3 ms·
> while the percentage of households with guns has gone down, significantly The civilian gun stock has grown significantly since the 60s [1]. These data, toget
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> while the percentage of households with guns has gone down, significantly
The civilian gun stock has grown significantly since the 60s [1]. These data, together, seem to imply a large (but declining) number of households with a couple of guns and a few households with a ridiculous number of guns.
Of course, the dagger in your argument is that American divorce rates are not extraordinary [2]. Our gun ownership and school shooting rates are.
Given school shooters [3] (and now political shooters) come from gun-owning households, it seems fair to pin the blame for these events on that fraction of one third of American households who maintain private armories.
[1] https://www.thetrace.org/2023/03/guns-america-data-atf-total/ https://www.thetrace.org/2023/03/guns-america-data-atf-total...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_divorce_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_divorce_r...
[3] https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/27379/Study-Adolescent-school-shooters-often-use-guns?autologincheck=redirected https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/27379/Study-Adoles...
- robotresearcher 1y ago> Of course, the dagger in your argument is… Reading comprehension moment: the parent comment was carefully not claiming either side of the argument. Your response, and the downvotes, are as if they declared for the locally unpopular side. They did not.
- mft_ 1y agoNot sure I agree, based on (more subtle?) reading comprehension. > The conservative view simply is that this correlation is causal, while the liberal view is that the causation runs in the opposite direction of the correlation. You're right that the poster doesn't make it clear (deliberately or not) but the use of the word "simply" feels sympathetic, and suggesting that the "liberal view" is that correlation and causation are opposed (when that would typically be counter-intuitive) sounds critical. At least, that was my comprehension of the post, as someone without any skin in the game.
- maleldil 1y agoSuggesting both points of view as reasonable is an indication of what they really think.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Your response, and the downvotes I upvoted rayiner’s comment because it’s argued in good faith. (What would be in bad faith would be putting forward a third party’s flawed argument without pointing out the flaws for shits and giggles.)
- rayiner 1y agoI certainly believe in the argument so no problem ascribing it to me.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoFor what it's worth, I don't think the science on this is settled. I think the evidence swings towards too many irresponsible Americans having too many guns. But the single-family bias in school shooters is something I hadn't read about before. One takeaway from that evidence, however, could be that single-parent homes should have restrictions on how many guns they can own, what kind of guns those can be and how they must be stored. The fact that American single-family kids turn into school shooters, while the rest of the (rich) world's do not, continues to speak to a uniquely American nexus. The most obvious and evidenced one is our prevalence (and loose regulation) of guns.
- mindslight 1y agoPersonally I think it's a bona fide societal mental health problem. The American ideal of hyper-individualist self-reliance implies you are utterly on your own. This means that everything that happens to you is your fault, and you can only right it by taking responsibility to fix it yourself. But it's kind of impossible to simply stop yourself from being bullied, because "if you could have, you would have". Coupled with entertainment that primarily revolves around people aiming guns at each other while barking orders, then shooting to see who gets to be in charge, then more aiming/barking. Guns are framed as the obvious solution to problems, and the media reinforces this by making sure every shooter gets their 15 minutes (or days). Frankly with this setup, the surprising thing is that there aren't more mass shootings.
- rayiner 1y agoSurely the more relevant metric is the percentage of households with at least one gun? Guns are durable goods that people don’t dispose of, so of course they accumulate. My father in law has boats, old cars, and guns piling up around his house. But school shootings typically aren’t committed by people rummaging through their grandparents’ basements, right? Similarly, it surely is better to compare the same country over time instead of comparing different countries which differ in many additional respects? If your thesis that the availability of guns causes school shootings is true, you should expect to see school shootings going down in the U.S. as the practical availability of a gun goes down.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Surely the more relevant metric is the percentage of households with at least one gun? Why? > Similarly, it surely is better to compare the same country over time instead of comparing different countries which differ in many additional respects? Mass shootings are a distinctly American phenomenon. (One happened today. It probably won't make any front pages [1].) It absolutely makes sense to ask what we're doing wrong relative to other countries. > If your thesis that the availability of guns causes school shootings is true, you should expect to see school shootings going down in the U.S. as the practical availability of a gun goes down One would expect to see more school shootings in states with "more permissive firearm laws and higher rates of gun ownership" [2]. One does. I also challenge the notion that fewer households with more guns makes guns less available to kids. A household with one or two guns is probably keeping track of them in a way one with a new gun every Christmas is not. 82% of school shooters don't grow up in stable homes [3]. Practically all of them are from gun homes. More critically, the prevalence of two-parent households has been going up since the mid-2000s [4]. So have mass shootings. (Kirk's assassin grew up in a stable home. He used the rifle his family gifted him to do the deed [5].) [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4gvgr7w2yko https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4gvgr7w2yko [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35449898/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35449898/ [3] https://schoolshooters.info/sites/default/files/shooters_myth_stable_home_1.15.pdf https://schoolshooters.info/sites/default/files/shooters_myt... [4] https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-resurgence-of-the-two-parent-family https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-resurgence-of-the-two-parent-... [5] https://people.com/tyler-robinson-received-rifle-as-gift-used-assassinate-charlie-kirk-11810901 https://people.com/tyler-robinson-received-rifle-as-gift-use...