20 ms·
As far as I know, it is the only "social network" that allows you to grow intellectually through participation. This describes Wikipedia more than HN.
by tptacek 1y ago
As far as I know, it is the only "social network" that allows you to grow intellectually through participation.
This describes Wikipedia more than HN.
- abuani 1y agoThere are still a select few subreddits where this is true as well. I genuinely miss 10 years ago getting into random shit like double edge razors, home brewing and woodworking and how supportive those communities were to get into. Some communities _do_ exist, but once they get past a certain size it becomes worthless
- tptacek 1y agoAskHistorians is still pretty great too.
- culll_kuprey 1y agoTurns out gatekeeping works
- tptacek 1y agoAbsolutely. Why wouldn't it? All the useful forums are "gatekept" in some fashion; AskHistorians just has an especially legible set of gates.
- bigiain 1y agoWhat was that weightlifting sub that worshiped "Brodin" and "The Church Of (Something? Maybe Iron?)" I am not a weightlifter, but I'd occasionally visit that sub just because of how welcoming and supportive it was.
- b112 1y agoYou mean this forum? http://139.177.194.177/worst.date.ever.jpg http://139.177.194.177/worst.date.ever.jpg
- einsteinx2 1y agoOh man this brings back memories! I can’t remember the name either but they would say stuff like “whey-men” after these “prayers”. I think at some point it kind of devolved into the same jokes over and over as those subs tend to do so I drifted away, but it was fun for a while.
- Dracophoenix 1y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/swoleacceptance/ https://www.reddit.com/r/swoleacceptance/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Brodinism/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Brodinism/
- oncallthrow 1y agoWikipedia is an encyclopedia with a kinda-social-network-ish-in-the-broadest-possible-definition attached. HN actually is a social network.
- chubot 1y agoI don’t think its a social network — it’s content-focused, not person-focused You upvote stories on Hacker News and Reddit, as opposed to following people
- Imustaskforhelp 1y agoYes but I feel like HN does have some lore from time to time as well. I had seen a recent comment where the commenter shares his personal experience with the author and how they helped him in a stackoverflow question and how it led to their startup and saved their asses. Oh yeah just remembered, it was nadernx (sorry if the name wasn't right), and people in the thread were asking if it saved their asses or what they did and they said that they donated to patreon Like, its not following exactly per se but it was a discussion outside of the post itself which was about python. And it was great. I feel like this could be an example for the parent comment as well as how I personally feel like HN is more social networky than say wikipedia but not at twitter or trad social media level I guess.
- akerl_ 1y agoIt's wild to see two people in a row, one that's saying Wikipedia isn't a social network and then that HN/Reddit aren't. Maybe we should all stop trying to narrowly class what's allowed to be a social network?
- b112 1y agoThis describes Wikipedia Does it? Modern Wikipedia is OK, I suppose, but I feel its glory days are far behind it. It's so gated. And any time I try to participate, it's like walking through waist deep mud. I almost feel it forces you to shrink to participate. Maybe I keep trying to edit long-standing articles, which have custodians that feel ownership over the content? And you're editing articles with less gatekeeping? I frankly don't even try any more. I've heard the same from others.
- akerl_ 1y agoThat’s more an argument that Wikipedia is a social network with a high barrier to entry than an argument that it’s not a social network. Facebook was a social network even when the barrier to entry was “must have gotten in to an elite school”.
- b112 1y agoI didn't say it wasn't a social network. I was specifically addressing the conjoined "intellectual growth + participation" claim, by saying the 'growth' wasn't there. I even joked that it feels you're shrinking intellectually, to participate.