4 ms·
I think everyone supports market making. And market makers should take a reward for holding onto a stock (even for a short period of time) But the benefits of
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I think everyone supports market making. And market makers should take a reward for holding onto a stock (even for a short period of time)
But the benefits of market making tail off with frequency - would you mind waiting another hour for a deal at 518 or even a whole day? To a trader its unacceptable, to an investor, its a coffee break.
But what drives HF trading is trading - as markets become more efficient trading opportunities, as you point out, vanish. So smaller amounts of arbitrage need to be leveraged with larger amounts of cash to get the same return.
We want nice safe retail banks who make a tiny fraction on the movement of wages from company to employee to shops each year, and bundle it all up into mortgages and ATMs. They keep society oiled
By the same token we (society) wants nice safe boring market makers. Who efficiently take a tiny fraction of each trade and keep liquidity in the markets for investors.
I cannot prove it but the amount of margin gained for investors who hold for >1 year through the existence of HF trading is probably small - you can now get 515 offered quickly. 5 Years ago? 520? If that would have prevented you investing, maybe it was the wrong company.
- tptacek 14y agoA lot of people support "market making", but then talk about frontrunning trades in situations that are morally and technically equivalent to market making. Computer nerds tend to assume the role of "market maker" is more formally defined than it really is. Really, there are just liquidity sellers and liquidity buyers.
- wglb 14y agoAnd are obligated to stay in the market and provide liquidity, no matter what the circumstances.
- makomk 14y agoUnfortunately, HFT firms playing at market maker don't actually have any obligation to stay in the market and provide liquidity. There are some people that want to see this changed (for example, I heard the head of the financial stability department at the Bank of England complaining about it on the radio the other day) but until then...
- wglb 14y agoThis is not true. Some HFT firms have agreements with the exchanges that require them to be in the market providing liquidity no matter what. This is not true of all HFT practitioners, but major key players are required to do so.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoFirstly I am not a fan of the term buying liquidity - I prefer injecting liquidity or extracting liquidity. In exact also but at least gives the one sided nature of the deal secondly I also dislike the justification that HFT is ok be ause it is Market making. I see it as a form of Market making trying to capture the equivalent of the consumer surplus - I was quite happy to sell my shares at 505 and old boring mRket maker would turn and sell them at 510 tomorrow - but HFT nips in buys from me at 504 and old Market maker has to take them at 506 no real liquidity has been added to the Market in that situation - a deal was ready and raring to be done and another just reduced margins. Not bad, ethically fine but not actually adding much to the system thirdly I dislike broccolli
- tptacek 14y agoLiquidity costs money. It has buyers and sellers. Obviously, those aren't terms I'm making up. I know you're not making up "injector" either, but that term is less precise. If you want to sell at 505, an HFT can't change that. Place a limit sell at 505. If you're not willing to hold out for 505 and want to sell at the market price, you're a liquidity buyer paying a premium (of some sort) for getting out of the market right now. People love to point out this scenario where the HFT buys something at $9 that a human would have paid $10 for. They never acknowledge the fact that by doing that, the HFT assumed the downside risk; the HFT is now to some extent illiquid and exposed to the market. If the price goes to $11, the HFT wins, sure. But if the price goes to $8 --- which should be equally likely, else why sell --- the HFT is fucked. Broccoli is delicious. Here's what you do: blanch it in boiling water, just like 20-30 sec, shock it in ice water, and then dry it off. Put it in a bowl, douse it in olive oil, shake some fish sauce into it, cumin, chili flakes, maybe a little sriracha or maybe some lemon juice. Shake the bowl up. Now grill it. Yum. Eat it with sriracha mayonnaise, which is the highest calling of mayonnaise.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoYes, the HFT assumes the risk, for it is acting as a Market maker. My point was that there already was a Market maker there - another is not more liquidity. Liquidity is a binary term IMO. Having two Market makers in same product does not make more liquidity it just makes liquidity cheaper. That might benefit the seller but makes no difference to the exchange function in the comics, when Superman is protecting Metropolis and Supergirl turns up, she cannot do anything the Man of Steel could not do - she just looks better in tight blue Lycra. Kudos for your recipie. Edit removed my dumb, knee jerk, unappetising broccolli recipie/comment on state of English cooking in my childhood. Nevermind.
- smoorman1024 14y ago"as markets become more efficient trading opportunities, as you point out, vanish. So smaller amounts of arbitrage need to be leveraged with larger amounts of cash to get the same return." This is contradictory. If there is only one offer of 100 shares at an arbitrage price you take it and the arbitrage is gone. You can't leverage more money to get higher returns, you're done. Market=efficient wipe hands and walk away.
- brazzy 14y agoYou can leverage more money to do the same arbitrage on more stocks, and to get faster computers and connections to be able to do that arbitrage faster than anyone else.
- FJim 14y agoForce quotes to be in sixteenths, the way they used to be and HFT disappears.
- stch 14y agoWhat makes you think increasing the tick size would help? HFT would still be at the front of every book, except in larger quantities now. Most people support MORE decimalization than less.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThis would dramatically increase the profits of HFT, and cause more people to do it. http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/subpenny_rule_responses.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/subpenny_rule_respons... http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/bigger_ticks_more_rent_seeking.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/bigger_ticks_more_ren...