3 ms·
Calling Nehru "installed" by Mountbatten misses the crucial context of the time. Nehru was the undisputed leader of the Indian National Congress, which had been
by prashantsengar 1y ago
Calling Nehru "installed" by Mountbatten misses the crucial context of the time. Nehru was the undisputed leader of the Indian National Congress, which had been the primary force behind the independence movement for decades and had overwhelming popular support. Mountbatten's appointment was more of a constitutional formality in the transfer of power, not an act of kingmaking. It's like saying the Chief Justice "installs" a newly elected president.
The same goes for the Aung San Suu Kyi connection. Labeling her a "compliant native" seems to ignore the 15 years she spent under house arrest actively fighting against a military junta. That's a pretty high price to pay for being a supposed puppet.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoPatel won the Congress presidency in 1946 and was made to step aside by Gandhi. Nehru, if memory serves me right, won only one vote. "House arrest" was reserved for compliant natives. Aga Khan's palace was another favoured location for the likes of Nehru and Gandhi. Real freedom fighters, were sent to the Cellular Jail in the Andamans.
- prashantsengar 1y agoWhy would the military keep a "compliant native" under house arrest though? Wouldn't it be better for them to get her killed?
- tsimionescu 1y agoNot if that might bring the anger of the Empire down on them in full. There's a reason even totalitarian regimes don't apply the same amount of force to all of their political enemies.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoYou're conflating two different things: she is a compliant native for the British, not for the military. She was always a thorn in their sides. As for your murderous suggestion, that reveals more about your thought process than any thing else.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoAs for kingmaking, I suggest you read the letter exchanges between Gandhi and Motilal Nehru, available online in the Gandhi website. They openly talk of their respective candidates being offered the "crown."