3 ms·
> We have an actual consistent way to define fascism One, a 14-point checklist is functionally worthless in politics. Two, why is Britt the final say on what
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> We have an actual consistent way to define fascism
One, a 14-point checklist is functionally worthless in politics.
Two, why is Britt the final say on what fascism is?
Three, this list is extremely ambiguous. When does criticism cross into disdain, interest into obsession, grim tolerance into rampant acceptance?
Everything on that list is accurate as a retrospective tool. But for contemporaneous measure, it falls short by failing to propose clear tests.
- mystraline 1y agoChecklists are absolutely important, as one can compare various governments across those metrics. And those can be seen as a percentage as to compare scientifically. You added 'final say what fascism is' to create a controversy where there is none. That was never the claim. This was a set of commonalities of previous historical fascist governments. And you add in an ad hominem to Political scientist Dr. Lawrence Britt. His study is in this realm, giving proper credence as an evidentiary start of analyzing fascism. And yes, the abbreviated list I copied and pasted pales into comparison to the source. But I find many on HN dont bother to read linked articles, and instead create strawmen of the copied text. After reading tge posts so far, well, point made.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Checklists are absolutely important Checklists are good, including in public discourse. A 14-point list where every item is ambiguous, is not. It’s not useless per se. Just insufficient as a consistent definition. > you add in an ad hominem to Political scientist Dr. Lawrence Britt Literally don’t. (Ad hominem would be me saying I hate Dr. Britt and rejecting his checklist on that basis.) Saying I reject Britt as a final authority on a topic I don’t believe we have any final authority on yet is very different from rejecting them in any capacity.
- idle_zealot 1y agoWell yeah, fascism doesn't have an actual definition. People even disagree about what it is. Is it a political ideology, a worldview, a form of government, a movement, a type of psychosis? And yet people do retrospectively agree that certain people or groups were fascists. There's an idea in peoples' minds that defies a simple dictionary definition. For an idea like that, we turn to a list of soft criteria. People can and will disagree on that exact set of criteria, or over whether one is met under specific circumstances. But really, that's true of all language outside of hard mathematics. Who gave Britt final say? Nobody in particular, and yet his criteria are often cited and used in more serious discussions of fascism. So a lot of people seem to think his criteria are useful. Language is a collaborative thing, meaning comes from diffuse and tacit agreement. If you expect that some power authorize and enforce a rigid definition of any political or sociological term, prepare to be deeply disappointed when you realize that nobody can provide such solid and concrete definitions of any terminology, even words you think you understand. What's democracy? Capitalism? Authoritarianism? Socialism? They're all defined by tacitly approved sets of criteria invented by an unofficial source and iterated upon by academics and misconstrued by and to the broader population.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Well yeah, fascism doesn't have an actual definition That’s my point. OP said “we have an actual consistent way to define fascism,” and that’s simply not true. That doesn’t mean we can’t call out fascism in real time. But it does mean that everyone who disagrees with you isn’t necessarily a fascist.