4 ms·
Perhaps a student should go to a cheaper school if the profession they have chosen isn't ever going to pay back the money they spent on college.
by protomyth 14y ago
Perhaps a student should go to a cheaper school if the profession they have chosen isn't ever going to pay back the money they spent on college.
- alanctgardner2 14y agoAll of these articles are full of the same stories: 'I spent 100k on a degree in sculpting, and now I owe 100k'. Does a hundred thousand dollar education in sculpting really provide value to you? I'm not saying people who are truly interested in art shouldn't go to school, but pick a school whose costs are better aligned with your ability to pay, and consider your ability to pay after graduation. Maybe apprenticeship / community college / just starting a business is a better use of your time and money.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoOn the other hand, 18 year old wannabe sculptors are probably poor judges of value. And why should they be? It's no crime for your talents and experience to be outside business accounting. The judge of value should be the underwriter. If Bank of America wants to buy some goofy kid a $100,000 sculpting business, let them bear the risk if that plan tanks. They can repo the chisels. Edited for grammar.
- jlgreco 14y agoThis I think is a key insight. Young people tend to be idealistic, that isn't going to change, and it shouldn't even be changed. We need that idealism in the world. A viable and palatable solution should therefore address the people enabling (or even encouraging) these idealistic young people to make poor decisions. There is a lot of money in convincing people that getting degrees that they won't be able to use is a good idea. A lot of money for everyone but the student.
- Evbn 14y agoThe US govt is underwriting the loans. That is what needs to stop.
- jlgreco 14y agoThis is an example of a case where the correct answer is not a popular answer. The people who need this advice seem to not accept it, only to eventually wish years later that they had.
- protomyth 14y agoThe other half of the story is that the institutions have no incentive to lower prices. They don't suffer for the lack of jobs and failure to pay. I often wonder if the US payed for the first two years of college / vocational school at a fixed rate (say: $15,000 per year or half what D.C. Public Schools spend per pupil) with the condition of an institution accepting the money that it cover tuition, room, board, normal fees (not, for example, airplane hours), and books what would happen? I get the feeling that two tiered pricing would result.
- jlgreco 14y agoAnother proposal I have heard is to somehow (there could be various methods of accomplishing this I think) put the the responsibility for paying off all or part of the loan on the institution if the student was unable to pay. There are a few rough points that would need to be worked out with this sort of system, but the overall intended affect would be to make institutions care about the employability of their graduates. If only half their graduates in a particular major were finding paying work in their field, then the university would be financially pressured to accept fewer students into that major in the future. Universities with deep enough pockets to pay off the inevitable debt would be free to offer what they please, the idea being that a university is in a better position to make a rational and responsible financial decision in that matter than someone fresh out of highschool. However universities strapped for cash would be discouraged from taking advantage of students by selling them unobtainable dreams. (This I think would be particularly effective at putting a damper on the predatory nature of for-profit 'schools')
- guylhem 14y agoYou are arguing for price control, which will likely cause a shortage.
- rayiner 14y agoThe problem with liberal arts degrees is that the job prospects are heavily dependent on the brand recognition of the school. You can have an expensive school with decent job prospects, or a cheap school with terrible job prospects. And this is where I think you've got a market failure in education. It's not that there aren't any jobs for people with non-technical/non-math degrees, it's that employers would much rather hire someone with average grades from a top school than someone with great grades from a cheaper school. Pedigree becomes like brand names for handbags--inflating the price of education far beyond the cost of education, and almost eliminating competition by reducing the fungibility of the products.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoProblem is, that's not the way it actually works in practice. In practice, the American university system is financially upside-down. * Very expensive, very wealthy institutions like Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and MIT can afford extensive financial aid for almost every single admitted student. Students at these institutions usually receive enough tuition reductions and scholarships to bring the education into their affordable range before loans come into the picture. * "Cheaper" public universities have all had their budgets cut by strapped state governments and their associated greedy taxpayers (see: Prop 13 in California). They also have much smaller endowments and little extra income. They've started biasing their admissions more towards out-of-state and international students as much as state law allows them to, because those students pay the full non-resident sticker-price (which includes little to no state subsidy defraying the cost). As a result, the average student at a "cheaper" public university will now pay or borrow a larger price, closer to the sticker-price, than a student attending an elite private university. * (Of course, the worst-off remain those who went to very expensive private universities/colleges that aren't actually that rich or that good, and who therefore have tens of thousands of dollars of debt for very little education. But they were always screwed.)
- Evbn 14y agoBut out of state students are intentionally overpaying and don't deserve much sympathy. In state students get a pretty cheap deal still, only the ones who don't get admitted have cause to complain.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoBut out of state students are intentionally overpaying and don't deserve much sympathy. No, they are most definitely not intentionally overpaying. Not all public universities are educationally equivalent. UC Berkeley is just better than the University of Nevada, and I would not say that a student who chooses the former over the latter has justly chosen to hurt themselves financially. They've chosen the superior education, which is supposed to be what matters.