4 ms·

What does Android need "in terms of usability, features, and overall experience"? I personally don't feel that anything is missing. I'd love a denser battery ma

What does Android need "in terms of usability, features, and overall experience"? I personally don't feel that anything is missing. I'd love a denser battery maybe.

idle_zealot 1y ago
I'd like to see some experimentation with core system UI, like the notification/quick settings thing. I'm not convinced the weird double-pull-down hybrid thing Android uses is a good design. I'd love to see some experimentation on a multitasking system that isn't clunky and inconsistent. Some of the tweaks Samsung puts in their Android spin could be nice. I'm not expecting a security-focused team to work on this stuff, but it's too bad that nobody is. I feel like we've settled on a pretty lousy core mobile operating system paradigm, and just generally wish people were experimenting and iterating on a variety of ideas.
- jampekka 1y ago
  A lot of people get Pixel and other "vanilla Android" phones to avoid spins like Samsung's.
- npteljes 1y ago
  I see what you mean, but GrapheneOS has completely different goals. Simply put, Graphene strives to be a secure, degoogled Android. Other than that, it has the same goal as the Pixel phones: to be as close to mainline Android as possible.
- phatskat 1y ago
  I watched my partner adjust the volume on her android phone (some Motorola phone) and first there was the vertical slider, she tapped it, and it expanded to idk 5-6 different volume sliders? I appreciate having the option, and I feel like that’s a lot to shove into the UI for a mobile device. I prefer the iOS model, though it’s not without its own issues. For iOS, if no media is playing, the volume buttons control the ringer/notification volume. If there’s music or a video actively playing, the controls adjust the playback volume. Honestly, my biggest gripe is not being able to easily set ringer volume while something is playing - I just did a quick test with Spotify open, and going to the settings app and adjusting the ringer stopped playback for the ringer sample to play.

What does Android need "in terms of usability, features, and overall experience"? I personally don't feel that anything is missing. I'd love a denser battery maybe.

idle_zealot 1y ago

I'd like to see some experimentation with core system UI, like the notification/quick settings thing. I'm not convinced the weird double-pull-down hybrid thing Android uses is a good design. I'd love to see some experimentation on a multitasking system that isn't clunky and inconsistent. Some of the tweaks Samsung puts in their Android spin could be nice. I'm not expecting a security-focused team to work on this stuff, but it's too bad that nobody is. I feel like we've settled on a pretty lousy core mobile operating system paradigm, and just generally wish people were experimenting and iterating on a variety of ideas.

jampekka 1y ago
A lot of people get Pixel and other "vanilla Android" phones to avoid spins like Samsung's.
npteljes 1y ago
I see what you mean, but GrapheneOS has completely different goals. Simply put, Graphene strives to be a secure, degoogled Android. Other than that, it has the same goal as the Pixel phones: to be as close to mainline Android as possible.
phatskat 1y ago
I watched my partner adjust the volume on her android phone (some Motorola phone) and first there was the vertical slider, she tapped it, and it expanded to idk 5-6 different volume sliders? I appreciate having the option, and I feel like that’s a lot to shove into the UI for a mobile device. I prefer the iOS model, though it’s not without its own issues. For iOS, if no media is playing, the volume buttons control the ringer/notification volume. If there’s music or a video actively playing, the controls adjust the playback volume. Honestly, my biggest gripe is not being able to easily set ringer volume while something is playing - I just did a quick test with Spotify open, and going to the settings app and adjusting the ringer stopped playback for the ringer sample to play.