3 ms·
We honestly need the next administration to shut down our coal- and oil-fired power plants, and shut down our coal mines. Physically ensure they can't be restar
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
We honestly need the next administration to shut down our coal- and oil-fired power plants, and shut down our coal mines. Physically ensure they can't be restarted.
With the precedents handed down from Trump, that could likely be concluded before the courts have a chance to weigh in. The owners will be entitled to cash damages. But the industries will have been politically destroyed.
(Note: leave natural gas alone. It’s cheap and relatively clean. It’s also geopolitical export currency.)
- kayodelycaon 1y agoI don't think escalation and revenge is a good strategy for our country long term. This shit shouldn't be normalized.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> don't think escalation and revenge is a good strategy for our country long term I agree, but if the precedent is set it doesn’t go back in the bag because it skips an administration. Unilaterally disarming doesn’t work.
- lesuorac 1y agoEnding qualified immunity and letting people be prosecuted for stuff not authorized by the government would be enough. There's no reason ICE should be protected from the courts for arresting US citizens.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoThis would still be ex post facto. We need to be able to put guys like Stephen Miller and the DOGE bros in jail based on existing violations. > no reason ICE should be protected from the courts for arresting US citizens Nor those in the military executing unlawful orders.
- coldpie 1y agoIt's not revenge, it's just good policy. It will be vastly cheaper for the US if we pay these industries to shut down and replace them with renewables. We could pay every person working at a fossil fuel job their full wage to do absolutely nothing until they die and still come out ahead. Climate change isn't a joke, it's going to be really, really, really, really expensive.
- themafia 1y ago> It's not revenge It's a kneejerk response designed to obviate a political problem. Historically these will be perceived as vengeful and undemocratic. > it's just good policy. It's good policy if you only consider _one_ outcome. Good policy is made from compromise. Yours explicitly denies that, to the point where I'm very sure there are _better_ policy choices available to us. > We could pay every person working at a fossil fuel job their full wage to do absolutely nothing until they die and still come out ahead. I'd like to see your math on this. > Climate change isn't a joke Then shipping manufactured items from China should be a huge concern. If you're not making the replacement equipment in the USA for the USA then you are just ignorantly displacing the problem. To the point where this all begins to look like a modern colonial strategy solving local problems at the expense of global outcomes.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> these will be perceived as vengeful and undemocratic They're vengeful. I don't think they're undemocratic. > Good policy is made from compromise Not always. Sometimes there is a correct answer. For energy costs and political stability, continuing to subsidise coal has turned into a corrupt and expensive mistake.
- themafia 1y ago> I don't think they're undemocratic. Fair; however, you do share this country with people who do not explicitly agree with all your decisions. Which is why I flagged this as a /perception/. Those still have actual consequences whether you agree with them or not. > For energy costs and political stability, there seems to be only one here. You're ignoring national security and resistance to natural disasters. There's the part of the argument you want to have; unfortunately, it explicitly touches on several other complicated ones. Ignoring them introduces unnecessary peril to your own stated goals. If climate change is that important then you should really be seeking to rationalize the common concerns surrounding this approach and working to address them through incorporation into your strategy. There's more than one thing to "get right" here.
- sixothree 1y agoSince when is sensible policy considered revenge?
- lesuorac 1y ago[flagged]
- nine_zeros 1y agoWhile in understand where you are coming from, I don't think we should completely destroy coal mines. They should be kept around as a backup. That said, I would be 100% onboard with a future administration applying a massive tax on the wealthy to fund solar plants, rooftops, and wind energy - 100% paid for by the wealthy who are profiting from this administration at the expense of our lives.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> I don't think we should completely destroy coal mines. They should be kept around as a backup Totally agree. I’m talking about taking out heavy machinery. Turbines. Elevators. Generators. I’d also argue for doing this on federal lands, or federally-permitted equipment, first.
- JuniperMesos 1y ago[dead]
- lovich 1y agoI have disagreed with you on a number of discussions, but I am 100% behind you on this.
- cmxch 1y agoOnly if you’re willing to have the environmental interests directly cut large salary-replacing checks to people in coal/oil heavy regions. Not government checks, but from the private industry that displaces coal/oil.