://www.usenix.org/publications/proceedings
- tptacek 1y agoI've been a Usenix reviewer twice, once as a program chair (I think that's what they call the co-leaders of a PC?). So this doesn't clarify anything for me.
- skydhash 1y agoTo out it more clearly. You take a domain (like OS security, perfomance, and administration) and you’ll find those kinds of problems that people feel important to share solutions with each other. Solutions that are not trivially found. Findings you can be proud your name is attached with. And then you have something like the LLM craze where while it’s new, it’s not improving any part of the problem it’s supposed to solve, but instead is creating new ones. People are creating imperfect solutions to those new problems, forgetting the main problem in the process. It’s all vapourware. Even something like a new linter for C is more of a solution to programmer’s productivity than these “skills”
- tptacek 1y agoOK: I think I have decisively established my Usenix bona fides here, and I'm repeating my original question: what is the cadence at which we resolved "deep question" prior to the era of LLMs? (It began in 2023.)