6 ms·
SpaceX launches Starship megarocket on 11th test flight
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- d_silin 1y agoMission success, apparently. Next flight (in 2026) will launch next generation of Starship.
- woliveirajr 1y agoSpaceX got so good that even test flights that go well aren't news anymore.
- tonyhart7 1y ago[flagged]
- martin-t 1y agoCounterpoint: I dislike Musk because he's narcissist (subtypes: strongly communal, somewhat grandiose) but I don't wanna see spaceX fail. I just don't want abusive individuals in positions of power to have so much influence and to be given credit for the technical achievements of others.
- misiti3780 1y ago[flagged]
- King-Aaron 1y agoThe person above you is not wrong. Objectively people who fawn over Musks wealth and achievements without commenting on his nefarious qualities and blatant illegal behaviour recently need a reality check.
- misiti3780 1y agoyou need to break some eggs to make an omelette. it's not a coincidence that he is landing skyscrapers while you're talking shit about him on HN.
- toss1 1y agoYes, you need to break some eggs to make an omelette, but you do not need to spend more than a quarter-Billion dollars to help elect an administration working to end democracy in order to build a new spacecraft. In fact the spacecraft development would likely go better without any political intervention at all; it is widely seen as a distraction, and rightly so.
- misiti3780 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- toss1 1y agoNice offtopic whataboutism tic you have there... The point was that it is and was completely unnecessary for the particular omlette of making new self-landing spacecraft to break the particular eggs of spending all that time and money on politics. They are two entirely different pursuits, negating the GP comment. As for Harris, you are comparing an exaggerated number for total campaign spend to Musk's $250-$400 million spending as a single donor to a campaign in which he was not running. Comparing apples-to-apples, the Trump and Harris campaigns spent comparable amounts [0], and that is officially, not counting the massive media coverage Trump obtains for free. [0] https://www.ft.com/content/c3613e1b-c15d-47b8-a502-400c4114c09e https://www.ft.com/content/c3613e1b-c15d-47b8-a502-400c4114c...
- King-Aaron 1y agoIt should be noted also, that to normal people, the answer is yes - any politician wasting taxpayer money is a huge problem. It is absurd when people bring up the whataboutism as if everyone is as politically biased as they themselves are.
- dotnet00 1y agoHe deserves at least some credit, considering that he and Bezos are the only billionaires actually willing to put their wealth into chasing a vision. Books documenting SpaceX's early days make it pretty clear that Musk had a pretty significant role in putting in place the kind of thinking that has allowed SpaceX to blow open the commercial space market. Both also have at least some understanding of what they're paying for considering the tours and testimony from former employees. They also frequently thank the employees for their successes.
- gtowey 1y ago> He deserves at least some credit, considering that he and Bezos are the only billionaires actually willing to put their wealth into chasing a vision. As much as I love space exploration, I think it's actually a problem that so few people get to decide where so much money goes. Imagine if instead we as a society could put it towards better education, healthcare, public transportation so that the downstream effect is a society with many more aerospace engineers and astrophysicist, who dont have to instead focus on working corporate jobs just to afford housing. We might foster a society where space exploration is an ongoing societal goal instead of a playground for the elite.
- DoesntMatter22 1y agoWe put far more money into healthcare and education, by a literal order of magnitude. US spends 1.75 trillion on education per year, and 2.12 trillion on healthcare. People make it out like we aren't putting a ton of money into this stuff when those are literally are two biggest expenses. Space X is a drop in the bucket compared to that.
- dotnet00 1y agoI would love such a society, but I think the way space funding has been in most parts of the world shows that most people are just not good judges of what is and is not worth spending on. It seems very few people actually understand the importance of funding R&D that isn't directly improving their life, such that it takes some stubborn rich people to actually show that something is worth doing. Kind of like other countries all working on Falcon and Starship inspired rockets after seeing that the concepts can work. As other examples, we have particle accelerators (everyone knows about the colliders like LHC and assumes they're luxury projects with no relevance to improving lives, yet they led to the development and side-by-side refinement of synchrotron light sources, which are very important for modern science) and medical tech like what led up to mRNA vaccines and Ozempic. I would say we need a society that trusts experts and also holds said experts accountable, but then again, most of SpaceX's founding employees were not conventional aerospace experts, which was part of why they were able to question a lot of the corrupt/inefficient practices that traditional aerospace people dismissed as being standard and necessary practice.
- didibus 1y agoThe thing Elon does well I feel, is he takes real experts with know-how and talent, and puts them on the cool project they want to work on and just lets them cook. It sounds like a no-brainer management strategy, but it's surprisingly rare in practice. People will lend on random teams and projects, projects won't try to push any envelope but just be the next thing marketing or product came up with to boost some metrics or acquire some new customer, etc. Now I might be entirely wrong as I never worked at one of his companies, but it's the impression I get and most of his success, Tesla and SpaceX, I think he really managed to snatch the experts away from where they worked because of that. At least I think this holds for bootstrapping. And then that top talent left, and now since the major innovations have already landed, probably you can just churn out grunt out-of-schoolers to iterate and keep the lights on.
- DoesntMatter22 1y agoThat and the other thing I think he does that's just as important is go get things unstuck. When there is bureaucracy and managers getting in the way he gets it through. Very under appreciated IMO.
- panick21_ 1y agoThis isn't really the case. For Falcon 1 he hired a bunch experts but a pretty small handful. Then he hired a lot of really young hungry engineers. And its also hard to say that 'top talent left'. Because arguable some of the achievements after some of those people left is bigger then before. Tom Mueller for example build the Merlin engine, but claims to be more proud of the team he build that then went on to build Raptor. So clearly even while some talented people left, many others joined. SpaceX is not 'iterating and keeping the lights on' they are always going for something harder in the next iteration.
- didibus 1y agoWell, I don't mean it's not talented people that join, I'd assume it's all top grade students. But the initial best-in-class experts in the field I mean. I agree with a small handful, I think that's also necessary. A select few best in class experts is ideal, because too many and they don't have room to lead and start stepping on each other and entering debates and so on. You take best in class experts in the field, give them a team of top tier workers under them that can follow and deliver. In turn they learn from the best. I think for Starship and Starlink he followed the same playbook though. He brought in best in class specialists to bootstrap them.
- gtowey 1y agoAs one of the aforementioned, yes I don't mind seeing his projects blow up. I'm sure Starship will make it to orbit, but I'm betting that the claim of 100 tons to orbit is where it will miss the mark. And that is the crux of the issue IMO -- because getting the new rocket engines to be reliable enough can always be accomplished by dialing back on its efficiency and overall thrust capabilities. I'm waiting to see if they will be able to deliver on its claims.
- sixothree 1y ago[flagged]
- Sparyjerry 1y agoHe's not a nazi though. It's literally only those on the opposite political spectrum saying that. He waved and literally described the motion in words as he was doing it.
- Rebelgecko 1y agoI believe the woman who gave him his Auschwitz tour leans politically conservative and yet...
- sixothree 1y ago[flagged]
- dzhiurgis 1y ago[flagged]
- mlindner 1y agoThat's a completely unfair thing to say. It's a meme at this point even that if you elevate your arm upwards at any angle between 90 and 180 you're automatically treated as having made a nazi salute. What matters is the context around it, as has always been the case. And the context is not that of a nazi salute. The people who insist on it being a nazi salute are just disingenuous people pushing an angle for their own virtue signalling. It's tiresome.
- sixothree 1y agoYou're literally just wrong. It's not a meme "at this point". It's _always_ been a thing people recognize as a nazi salute. Plus the context surrounding Elon is certainly not supporting your argument. Actual truth" conspiracy theory, George Soros comments, "DEI must die", transgender comments, amplification of racism and harassment.
- ericcumbee 1y agothe people that hate musk are going to find something wrong with it "The Ship blew up on landing" and the musk lovers will do the opposite when things actually go wrong.
- spwa4 1y agoAnd the many more people he fired through DOGE? What will they do and how justified is that?
- bigyabai 1y ago[flagged]
- vardump 1y agoDo you have some insider information how SpaceX is managed?
- danpalmer 1y agoA bunch of info came out a few years ago. Shotwell is widely known to be effective and a great leader, and to insulate most people at SpaceX from Musk. She's the reason the Falcon program works so well. However things changed with Starlink, as it was an org controlled by a Musk loyalist and apparently got a lot of control very quickly internally. They prioritised loyalty over experience and capability and forced out some long term SpaceX folks who had made Falcon a success. Starlink was mostly ex Tesla and Boring people at the beginning I think. I think Starship is somewhere in the middle. It started as a Musk hobby project but has now got contracts and is the future of the company so Shotwell is involved.
- stinkbeetle 1y ago> A bunch of info came out a few years ago. Shotwell is widely known to be effective and a great leader, and to insulate most people at SpaceX from Musk. > She's the reason the Falcon program works so well. A bunch of rumors and hearsay is an unreasonable basis for making these kinds of claims with such confidence. The reality is the public does not know much about how Musk's companies and projects are run, and most people are emotionally ill equipped to have a rational discussion about it no matter how much we know of it.
- bigyabai 1y agoThis opinion is always so funny to me. Sometimes HN is afraid to judge someone on-grounds, other times they're afraid to draw conclusions that might make them look bad. Apple: "Nobody knows exactly how it's ran, but it's preeminently clear that Steve Jobs was a true MBA and had an almost perfect track record." Tesla: "Nobody knows exactly how it's ran, but we can say for sure it's probably not the social media edgelord/ketamine addict doing a bang-up job."
- Dig1t 1y agoAnother smashing success. It is cool that they've started adding more explanations and nice footage leading up to the launch. Explaining some of the improvements they are testing out like the crunchwrap heat tiles, I enjoyed the "Live Mas" joke he snuck in there. Just incredible overall to watch and very inspiring. Few things give me hope for the future like these videos do.
- IncreasePosts 1y agoTaco bell, taco bell, product placement for taco bell
- timschmidt 1y agoNacho, burrito, and enchirito, taco bell...
- cryptoz 1y agoThe video and info: https://www.spacex.com/launches/starship-flight-11 https://www.spacex.com/launches/starship-flight-11 (Liftoff is around 33 mins in)
- jfengel 1y agoStill not orbital? Well done, of course, props and snaps. But I'm looking forward to it getting up to full speed, and being able to get down from that.
- cryptoz 1y agoThey're testing specific things with no need for full orbit, although I think they reach verrrry close to orbital velocity. They want the payload dummies to 'de-orbit' quickly (from a suborbital trajectory). They could easily have gone orbital if they wanted to. I guess we'll see orbital demonstrations after a few splashdowns of v3 stack early next year.
- ls612 1y agoThey go up to 98% of orbital velocity on purpose to ensure they don’t create space junk if something goes wrong.
- reassess_blind 1y agoIf it gets up to that speed and something goes wrong, is the entire possible crash trajectory over the ocean?
- dotnet00 1y agoI think it depends on which specific step fails. The farther into flight it happens, the narrower the area over which the debris is spread. But, I think being over the entire ocean is unlikely, since the trajectory intersects with the planet, and that intersection point would also have to be in the ocean. Correction: the trajectory only intersects with the planet prior to engine relight testing. After that it's at ~50km [1] (though to be fair, if they make it safely through the relight, all testing so far shows they're likely to make it through most of reentry) [1] https://x.com/planet4589/status/1977917833825730792 https://x.com/planet4589/status/1977917833825730792
- ls612 1y agoThere’s a very short period of time where if it exploded debris would fall on the African continent which is an unavoidable risk of orbital flight out of the US. Other than that it’ll either fall in the Atlantic or Indian Ocean.
- greekrich92 1y ago[flagged]
- dgrin91 1y agoDespite Elon's perpetual over promises, starship is the closest thing humanity has to getting to Mars, and it is an impressive feat of engineering. Elon can be an asshole and also own the best piece of space hardware out there There is also a big difference between cant get orbital and won't (yet) get orbital. They pretty clearly can get orbital because their current route gets 99% of the way they. They actively choose not to because it's a test vehicle and if something goes wrong they don't want to have uncontrolled reentry. Also the hydrocarbons you mention are not even a rounding error in any sort of count that matters, so there is no real destruction of ecosystems
- oskarkk 1y agoI think greekrich92 when talking about "destroying the South TX ecosystem" meant their huge rocket production and launch site right next to some protected ecologically valuable areas in south Texas. The extent of the damage is debatable, they are of course legally required to minimize impacts, and even to do things like monitoring the state of the wildlife in the area, and they passed environmental reviews under both Biden's and Trump's administrations. Anyway, if anyone would want to build a new launch site, it must be on the coast, as near the equator as possible (for launch efficiency because of Earth's rotation), and as far from populated areas as possible, and that correlates with ecologically valuable regions. So that's the cost of progress.
- panick21_ 1y agoPretty much everybody know that launch site and exclusion zones for human are great for wildlife. Turns out, what is destroying the environment is humans living in places, large areas with few humans usually do pretty well. But instead of focusing on that, we need to test if dolphins get hearing damage from rockets. > So that's the cost of progress Its actually the benefit of progress. The cost of progress is having to close the beach and having to relocate a small village.
- reliabilityguy 1y agoI think these videos and the fact that this rockets actually works is one of the inspirational things in my life (and I am almost 40). I grew up loving everything about space (sci fi books and movies, astronomy in school, etc), and it was very bewildering not to see any progress basically for the first half of my life. Now it seems that humanity is back in the game, and it is amazing! Perhaps kids of my kids would be able to travel to the moon.
- bombcar 1y agoHonestly the most surprising thing isn’t that they’re doing all this stuff - they’re live-streaming it; failures and all. It’s so refreshing in a glossy PR-coated world.
- creer 1y agoThis launch got a massive amount of ad time for starlink. But as advertising goes, I'm not complaining about that one - just that saying that the PR was pretty thick there.
- atlgator 1y agoI'll never forget watching SpaceX launches during the COVID lockdowns. A beacon of hope in troubled times.
- 7e 1y agoThe original Starship payload was supposed to be 300 tons. The latest flight was 16. They’ve had to scale everything back because it’s been such a shitshow.
- mempko 1y agoYeah, I don't think the public understands how far behind they are. SpaceX was supposed to have moon missions in 2023-2024 time frame. NASA has said that Starship's timeline is "significantly challenged" and expects the vehicle will be years late. Apollo for comparison took about 8 years from announcement to moon landing. Space shuttle took about 9 years from approval to first flight. Starship has been in development now about 9 years. Despite it's iterative approach (and benefit of decades of space technology and learnings) it has been slower than both Apollo and Shuttle. Keep in mind Starship hasn't even achieved orbit yet. It's making the 2027 Artimis III moon landing increasingly unrealistic.
- chasd00 1y agomy favorite part of these has gone from liftoff to the purple plasma glow on re-entry. The glow is so perfect and beautiful it looks like an "artist's rendition" of what re-entry plasma would look like. I think the chopsticks catch still takes the cake just for the absurdity of it. It is a little depressing to realize some people pull things like this off yet i can't get my team to load a csv of records into a database correctly...
- rogerrogerr 1y agoLoading a CSV into a database is one of the tasks I offload to AI every time now.
- indoordin0saur 1y agoWhat AI do you use to do this? I can definitely get direction on what to do if it doesn't work but haven't found an agent that I can give this task to and it'll actually get it done.
- rogerrogerr 1y agoUsually just hand something a header and a few rows and ask it to give me a command/code/whatever to import it. Usually it can give you decent enough code to do a streaming import. Haven’t had any model since like 2023 stumble on import glue code. I don’t trust “agents” to do things on their own.
- socrateswasone 1y agoWhy are we going into space? Don't we already know what's there?
- panick21_ 1y agoWe also know what isn't there, and thus we plan to put it there.
- socrateswasone 1y agoNuclear weapons right?
- panick21_ 1y agoTeapots.
- dotancohen 1y agoStarship can't do that. Think more along the lines of communications satellites and humans on other planetary bodies.
- Mystery-Machine 1y agoSo you can have the technology that allows you to comment here (Starlink), or drive home from work (GPS), or cure cancer (various ISS research), or survive as a species, or mine space rocks so we don't fight nor pollute land for some scarce resource, or inspire children to dream big, materials science, water purification/generation, satellite communication, faster travel, physics, and a few more.
- ericcumbee 1y agoOr just more people being exposed to the blue marble effect the better.
- socrateswasone 1y agoI don't think being able to comment here is that valuable, GPS is fine but so were maps, curing cancer won't save anyone from dying anyway, surviving as a species is useless for an individual, mining space rocks won't stop fighting or polluting, I don't see how any of this would inspire children, etc etc. The answer should be obvious and easy to muster, instead we have to dig hard to come up with vague possibilities. That should tell you something.
- Veedrac 1y agoVery clean flight, almost all the way through, despite the intentional missing tiles and new flight pattern. No flap burn through, no issues with simulated Starlink deploy, I don't think they even lost any engines. They're clearly almost ready to scale this thing, if the next block version doesn't add a ton of problems back on. I'm not sure they're quite at the point of rapid reuse looking feasible, since tiles did come loose near the end of flight; not a problem for stage return, but definitely bad enough to warrant a meaningful correction before a (counterfactual) reflight. Overall they've clearly proven the recipe works.
- Polizeiposaune 1y agoThe boostback burn of the booster was short 1 engine (12 of 13 were running), though the one middle-ring engine that didn't light during the boostback burn did light during the first phase of the landing burn.
- dzhiurgis 1y agoStarship re-use is what this entire thing hinges on and we are still few years away from validating this.
- elteto 1y agoThe booster and most engines were reused in this test flight.
- dzhiurgis 1y agoYep but ship is where this is very difficult and far from validated.
- Veedrac 1y agoThe hard part of reuse is getting the thing back in flying shape. The booster part is actually just demonstrated, and this flight got us a fully-intact upper stage back, sans a few tiles lost to the wind and the landing being simulated. I can see room for skepticism on their rapid reuse plans, but skepticism on practicable reuse alone just seems discordant with the demonstrated success.
- rich_sasha 1y agoI find it amazing how sentiment extrapolates. Or maybe different people dominate on different threads. For ages people took it for granted Starship will succeed - even quoted cost per kg to orbit! Any comment saying it might still fail would be usually ridiculed and downvoted. Then Starship hit a few failures and the sentiment flipped completely - megalomaniac Musk had his hubris catch up with him. Now two successful launches later it's all gung ho again and great success. What I would like to say is that each success increases the overall chance of final success but there's still non trivial hurdles to overcome: - how well can they reuse the Starship - how much is the turnaround cost - how reliable they end up being after N launches - is the marginal return on building a new Starship positive A380 for example is a marvel of engineering and a technical success, but overall a commercial failure. I love flying on it, but they're not building them anymore. Similar case for the Concorde. I wish SpaceX well, I'd wish them even better if Musk wasn't a part of it, and let's see if they can cover the last 20% on this project. It's not a given to me that they will.
- andelink 1y agoRelevant primary source: https://www.spacex.com/launches/starship-flight-11 https://www.spacex.com/launches/starship-flight-11
- amai 1y agoFrom a purely design standpoint I still think the Saturn 5 looks nicer. Starship and Super Heavy somehow have a scrappy look.