That's not my impression at all. The logical "contradiction" it spends all its time talking about only applies if everything is strict binaries, and falls apart

That's not my impression at all. The logical "contradiction" it spends all its time talking about only applies if everything is strict binaries, and falls apart if we start addressing how much for every single point. Or to pull out another example: what level of overstep is necessary for it to become acceptable (praiseworthy?) to throw your shoes at George W. Bush?