5 ms·
"There exist historical examples of quackery which wasn't, e.g. hand washing." And homeopathy, which even James Randi admits was more effective than western me
by Alex3917 14y ago
"There exist historical examples of quackery which wasn't, e.g. hand washing."
And homeopathy, which even James Randi admits was more effective than western medicine in the 1800s. (In the video that was submitted to HN recently.)
- derleth 14y ago> homeopathy, which even James Randi admits was more effective than western medicine in the 1800s I hope you realize how worthless this statement is in a discussion of modern medicine. Also, it's incredibly racist to call 'medicine that works' 'Western medicine'. Do you also call 'math that works' 'Western mathematics'?
- Alex3917 14y ago"Also, it's incredibly racist to call 'medicine that works' 'Western medicine'." I assure you that's not how I'm using the phrase.
- derleth 14y ago> I assure you that's not how I'm using the phrase. Except it is. Medicine can be practiced by anyone who knows how, not just people with the right-colored skin.
- TillE 14y agoThe placebo effect is remarkably powerful. But there's nothing special about homeopathy.
- carbocation 14y agoThat's very misleading without providing proper context. In Hahneman's time, medicine was actively harmful and virtually never actively helpful. The risk benefit analysis would not come out in favor of getting treatment. In contrast, homeopathy does nothing. It's placebo. And giving placebo, it turns out, is safer than actively sticking dirty instruments into your patient's bloodstream and giving them bacteremia. In that context, the statement makes sense, but is still obviously tongue in cheek. Homeopathy never worked, but medicine at the time actively harmed.
- Alex3917 14y ago"In contrast, homeopathy does nothing. It's placebo." Well, yes and no. It is a placebo, but the research seems to show that placebos do significantly more than nothing, at least for some diseases (pain, depression, etc.). The comment I was replying to was asking for examples of where things that were once believed to be quackery were later vindicated. At the time homeopathy was believed to be quackery. In fact the reason the AMA was launched was to combat homeopathy because it was cutting into their profits; one of their first acts was to launch a 'propaganda department' to scare people off of homeopathy. (Essentially the AMA was founded to kill people. They knew they were less effective than homeopathy at the time and they knew they were killing people, but they just didn't care because they wanted the money.) The point is though that at the time homeopathy was actually significantly better than western medicine. Now if the definition of something not being quackery is if it's the best treatment available to us at the time, then homeopathy couldn't have been quackery by definition, since it was in fact the most scientifically advanced (or however you'd phrase it) form of medicine available at the time.
- derleth 14y ago> At the time homeopathy was believed to be quackery. It still is believed to be quackery, because it still is quackery. > In fact the reason the AMA was launched was to combat homeopathy because it was cutting into their profits; one of their first acts was to launch a 'propaganda department' to scare people off of homeopathy. (Essentially the AMA was founded to kill people. They knew they were less effective than homeopathy at the time and they knew they were killing people, but they just didn't care because they wanted the money.) This sounds like conspiracist nonsense. Do you have a single cite for any of it?
- Alex3917 14y ago@Derleth Read the book Homeopathy: The Academic Years. Even the AMA admits that this is true, and they give the book a very favorable review on their website. (And also the AMA talks about their propaganda department on their own timeline of their history.)
- carbocation 14y ago
- frobozz 14y agoHomeopathy was more effective in the 1800s because the patient was only under threat from their ailments, rather than having to worry about the doctor killing them as well. Early medicine was in a large portion, quackery. Some of it was actively harmful. Something that has no effect whatsoever will be more effective than something that harms and doesn't cure.