9 ms·
Decentralizing things like this is never ever going to work. In terms of running it... my mom/sister/dad/cousin are not going to host this themselves. They migh
by whalesalad 14y ago
Decentralizing things like this is never ever going to work. In terms of running it... my mom/sister/dad/cousin are not going to host this themselves. They might depend on me to do it, but even I'm not going to run a decentralized social network myself. There's too much liability involved. Not to mention, it's a pain in the ass.
I want to hack and work on my own ideas. That's why I trust my mail hosting to Google. Sure, they read all my emails and analyze me for marketing. That's a small price to pay though. I get a rad web client, Apple Mail + iPhone support, and never need to worry about my email server. Anyone remember qmailrocks.org? I used to sit for hours messing with and playing with qMail back in the day. I've done it. I've hosteed mail servers for friends and family. What a pain in the fucking ass!
Same for hosting. I love configuring infrastructure. I taught myself HAProxy, load balancing, nginx, and clustering years ago when people were still using mod_python. I built a FreeBSD box for fun with old parts an an old SSD the other weekend. I have quite a few linodes running right now. But it's also a pain in the ass. Because of that, I also enjoy pushing my personal site to Heroku and not worrying about it ever again. git push, boom done.
A lot of people take things like Facebook for granted. We all bitch and moan about all kinds of issues it has or features it lacks, but it's a gargantuous network that virtually everyone that I know or care to talk to is on it. My family and friends back home in LA where I grew up, my new friends in Sweden that I met while abroad recently. It's got a handy mobile app (that was luckily redeveloped recently) and best of all it's 100% free.
This decentralized stuff is nonsense. There's too many layers of crap. Even if there was a one-click-deploy social network for people where all they needed to do was rent a server somewhere... someone is still running that server and you need to worry about them snooping your data or whatever else the neckbeards are worried about.
Remember Diaspora? Hah.
- EvanAnderson 14y agoISPs hosted email servers for individuals for years. I don't know why hosting a social networking server for Customers would be any different. I don't know enough about the tent.io API to decide how I feel about it, but I think that history with SMTP, NNTP, etc, shows that decentralized protocols with servers hosted by a diversity of third-parties (instead of a single Facebook, Google+, etc) can work.
- danielsiders 14y agoWe are launching a hosted version very soon, and expect others to as well.
- ericmoritz 14y agoI would think ISPs would love to host folk's social network servers. Just think of all the social data they'd have at their disposal for whatever they could use it for.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI disagree. The software will get easier over time until it is literally plug-and-play. But it won't happen without projects like this happening.
- andrewflnr 14y agoThis. It's easy to assume that software will be hard to configure forever. We just have to not let that happen. Lots of people manage to set up their routers, right? How much more complicated does this need to be?
- wmf 14y agoExactly. iOS and Android are based on Unix but they're easy to use. There's nothing stopping the same thing from being done to servers.
- stcredzero 14y ago> There's nothing stopping the same thing from being done to servers. Wordpress.
- whatshisface 14y agoWordpress takes a simple thing (One-way flow of text from author to reader) and makes it easy. It could be a lot harder to deal with something where information was going both ways. A very important part of an interactive webpage is how it changes over time and with different inputs. Web developers have no trouble looking at some example widgets and imagining all the possible things a user could make them look like, but most people (might) have trouble doing that. The same thing, I imagine, applies to running servers. I only know a bit about operating servers, but from my experience there is a complete, unremovable complexity that comes with having a powerful set of tools. Perhaps, we could remove almost all the configurability from the instant-server kit, but then why would you want to run your own?
- 14y ago
- nicksergeant 14y agoSo decentralized email (you know, "email") doesn't work? Your mom/sister/dad/cousin are going to use a service that allows them to post status updates, instead of just using Twitter. Just like your mom/sister/dad/cousin use Gmail for email, and not their own server.
- joshaidan 14y agoAnd there's also IRC as an example of a decentralized service that is still alive.
- cyarvin 14y agoThis might be (just a little) too pessimistic. The sweet spot both Tent and Diaspora are/were aiming for is one where most users use somebody else's service, but a few crazy neckbeards choose to self-host. The neckbeards who actually care (often quite unreasonably) about privacy, etc, provide a very useful service to the ordinary users - they keep the central service(s) honest, ie, keep them from turning into Facebook. Because it's possible to escape, because the neckbeards keep that possibility open, the ordinary users are not captured. At least, that's the theory. Diaspora didn't execute on it. Tent, well, we'll see.
- sbarre 14y agoI agree. This is like Usenet, or further back the old Fidonet days where most people accessed through a small local hub, but you still had the nutty people who ran their own node. Make it easy for people to participate casually, but also make sure that people can customize to their liking and exert full control over their own stuff if they wish to, without causing trouble to the rest of the network.
- Sami_Lehtinen 14y agoNo, nodes were usually BBS systems. If you wanted to use same protocol, then you did run your own point usually. Of course there were a few sysops with their own nodes. But Point was the usual way of personally joining the network using official protocols. Of course most did use qwk and bluewave etc to get messages quickly without setting up systems without mandatory zone mail hour etc. Didn't you run your own point / node? ;)
- sbarre 14y agoYou're right, I got my terminology mixed up (it's been a while heh).. Point is what I meant.. Thanks. :-)
- lhnn 14y agoSPOT ON CHAP. This is truly, exactly it. I don't expect my mother or friend to run a Tent server. But imagine Facebook were a Tent/Diaspora host. People would have left in DROVES by now if another, somewhat equal host could migrate their data in and provide better user respect.
- sgwil 14y agoThough I believe the idea is that Tent be more like an email server: email hosts are able to offer their own features and interfaces, yet remain interoperable with one another. Most people don't host their own email service, but most people do benefit from using email – and the best part of it is that there's no monolithic Email Inc. that could someday go bankrupt and bring everyone's emailing days to a close.
- k2enemy 14y agoDecentralized protocols seem to work well for things like email and web sites though. I think the idea is that most people will use a provider to run the server, but it is possible/easy to switch between providers. The lack of lock-in and network effects at the provider specific level mean that competition can do its thing and people won't have to put up with shenanigans like retroactive privacy changes a-la Facebook.
- mej10 14y agoYou say decentralized services never work, and then give an example of the most successful one: email. I don't know why you are assuming that everyone will have to run their own. Also, it seems very cynical/naive to think that just because such systems aren't currently working/won't currently work with given social structures, that this will always be the case. Do you disagree?
- wdewind 14y agoEmail essentially IS centralized at DNS. Any decentralized social network has to solve the lookup problem: how do I find people. None really do this in a way that's going to make it fundamentally different than what we have now. I can't help feeling that the natural outcome of decentralized social networking is that people eventually start hosting them for mom and dad, then a few friends, then start companies, then we are back to facebook. Someone, somewhere is going to have to have a database of names mapped to servers. Centralization is, in an abstract way, present in so many of our social structures, that yes, I disagree that within a capitalist economic structure (one which is optimized for sharing of services rather than individualism, ie: non-technical users simply wont do this unless the work is done for them, like facebook did) it would be next to impossible for something like this to work. People quite simply don't want to deal with this shit, and centralization brings efficiency and management amongst many other things.
- jackalope 14y agoEmail is a decentralized service and the task of discovery is solved with DNS. If you have an address, jackalope@example.com, you can find out where to send the message if it is explicitly set (MX record) or not (A record). I don't see why you can't do the same with a decentralized social network.
- wdewind 14y agoAnd who runs the DNS servers?
- 14y ago
- jre 14y agoI would be willing to pay for a hosted version of a decentralized network that respect my privacy. Decentralized is important to me not because I want to run my server, but because this mean I can switch providers or choose to run my server if I want. Plus, it's really just an advanced version of email. I mean, you could build a fancy social network on top of SMTP. And SMTP is decentralized, so I don't see any reason why this shouldn't work. Regarding Diaspora, it seems that tent.io is starting with the protocol instead of the frontend, which seems more promising to me.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- innernette 14y ago> That's why I trust my mail hosting to Google. Imagine if GMail only allowed you to send Google Mail(TM) to other @gmail.com addresses. Email's decentralization allows us to ignore the fact that other people may be reading on an iphone, yahoo mail, or emacs. Decentralization isn't (only) for neckbeards. It's about giving users freedom to socialize with those who choose a different client. Isn't it bizarre that I use LinkedIn, you use Facebook, therefore we can't be friends? First we build the decentralized social network, then I will decide if I want to social network with you via google, yahoo, or emacs.
- mikeash 14y agoI can't understand how you say that decentralized systems can never work, then point to e-mail as an example of doing it right. E-mail is the classic decentralized communication system!
- slapshot 14y agoExcept, as GP points out, the vast expansion of the email system was followed by a huge number of users running to GMail and a huge number of domains running to Google Apps and other hosted platforms. My parents don't run mail servers. My employer no longer runs a mail server (outsourced to a common third-party provider), and I used to run a mail server but I gave up on it and fell back on Google Apps when I needed one. Running a mail server is a huge pain and once centralized systems became available (Hotmail, then Gmail and Google Apps) most users fell back on them.
- wmf 14y agoEven a situation where 99% of people use a handful of providers is a lot more free than everyone being forced to use a single provider.
- jeremyjh 14y agoThis. And if you put just a tiny bit of effort into it and own your own domain you can switch providers at any time for little effort. A world of difference from the Facebook trap.
- drgath 14y ago"Decentralized" don't mean outsourced vs self-hosted. It just means there isn't a central/core part of a network that everything relies on. Outsourcing of decentralized systems is very popular (see: email, web hosting, DNS, etc.)
- unixnoob 14y agoYes. I think most people miss this. For peer-to-peer to succeed I think there needs to be some amount of "re-education". There needs to be a shift in thinking. Many of these things that others are doing for you (email, etc.) can just as easily run from your machine instead of theirs. You do not need the same capacity and ability to scale as they do. What makes it all possible is NAT traversal. That is the fundamental problem being solved which takes us back to peer-to-peer and the orginal model of the internet. The rest is all just pre-configuration and UI.
- darkhorn 14y agoAre you high?
- unixnoob 14y agoWhile I know nothing about tent, the _idea_ of running an overlay among trusted peers (family, friends) if done right++ is not much work or liability at all. It is possible to not have data being forwarded through a third party server (after all what is the idea behind STUN, TURN and similar methods? the goal is NAT traversal not forwarding traffic) so your point about snooping being an issue for _any_ decentralized network seems moot. Tent might not be the solution you'd like, but that doesn't mean the very notion of decentralized networks is bogus. The internet started as one. Then we added "too many layers of crap" because the whole thing was a hack from the beginning, duct tape and chicken wire, and for some reason users can't be trusted to use an open network responsibly. Now we have to add more layers just to get back to the original idea. It doesn't mean the original idea sucked. ++ Simply because you haven't seen anyone do it right yet (for your purposes) or you can't do it yourself does not mean it cannot be done. Third party services will always have their place. We need them. But the idea that _social networks_ (the networks, not the stuff you choose to do over them; not everyone wants to "hack on stuff", some might just want to do simple things) must all be run by third parties (whose "business model" is snooping and trying to guess intent) is absurd. Hopefully that is not what you are advocating.
- mrinterweb 14y agoI think that an open protocol for social networking could really take off. Different hosting companies could offer different services for the same underlying protocol. Some hosts may offer free hosting with advertisements, while others may offer the service without adds for a monthly rate, etc. Ideally, if people were unhappy with a hosting company, they could migrate their data to a different host. I like the comparison of a protocol like this to a protocol like email. I really believe that social networking should be a protocol and not an exclusive service owned by other companies. Diaspora has some similarities with Tent, but there are a lot of differences between Tent and Diaspora.
- riffic 14y agomy mom/sister/dad/cousin are not going to host this themselves. They might depend on me to do it, but even I'm not going to run a decentralized social network myself. There's too much liability involved. Not to mention, it's a pain in the ass. That's not the point. Those aren't the ones decentralization benefits. Decentralization will benefit other organizations, such government agencies, companies, non-profits, NGOs, etc. These organizations most likely have other services running on either their own infrastructure or they have some one else paid to host it. They benefit by retaining control of the namespace and ability to post a message without relying on a centralized service.
- nine_k 14y agoRemember Skype? It's very much peer-to-peer, with various node types, third-party traffic forwarding, encryption end to end, QoS issues to manage, NATs and firewalls to handle, etc. Did you try to install a recent Skype version? Download an executable, run, enter your login and password, and it just works. Execution matters, you know.
- cjoh 14y agoI'd say "my mom/sister/dad/cousin" is not going to host this themselves is a tricky assumption. I can imagine a world where my mom creates an account with a service that kicks off an EC2 instance on her behalf without her even knowing it. Want to build a facebook that scales cheaply? Make every user bring their own server. On top of that, make "bringing a server" as easy as a registration process.
- njharman 14y agoExactly. There is a reason we don't dispose of our own garbage. It's just worth paying some one else (plus efficiencies of scale). Infrastructure like social network is garbage. People don't wanna deal with it, don't care how it works, and are glad to externalize the cost. They just want their waste to magically disappear. Or, to maintain / increase their social status with friends and family.
- biomechanica 14y agoThe existing decentralized software out there (except for maybe bitcoin which is actually quite simple and a couple others) are not sufficient for normal people because of the way they are presented. Diaspora failed horribly because it was hard to use on your own system. That and it was rather scrambled at launch. The code was horrible. If there was a system that acts like current centralized systems out there it wouldn't be a matter of it being hard. The technology is becoming easier and easier. If presented properly, there is no reason a decentralized system couldn't attract normal people. Facebook and Google make it appear that what you are using is actually on your system. That you control the information. Yet, the so called "small" price of that is you have to give away personal information to them. With a system that is completely decentralized and secure and keeps people's privacy while being so easy to use that my Mother can use it w/out problem, centralized systems would be in danger. So yes, the current way of doing things is for geeks. That will change with projects like Tent. Centralized services will ultimately fail simply because of the violations to peoples privacy are starting to really piss people off. Normal people. Like me. If I want to share my music playlist with my friends, I should be able to do it. I also don't like being censored and watched, which is exactly what these systems do. Don't believe me? Search it. And if you don't mind that type of thing for convenience, then I'm not sure you understand freedom. And by the way, those "neckbeards" are the ones who are going to set things straight. A decentralized system doesn't necessarily have "servers". Everyone will be their own type of server.
- TimJRobinson 14y agoMany people thought the same about live journal and Blogger in the early 2000's, then Wordpress came along. This (and diaspora) are Wordpress for social network profiles.