4 ms·
Given that he makes money off his books, and his books are only succeed or fail based on the strength of research supporting his point of view, he has a financ
by DannyBee 14y ago
Given that he makes money off his books, and his books are only succeed or fail based on the strength of research supporting his point of view, he has a financial interest in seeing a particular point of view succeed or fail.
He isn't simply "doing more than one activity in a field", he is, as you say, "setting yourself up as someone who is only judging on the merits when you have a financial interest in the judgement going a particular way".
BTW, conflicts of interest are not always monetary. At least in most fields, emotional (and other kinds) conflicts of interest are also prohibited.
Even ignoring him making money off his books, i'm not sure how you can say that, given his very passionate, subjective, argument in favor of one particular point of view in his books, he doesn't have an emotional conflict of interest in seeing his point of view succeed.
The idea that he can just "turn it on and off" so that when he's doing "science time" he's magically objective, and when he's doing "book time", he's not, would require a bit of straining to believe.
This is why, for example, in the legal field, judges are required to avoid the appearance of bias, not just bias.