5 ms·
"A few years ago, Long Island's North Shore University Hospital had a dismal compliance rate with hand washing—under 10%. After installing cameras at hand-washi
by greenyoda 14y ago
"A few years ago, Long Island's North Shore University Hospital had a dismal compliance rate with hand washing—under 10%. After installing cameras at hand-washing stations, compliance rose to over 90% and stayed there."
There's something seriously wrong with the medical profession if doctors only wash their hands 90% of the time, even if they know they're being watched. The words "reckless disregard for human life" spring to mind. How many deaths from infections per year could be prevented if hospitals just fired any doctors who didn't wash their hands? (Hospitals are a breeding ground for antibiotic-resistant pathogens like MRSA.)
Another interesting article is Atul Gawande's "The Checklist" [1] (later expanded into a book), which describes how the use of simple checklists, similar to those that pilots use, can prevent medical errors like operating on the wrong body part.
[1] http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_gawande?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_...
- 7952 14y agoGreat read, thanks. "The tasks of medical science fall into three buckets. One is understanding disease biology. One is finding effective therapies. And one is insuring those therapies are delivered effectively. That third bucket has been almost totally ignored by research funders, government, and academia."
- HarryHirsch 14y agoBucket 3 actually conflates public health and industrial safety. But one wonders where he got that idea from. There is ample research in public health, although perhaps not so much in the US, as a hospital or pharmco you cannot make money from it, and there is ample research on industrial safety as well. Airlines know a hell of the last thing - cockpit management, checklists, the works. I seem to remember Atul Gawande discussing this last item.
- bryanlarsen 14y ago"There's something seriously wrong with the medical profession if doctors only wash their hands 90% of the time" It's not that they're failing to wash their hands 10% of the time, it's that they're not washing their hands properly 10% of the time. We don't know if the incompleteness is significant or insignificant.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoExactly. And the previous problem wasn't that doctors and nurses weren't washing their hands, it was that they weren't washing them well enough. A quick wash as one might do before eating a meal is not the same level of washing as required for someone who has had their hands exposed to, say, MRSA or who is about to interact with a sick patient.
- konstruktor 14y agoIf that's what they actually checked, I can see doctors avoiding washing at the washing stations to not get caught with errors, which is even worse than getting it wrong. Talk about bad incentives... However, I would consider bad hand washing almost as neglegient. It's really not rocket science
- mcmatterson 14y agoActually, it is. This is a classic example of blaming the offender and not the process. Many hospitals (and this is borne out by research conducted by colleagues of mine; I'm not making this up) don't even have soap dispensers near sinks. Some hospitals mistakenly cross-label hand sanitizer and soap. Things are simple as housekeeping being late refilling paper towel dispensers cause drops in adherence rates. Can you carry a coffee cup from room to room, or is that an infection vector as well? What about chart updating? Do you wash your hands before or after touching a shared computer keyboard at the nursing station (answer: both, but many nursing stations don't have sinks). Blaming healthcare providers for not washing their hands is like blaming John Q Public for the housing crisis. The reality is much, much more complicated, and solutions to the problem are equally so. Healthcare is an incredibly complicated ecosystem, and even things are simple as hand washing are affected by dozens of factors, many of which are non-obvious at first. Root cause analysis and a judicious application of process change can help greatly, but the reality is that even simple things such as this do not change overnight in healthcare. It's harder than you think.
- Alex3917 14y agoActually there is some (possibly) good news on this. The CDC guestimates that central-line associated blood stream infections (CLABSIs) declined by 58% in ICUs, from 43,000 to 18,000. While this is only a rough estimate (not a measurement) based on poor data, Provnost (the guy in the New Yorker article) did refer to the results as "the first national success we have for patient safety in this country." (So this is positive, but note the implication.) The bad news is that the majority of CLABSIs happen outside of the ICU where there is no previous data. For these non-ICU settings, the CDC writes, "efforts to improve central line insertion might have limited impact." ("In 2009, an estimated 23,000 CLABSIs occurred among patients in inpatient wards and, in 2008, an estimated 37,000 CLABSIs occurred among patients receiving outpatient hemodialysis.") Also, CLABSIs account for only a very small percentage of all hospital acquired infections. Sources: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6008a4.htm/ http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6008a4.htm/ http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2011/03/14/prl20314.htm http://www.ama-assn.org/amednews/2011/03/14/prl20314.htm
- mcmatterson 14y agoI've worked in the healthcare field for many years, and have written protocols and supporting applications to measure practise standards around central line procedures (both in and out of ICU environments), and I can say quite definitively that while CLI infections as a result of procedural mistakes happen, they are not the low hanging fruit you think they are. If I had to nominate three low hanging fruits with respect to medical errors, they would be: - Hand washing. Colleagues of mine have researched and written extensively about this issue; study after study bears out the numbers people are quoting here. I'll source some references and reply with them. - Positive patient ID. The high flying stories about operating on the wrong patient, or on the wrong limb are one thing, but much more sinister is the issue of mislabeled blood work, specialist reports that are delayed due to mismatched paperwork, and medication mis-administration (more on this later). The degree to which healthcare professionals operate in an environment of mislabeled, misattributed, and simply missing documentation is astounding. - Medication Administration. A close colleague of mine has made a career around studying the practice of chemotherapy administration and the reduction of errors therein. The feedback she gets when presenting to practitioners is both very encouraging (they, of course, genuinely want to improve their practice), and also disheartening (very simple changes to process have simply never occurred to many front-line staff. They're consistently amazed that the idea of process improvement is even a thing). If you've ever been in the unfortunate position of having to see chemo being (properly) administered, you get to see firsthand how rigorous process controls are supposed to work. Every bag that gets hung is triple checked via different calculation paths, every patient's identity is re-confirmed every time (even patients that have been on the ward for months), and every interaction with infusion pumps is double checked by at least two nurses after every action. It's a great thing to witness; it's just sad that it isn't the norm everywhere in healthcare.
- firefoxman1 14y agoThings like "Jiro Dreams of Sushi" make you realise how few people treat their job as a "craft" let alone a profession. I can't remember a single time in school being taught that what I should be striving for in a "career" is mastery, excellence, or to even take pride in my work. When you don't care about your craft, stuff like this happens.