3 ms·
The simplest living beings have some idea of self and other, and life and death, and so understand, even implicitly, what it means to be killed and dying. So a
by nis0s 1y ago
The simplest living beings have some idea of self and other, and life and death, and so understand, even implicitly, what it means to be killed and dying. So a primal impulse to fight back kicks in whenever something feels mortally threatened.
Bacteria might not be able to communicate that they don’t like being killed, but I don’t think their view of it changes despite that lack of ability to communicate. More complex and conscious organisms, like monkeys, take offense to lies and deception. Or dominant animals with higher-level cognition might punish members of their groups who display jealous traits. Who taught these animals human social mores? No one, they’re going purely off instinct.
There are primal instincts which drive some of these behaviors which have absolutely nothing to do with human culture or society. To paraphrase what I’ve already said, morality doesn’t change, but only how you think of it does. Humans are the only animals who elegantly communicate their selfishness about moral behaviors, and get away with it.
And I don’t get the point of the rest of your post about the Middle East, but I am going to leave it at that.
- necovek 1y agoOnly one paragraph was about the Middle East, where "Western" morality is on full display, mostly to show that there is no one true goodness anywhere. You seem to be using a definition of morality that's a lot narrower than what we generally call moral and morality: https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/moral_1?q=moral https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/englis... I don't think your examples show morality at work, but I already realised we disagree on this topic, and I am sure you'll interpret the dictionary definitions differently too. Thanks for the discourse and enjoy the day.
- nis0s 1y agoWhatever is moral stays that despite disagreements, it’s more clear cut than people would care to admit.