3 ms·
- Grades don't mean anything, so there's no reason to give people bad grades. I know I quote this all the time on HN, but only because it's accurate: "A grade c
by Alex3917 14y ago
- Grades don't mean anything, so there's no reason to give people bad grades. I know I quote this all the time on HN, but only because it's accurate: "A grade can be regarded only as an inadequate report of an inaccurate judgment by a biased and variable judge of the extent to which a student has attained an undefined level of mastery of an unknown proportion of an indefinite amount of material."
- Despite the fact that grades don't predict workplace performance at all, companies still use them to hire people. (Basically because it's a legal way to keep out black people.) Because of this, schools can boost their US News & World Report rank by giving people better grades, since starting salary factors into the rankings in many years.
- Schools are basically run as businesses these days, and that's what the customers want. Asking why schools keep inflating grades is kind of like asking why McDonald's keeps making their chicken nuggets taste so fucking delicious.
- mc32 14y ago-I don't know about you, but if I had to hire between 50 A students and 50 D students, I'd hire the A students. -Schools in Africa grade students, who are they trying to keep out? -Some schools might be run as a business; I think most aren't (they're subpar and inefficient). If they are, they're run as a mom and pop. If San Francisco schools were businesses, they'd have gone bankrupt and displaced a while ago.
- Alex3917 14y ago"I don't know about you, but if I had to hire between 50 A students and 50 D students, I'd hire the A students." The science suggests that if you we're assigned both groups at random, you wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
- lbo 14y agoAny citations for this? I can buy that this is the case for some jobs, from some school districts, for many students, across a certain distribution of grades, some number of years after graduation. I have a hard time believing that a D student who barely passed college will do just as well in a new consulting job as an A student, simply because the A student probably has actually learned a hell of a lot more useful information.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 14y ago"Any citations for this?" There are only a handful of studies because it's considered kind of a dumb question to ask. But Alfie Kohn references some of them in his books, I think in What Does It Mean To Be Well Educated? But the ones that exist consistently show the same thing. This includes the huge internal study that Google HR did: "Unfortunately, most of the academic research suggests that the factors Google has put the most weight on — grades and interviews — are not an especially reliable way of hiring good people." "When all this was completed, Dr. Carlisle set about analyzing the two million data points the survey collected. Among the first results was confirmation that Google’s obsession with academic performance was not always correlated with success at the company." http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/03/technology/03google.html?ex=1325480400&en=e71cadb22a20a3c4&ei=5088 http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/03/technology/03google.html?e...
- lbo 14y agoThe article you link to and quote, while saying grades are less important than Google thought, goes on to say that progressive Google after doing this study and at least partially implementing its new system "Last week...hired 6 people who had a below 3.0 GPA." 6 out of an estimated 200 weekly hires. That's a far far cry from D student = A student and nobody can tell the difference. Also, all of the direct quotations from Google people in the article talk about years spent in academia, degrees like doctorates, and interviews being the poor predictors. Some of the best programmers I know dropped out of high school. Doesn't mean I couldn't tell apart a room of A students from D students or that I couldn't use the A students better for many jobs I might need to fill.
- Alex3917 14y ago"That's a far far cry from D student = A student and nobody can tell the difference." That's what the results found. Google just didn't change their hiring policy accordingly.
- yummyfajitas 14y ago(Basically because it's a legal way to keep out black people.) Could you apply the principle of charity and think of any other possible reason why employers might care about grades? Like, I dunno, employers believe grades are correlated with conscientiousness, agreeableness and intelligence, and employers find these traits useful?
- Alex3917 14y ago"Could you apply the principle of charity and think of any other possible reason why employers might care about grades?" If you knew twice as much about the issue, do you think you'd be more or less charitable than you are today?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI try to apply the principle of charity no matter how much I know about something. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity It's a far better way to learn from other people than simply assuming they are racist/communist/terrorist and dismissing them.
- Alex3917 14y agoI think that's a reasonable principle to apply, but at least as stated by the Wiki article it refers to avoiding "attributing irrationality, logical fallacies or falsehoods to the others' statements, when a coherent, rational interpretation of the statements is available." Now if law schools have a rational argument for why they still use grades to determine who gets into law school even though it has been shown that GPA has zero correlation with ability as a lawyer, and that its main effect is to keep black people out of law school, then I'd love to hear it. But note that they would need a rational reason for doing this, not just any reason. (Which Malcolm Gladwell talks about here: http://www.newyorker.com/online/video/conference/2008/gladwell http://www.newyorker.com/online/video/conference/2008/gladwe...)
- 14y ago