2 ms·
> Surely the more relevant metric is the percentage of households with at least one gun? Why? > Similarly, it surely is better to compare the same country ove
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Surely the more relevant metric is the percentage of households with at least one gun?
Why?
> Similarly, it surely is better to compare the same country over time instead of comparing different countries which differ in many additional respects?
Mass shootings are a distinctly American phenomenon. (One happened today. It probably won't make any front pages [1].) It absolutely makes sense to ask what we're doing wrong relative to other countries.
> If your thesis that the availability of guns causes school shootings is true, you should expect to see school shootings going down in the U.S. as the practical availability of a gun goes down
One would expect to see more school shootings in states with "more permissive firearm laws and higher rates of gun ownership" [2]. One does.
I also challenge the notion that fewer households with more guns makes guns less available to kids. A household with one or two guns is probably keeping track of them in a way one with a new gun every Christmas is not.
82% of school shooters don't grow up in stable homes [3]. Practically all of them are from gun homes. More critically, the prevalence of two-parent households has been going up since the mid-2000s [4]. So have mass shootings.
(Kirk's assassin grew up in a stable home. He used the rifle his family gifted him to do the deed [5].)
[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4gvgr7w2yko https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4gvgr7w2yko
[2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35449898/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35449898/
[3] https://schoolshooters.info/sites/default/files/shooters_myth_stable_home_1.15.pdf https://schoolshooters.info/sites/default/files/shooters_myt...
[4] https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-resurgence-of-the-two-parent-family https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-resurgence-of-the-two-parent-...
[5] https://people.com/tyler-robinson-received-rifle-as-gift-used-assassinate-charlie-kirk-11810901 https://people.com/tyler-robinson-received-rifle-as-gift-use...
- rayiner 1y ago> Why? Because 0 to 1 is the big step. > A household with one or two guns is probably keeping track of them in a way one with a new gun every Christmas is not. That’s a theory, but what’s the evidence? Do you think farmers locked up their guns? Kids used to bring guns to school for sports shooting back in the day. > Mass shootings are a distinctly American phenomenon. Sure, but it’s been exceptional in terms of widespread gun ownership for longer than it’s had a major problem with mass shootings. When doctors are trying to diagnose people, the first thing they ask is: “what have you been doing different?”
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Because 0 to 1 is the big step This doesn't answer why 0 to 1 households with guns is a bigger step than 0 to 1 guns. > what’s the evidence? It's a hypothesis. The observation is monotonically more guns, monotonically fewer gun households, more school shootings, all while single-family households become more and then less prevalent. The corollary of the first two is more guns per gun-owning household. The implication of the last is it's not causative. The hypothesis is the larger number of guns in fewer households may have something to do with the mess. > it’s been exceptional in terms of widespread gun ownership for longer than it’s had a major problem with mass shootings Source? My understanding is these data weren't well tracked before WWII. > When doctors are trying to diagnose people, the first thing they ask is: “what have you been doing different?” Why wouldn't the NRA's radicalisation from a gun-safety orientation to Second Amendment extremism count?