3 ms·
It's forced deregulation by circumventing the rules. One interesting argument is that deregulation increases the supply of drivers hence making them inefficien
by mattmanser 14y ago
It's forced deregulation by circumventing the rules.
One interesting argument is that deregulation increases the supply of drivers hence making them inefficient. As they are inefficient the prices increase. Interesting POV.
However given that the American Medallion system doesn't seem to be working, there aren't enough drivers and a medallion is worth so much, screw that theory.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-08-31/ny-cab-medallions-worth-more-than-gold-chart-of-the-day.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-08-31/ny-cab-medallions-w...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicab#Regulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicab#Regulation
Uber have hit a nice niche in America where they're taking advantage of over regulation. And the really odd thing is the cities saying Uber is A-OK, they're just idiots. They should deregulate instead of making a special Uber clause, it's bad government. But that's the way it works I guess, the ludicrousness of local politics around the world always makes me sad.
Note that their success isn't really anything about customer obsession, the only reason for their success is because of regulation. You wonder whether that's a happy accident or the entire private car thing is a cover and they're deviously cunning. All respect either way.
Speaking from a country without these sort of onerous regulation where a taxi is a trivial and cheap thing to get in minutes, any city getting rid of the medallions will put uber out of business practically over night.
The problem they'll face is that as grow they will probably put themselves out of business by encouraging mass deregulation, and then they'll be expensive with no value add. Their customer base will dwindle as new customers won't want to pay the premium for a chauffeured car and that'll be the end of it. Probably a good 5-10 years away yet though.
- mathgladiator 14y ago> rid of the medallions will put uber out of business practically over night. Really? When I get Uber, I get a great car-ride and an experience. The driver is dressed for business. I don't get: * some cabbie's chatter * crappy radio * some odd smell that I can't describe * seats without holes This is what I think of when I get uber. There's nothing to stop taxi's now to compete on the above things. I love Uber because of the professionalism of the drivers. The App that powers it is a nice-have.
- eric_bullington 14y agoIt's funny -- except for the seats with holes, I count all of the things that you mention as downsides of traditional taxis among the things I love about traveling by taxi and other public transport through Asia, Africa, and yes, New York and DC.
- 3143 14y agoYes, who wouldn't count aspergillosis as an upside of taxis? If I don't have enough fever and lung bleeding, I'm just not happy.
- mathgladiator 14y agoThen, by all means, continue to use the taxi system. I find it shameful that there is a defacto-forced monopoly. Another comment hand a link to DC's taxi system about illegal taxis. It seems strange to me that we have regulations on something that... isn't a limited resource. I can understand enabling regulations for limited resources like electrics or water, but transportation? I'm... boggled to think what benefit comes from a regulated taxi system beyond customer safety? Sure, we should have a registered driver and some customer protection laws, but... a monopoly? I like the idea of competition to deliver a diversity of goods to a diverse set of markets. I'm glad for Uber because it's changing the game and stirring the status-quo. Sure, it's more expensive, but's it raising the industry which will cut into the regular taxi's margins. I'm optimistic that taxi's average quality will improve to steal away some of Uber's customers.