4 ms·
Being an old dog that still cares about gaming, I would assert many games are also not taking advantage of current gen hardware, coded in Unreal and Unity, a ki
by pjmlp 1y ago
Being an old dog that still cares about gaming, I would assert many games are also not taking advantage of current gen hardware, coded in Unreal and Unity, a kind of Electron for games, in what concerns taking advantage of existing hardware.
There is a reason there are so many complaints in social media about being obvious to gamers in what game engine a game was written on.
It used to be that game development quality was taken more seriously, when they were sold via storage media, and there was a deadline to burn those discs/cartridges.
Now they just ship whatever is done by the deadline, and updates will come later via a DLC, if at all.
- formerly_proven 1y agoUnreal and Unity would be less problematic if these engines were engineered to match the underlying reality of graphics APIs/drivers, but they're not. Neither of these can systematically fix the shader stuttering they are causing architecturally, and so essentially all games built on these platforms are sentenced to always stutter, regardless of hardware. Both of these seem to suffer from incentive issues similar to enterprise software: They're not marketing and selling to either end users or professionals, but studio executives. So it's important to have - preferably a steady stream of - flashy headline features (e.g. nanite, lumen) instead of a product that actually works on the most basic level (consistently render frames). It doesn't really matter to Epic Games that UE4/5 RT is largely unplayable; even for game publishers, if you can pull nice-looking screenshots out of the engine or do good-looking 24p offline renders (and slap "in-game graphics" on them), that's good enough.
- pjmlp 1y agoPretty much it.
- Uvix 1y agoThe shader stutter issues are non-existent on console, which is where most of their sales are. PC, as it has been for almost two decades, is an afterthought rather than a primary focus.
- MountainTheme12 1y agoNo, that's not the reason. The shader stutter issues are non-existent on console because consoles have one architecture and you can ship shaders as compiled machine code. For PC you don't know what architecture you will be targeting, so you ship some form of bytecode that needs to be compiled on the target machine.
- Uvix 1y agoAgreed. I didn't mean to say consoles' popularity is why they don't have shader stutter, but rather it's why implementing a fix on PC (e.g. precompilation at startup) isn't something most titles bother with.
- MountainTheme12 1y agoIt's not just popularity, Epic has been trying really hard to solve it in Unreal Engine. The issue is that, because of monolithic pipelines, you have to provide the exact state the shaders will be used in. There's a lot of that, and a large part of it depends on user authored content, which makes it really hard to figure out in advance. It's a fundamental design mistake in D3D12/Vulkan that is slowly being corrected, but it will take some time (and even more for game engines to catch up).
- jayd16 1y agoYou still don't get it. It's just not possible to ship a precompilation of every shader permutation for every supported hardware permutation.
- Uvix 1y agoThat's why I said "precompilation at startup". That has users compile for their precise hardware/driver combination prior to the game trying to use them for display.
- formerly_proven 1y ago
- jayd16 1y agoImagine living in a reality where the studio exec picks the engine based on getting screenshots 3 years later when there's something interesting to show. I mean, are you actually talking from experience at all here? It's really more that engines are an insane expense in money and time and buying one gets your full team in engine far sooner. That's why they're popular.
- jayd16 1y agoThey're both great engines. They're popular and gamers will lash out at any popular target. If it was so simple to bootstrap an engine no one would pay the percentage points to Unity and Epic. The reality is the quality bar is insanely high.
- gyomu 1y agoIt is pretty simple to bootstrap an engine. What isn’t simple is supporting asset production pipelines on which dozen/hundreds of people can work on simultaneously, and on which new hires/contractors can start contributing right away, which is what modern game businesses require and what unity/unreal provide.