9 ms·
The dollar is backed by taxing power of the US government - there are 300 million people who must pay taxes to US gov and the latter only accepts dollars. These
by DenisM 18y ago
The dollar is backed by taxing power of the US government - there are 300 million people who must pay taxes to US gov and the latter only accepts dollars. These 300m people will do anything to stay out of jail so they will trade whatever they have for dollars, thus insuring continuous demand year after year.
Money is not worthless.
- mjnaus 18y agoWhat you just said means absolutely nothing: "backed by the taxing power of the US government". First and far most, when everybody comes running to the US government to cash in on their dollars, there is no taxing power between heaven and earth powerful enough to satisfy all the creditors. And what do you imagine the government paying them with? For regular folks your statement is even more airy; when they start to figure out that their precious greenback has nowhere to go but down; are they gonna call their local representatives and ask them to change the dollars into gold (oops, no can't do, no more gold standard!) or euros/yen/whatever? Face it; the dollar is backed by NOTHING! And thank god most people don't realize this because we would be in a much deeper hole then we are now.
- pg 18y agoHave you acted on these convictions you seem to feel so strongly? Have you e.g. bought options to buy gold in the future at a price much higher than the present one?
- mjnaus 18y agoYes, I have. I have placed certain bets against the dollar. There is not a single doubt in my mind that the dollar will keep loosing it's value - with some minor exceptions in the short term. With all the billions of fresh created money (created out of thin air) being pumped into the US economy at the moment, the real devaluation of the dollar will pick up speed.
- pg 18y agoInteresting; what kind of bets?
- mjnaus 18y agoNext to buying small amounts of gold and silver, I have made a couple of lucrative forex transaction. Since I receive my income in euros in Europe and live in Thailand (baht rate is connected to the dollar), I have been able to increase my income quite a bit when the dollar hits new lows.
- yters 18y agoI'm probably missing something. If the dollar is worthless because it isn't backed by real goods, why are gold and silver valuable? Just because of common consent, i.e. most throughout history have considered gold and silver to be exchangeable for goods? If that's your reasoning, then the same applies to the dollar, except on a lesser scale.
- gaius 18y agoWell, quite. Tell that to Gordon Brown who flogged off the UK's gold reserves at 1/3 of the current price (he even announced weeks in advance that he was planning to dump a load of gold on the market which further drove down the price).
- mjnaus 18y agoCommon consent doesn't have much to do with the real value of precious metals. The reason why gold and silver are "valuable" and the dollar is not, lies in the fact that gold and silver can not be created "out of thin air". This was exactly the reason why, in better days, currency was backed by gold or silver, thus transferring the intrinsic value of precious metals onto the currency.
- yters 18y agoThe dollar cannot be created out of thin air either. The constraints are not physical, sure, but they are there.
- utnick 18y agoIs gold really any less arbitrary than paper money? Couldn't advances in technology create cheap alternatives to gold that would destroy its value?
- likpok 18y agoIndeed. This is the point that gold-standard people don't seem to get. Gold is just as arbitrary as anything else. More so, even, because it is absolutely /useless/ in any aspect except as a valuable. It's too soft to do anything with. Furthermore, it has issues with being a finite supply that is occasionally moved around (no control over the monetary supply). Steel. Now /that's/ what we should back our money with. Everybody needs steel. At least until carbon nanotubes get popular...
- mjnaus 18y agoIt is actually its finite amounts that make it valuable. Anything that can be produced at will not hold up as a currency.
- potatolicious 18y agoBut we do create more of it (or dig it out of the ground and refine it, as it were), there's simply a practically finite rate at which we can grow the gold supply. So the value of gold should in fact deflate over time, as we produce more and more of it.
- mjnaus 18y agoNo, we don't. No matter how you look at this, gold is not "created". Cold is extracted from gold mines, the only thing humans can do it try to find, but they simply can not create it. Key here is that the total amount of gold on this planet is finite - not the production or extraction rate - making it truly valuable. Same thing applies to other natural resources such as oil, natural gas and diamonds.
- 18y ago
- jerf 18y ago'What you just said means absolutely nothing: "backed by the taxing power of the US government".' Money is recursive. The US government's acceptance of dollars is the base case. The US Military, Police, and various other force-directing agencies are the induction step. It isn't entirely worthless, nor is its worth entirely intrinsic. It lives in the middle. Glib generalizations that put it on one end or the other are wrong.
- mjnaus 18y agoI never stated that the dollar would be completely worthless, I only stated that it's backed by absolutely nothing. For all the same reasons, it does not matter that the US government accepts dollars. It matters what you will get back for those dollars. When, if ever, people will come to collect en masse, the US government will have no means what so ever to pay of those creditors, in other words, the government becomes insolvent and the dollar plunges.
- bokonist 18y agoCurrencies do not need to be backed by anything. They are simply intermediary goods, valuable because of a coordination game. There is no "collecting in mass". The dollar is the final good. The U.S. has no debts outstanding in anything other than dollars ( which is quite a nice situation to be in).
- mjnaus 18y agoIn my world, goods and services I purchase are the final goods, not the money I need to purchase them. About "collecting en masse", I guess time will tell. You might be right, for those holding large amounts of dollars (China for example) a "run on the US government" would be a bad thing, they're better off unloading their less valuable currency gradually and exchanging them for something with intrinsic value such as gold and silver. And in the mean time, the dollar will keep on loosing it's value.
- eru 18y agoWhen the creditors come, they will get back what they have borrowed: Dollars. Why should that be a problem? Remember: The US is indebted primarily in Dollars. Not in cars, gold or Euros. They can not go bankrupt for lack of their their own currency.
- Xichekolas 18y agoActually what he described is the basis for Fiat money systems everywhere. As long as the government demands that all entities doing business pay a tax in dollars, the dollars will be worth something to those entities. (It's worth freedom to do business.) From Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_currency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_currency The unifying feature of all fiat money is its (typically exclusive) acceptability to the government for payment of taxes. And yet again: http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Fiat_currency http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Fiat_currency Therefore the integrity of the financial system requires that there be a different ultimate form of backing, such as the acceptability of the fiat currency in payment of tax.
- DenisM 18y agoYou missed my point: US citizens will always accept your dollars because they want to stay out of jail. This means they will give up whatever they have and give it to you. The entire sum of non-dollar poessions(goods and labor) of all US citizens are backing US dollar.
- pg 18y agoMore generally, you can/have to use dollars for any transaction with the government. E.g. buying oil leases, grazing rights, etc.
- mhartl 18y agoAnd this applies not just to transactions with the government, but to any (U.S.) transactions whatsoever. You can see evidence of this on every dollar bill: "This note is legal tender for all debts, public and private [emphasis added]". It's illegal to refuse dollars, even for private debts. Threatening people with imprisonment to force them to accept dollars should seem fishy, though, and it's a hint that there's something rotten about fiat currency. Unlike commodity money, whose supply is limited by physical scarcity, fiat money can be expanded without limit, and the result is both sad and predictable. Consider: (1) monetary expansion benefits debtors, who can repay debt in inflated dollars; (2) U.S. monetary policy is set by the Federal Reserve, whose officials are appointed by the U.S. Federal Government; (3) the U.S. Federal Government is the world's largest debtor. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what is going to happen in this scenario.
- DenisM 18y agoWhile no one can legally refuse dollars to settle debt, it's perfectly legal to refuse any other dollar transaction. If I trade my chickens for fish and fish only there is nothing illegal about this.
- jhancock 18y agoif you do not make any money, your tax is zero. therefore, no jail time and no need for dollars.
- bokonist 18y agoIf you do not make money, you starve. Also, it's not just taxes - there are tens of trillions of dollars of outstanding dollar denominated debt. Millions of people and corporations have contractual obligations to deliver dollars. If they renege on those obligations, their creditors will seize very real assets (buildings, houses, etc).
- jhancock 18y agono one that participates in this forum is in danger of starving due to lack of income. you could make zero money in the next year and not starve. someone will feed you. it is also highly improbable that anyone that reads HN would find themselves without a roof over their head by making zero dollars within the next year. these fears are highly overrated. the fears are real for others. and to build an economy around solving these problems is interesting.
- bokonist 18y agoStop being pedantic. At some point everyone must trade their labor for goods other people produce. This transaction incurs taxes that you must pay in dollars, or you go to jail.
- jhancock 18y agonot pedantic at all. I have not made a net income to be taxed in years (yes local governments have profited from transactional taxes; sales taxes). As a consequence, I have not starved to death (obviously) and am not writing this post from jail. However, I have provided much value to my community in terms of goods and services. If you were to come to my community and ask about me, you will find many that value my contributions to our local society. I believe now is a great time to think about alternate economies instead of holding steadfast to rules that govern the current domain.
- corentin 18y agoI think you may be confusing two things here. The federal debt indeed is backed by the taxing power of the US government. That is, if you lend it 100 dollars today, you can have some confidence that you will get them back plus interests in the future. But the dollar isn't backed by much; it's backed by trust, which itself depends on the acts of the Fed (i.e. it really depends on what the Fed does). If you can buy two widgets for 100 dollars today, you don't have much confidence that you'll be able to buy them in the future. In either case, there's nothing to guarantee your purchasing power. With gold, your purchasing power isn't 100% protected either (because new gold is digged every day) but at least you're much safer from arbitrarily high inflation. But you are obviously correct when you say that money isn't worthless.
- cellis 18y agoIf you really want to know what the dollar is backed by, you should read Confessions of an Economic Hitman.Yes, some may take what was said in the book for hyperbole, but i firmly believe that the dollar is backed by the power of the U.S. Military.But what the dollar is backed by is irrelevant. Currency values will rise and fall with the general prevailing theories of economists;in the end all modern monetary systems are simply backed by the belief in the system.For the US dollar, that belief stems largely from the network effects of the dollar, as well as the relative ease of doing business and fair regulation in the U.S. Pearls to swine, people will continue to lose money shorting the dollar. Its like Microsoft...you can love it or hate it, but its not going away.
- icefox 18y agoWell for the past year Microsoft stock has continued to slide down.
- helveticaman 18y agoI suspect the only kind of passive income that works is slavery.