4 ms·
All-natural geoengineering with Frank Herbert's Dune
- xiphias2 1y ago[flagged]
- romaintailhurat 1y agoI'm not taking it too seriously but damn i was caught off guard by the first sentence heavy spoiler.
- stronglikedan 1y agoThe first sentence in question: Science fiction understood something fundamental before science caught up.
- smt88 1y agoThe books and previous movies/shows have been out for 60 years, 40 years, and 20 years. I don't think it's fair to complain about spoilers. Should we also refrain from mentioning that Darth Vader's surname is Skywalker?
- orochimaaru 1y agoDune has been around since 1965. This has been flagged incorrectly. You can’t seriously expect “spoilers” to not happen for a work that is 60 years old.
- sjsdaiuasgdia 1y agoIf you're that concerned about spoilers, maybe just don't click on anything related to the media you're so concerned about being spoiled for you? It's a "you" problem with a "you" solution. No one owes you or anyone else this consideration. There's always someone who hasn't seen something. Taking "no spoilers!" to its extreme would prevent ever discussing the content of media at all.
- jghn 1y agoHopefully no one spoils the ending of Titanic for me. I've been waiting to watch that.
- hackable_sand 1y agoHe was already dead
- lanfeust6 1y agoThis is one of the substacks I'm increasingly paying attention to
- photon_garden 1y agoIf you liked this article, I recommend Robin Wall Kimmerer's Braiding Sweetgrass. She's a professional plant scientist and researcher, and her books are both informative and a delightful read.
- colechristensen 1y agoI hated that book. It's science filtered through a double dose of woo mixing unsubstantiated nonsense with plant science.
- isoprophlex 1y agoI on the other hand, loved it. She strikes, in my view, a perfect balance between plant science and folk wisdom. A very refreshing view bridging two worlds, and overall an optimistic one at that.
- colechristensen 1y agoThis is a disagreement I understand at least. I don't think it accomplishes that goal well but to each their own.
- thinkcontext 1y agoI thought a notable omission was discussion of releasing iron or other minerals into the ocean to stimulate algal growth. It mimics natural processes such as wind blowing sand from desserts. Its been tried by a rogue effort that didn't seek permission but saw some success and had the effect of restoring fish numbers in the area. I've gone back and forth on whether the potential for unintended consequences is too risky. Lately I've been in favor of slow, carefully controlled efforts. We've already geoengineered the oceans into a bad situation and are about to take things to a whole new level with ocean mining. Mineral release could be considered analogous to tree planting restoration work.
- colechristensen 1y agoOne thing I think we need to do is intentionally trigger algae or jellyfish blooms in low biodiversity ocean deserts. Usually they're thought of as a bad thing but they could be done in the right way to be significantly carbon negative. A bloom sucks a lot of carbon out of the atmosphere to make biomass which then dies and sinks to the bottom of the ocean as marine snow and then gets buried fixing the carbon under natural sedimentation. Finding places we can make this happen with minimal biome impact and minimal leverage needed to trigger (some missing nutrient which is cheap and readily available)
- zdragnar 1y agoThat's how you get the dead zone off the shore of Louisiana. The algae doesn't get to the bottom before it starts decomposing, and during calm periods (especially the summer months) the deep waters don't get mixed and replenished with oxygen faster than the bacteria decompose the algae. You'd need lots of careful planning to avoid causing more harm than good.
- colechristensen 1y agoThe point is to do this in the marine deserts where it is already mostly a dead zone
- SpicyUme 1y agoWith regard to the sections about beavers, I went to an event this year where a beaver scientist mentioned that many European settlers in North America showed up after beavers had been nearly extirpated by trappers. So they would come across open flat areas with a stream flowing through which had likely been dammed by beavers in the past. This caused problems with flooding and water damage, and problems as beavers have been reestablished in much of the US (and Canada?)
- sampo 1y agoNot related to the article, but related to Frank Herbert's Dune: The Dune ecosystem is much less thought out than it appears to be. Herbert drops bits and pieces about the Dune ecology here and there so getting an overall picture is difficult, so we don't realize how silly it is. * We don't know where sand plankton comes from. * Sand plankton lives in the top layers of desert sand, eats spice. * Some of the tiny sand plankton individuals grow larger, migrate deeper down, and become sand trout. * Sand trout excrement combines with water pockets deep below, is biologically active, grows, releases gases and explodes, transporting it back to surface, becomes spice. * We don't know what sand trout eats, but it should eat something in order to produce excrement. * Some sand trouts grow larger, become sand worms. * Sand worms eat sand plankton. So the thole ecosystem consists only one species, with 3 life stages: (1) sand plankton, (2) sand trout, (3) sand worm. And stage 1 lives by eating the excrement of stage 2, and stage 3 lives by eating stage 1. Ecologically and energetically this is silly. The species just eats itself and its own excrement, and there appears to be no energy input to the system.
- zem 1y agoit may indeed be silly, but as far as energy input to the system goes, all you need to do is postulate that one stage can photosynthesise sunlight.
- Terr_ 1y agoYeah, it's been many years, but my impression was that things could be explained as an invasive and engineered all-in-one species that terraforms (arrakiforms?) the environment, partly as a way to eliminate competition. One phase photosynthesizes, one phase sequesters excess water, and one phase... Stirs the lithosphere and eliminates large animals or trespassers?
- gerikson 1y agoIn the last Herbert Dune book, Chapterhouse, Arrakis is destroyed to eliminate the source of spice, but at least one worm is transported to another planet to begin to turn that into desert, thus ensuring a continued supply.
- ftkftk 1y agoThis summer I helped for a few hours to build Beaver Dam Analogues (BDAs) at Philmont Scout Ranch in New Mexico. I am really looking forward seeing the positive ecological impact when my future grand children trek Philmont. Building BDAs is good fun. You should try it.
- chermi 1y agoInteresting, tell us more! Do the beavers use/upkeep them, or are they purely to create pools where there are no beavers to do so? If the former, is it needed because there aren't enough beavers or not enough wood/vegetation for them to build? Do the beavers "adopt" the structures? Or are they too dissimilar to their constructions? I imagine the main goal is actually less about the beavers than it is restoring habitat that beavers otherwise create. Do you ever build them in places where there never were beavers? I have this funny picture of beavers refusing to enjoy the dams because they didn't build them. No "pride of ownership".
- ftkftk 1y agoBeavers were hunted so intensely that they completely disappeared decades ago in the area. Without the beavers building dams and thus slowing down the flow of creeks, more and more erosion took place and area that used to be wetlands dried out. With the gradual drying the willow tree disappeared, which is one of the major food sources for beavers. So while beavers are starting to repopulate, they don't move in where there is no food available. So Philmont is building BDAs in order to slow down the creeks, providing suitable habitat for willows - and once this food source is once again established, the beavers should return and take over maintenance of the BDAs.
- skylissue 1y agoFrank Herbert was inspired to write Dune after hearing about the sand dunes on the coast of Oregon, which were growing out of control until their spread was controlled by the introduction of European beachgrass https://www.pdxmonthly.com/arts-and-culture/2015/07/how-the-oregon-dunes-inspired-sci-fi-classic-dune https://www.pdxmonthly.com/arts-and-culture/2015/07/how-the-...
- araes 1y agoAt least on the part about the Nootka lupine (Lupinus nootkatensis), seems they're edible in seed and root form [1][2][3] as long as they're leeched properly beforehand to get rid of bitter (possibly toxic) alkaloids. Grizzly bears apparently also relish the roots. Some butterflies feed off the lupine. Medicinally, with less references, used for digestive disorders, skin conditions, and infections.[4] Can probably just farm them, or harvest the fields that exist, and then store the seeds / roots or make flour out of them. Seems like a possible farm crop personally. Go out with a harvester designed for beans / peas. There's not that much that grows in Iceland anyways. [1] USDA, https://plants.usda.gov/DocumentLibrary/plantguide/pdf/pg_luno.pdf https://plants.usda.gov/DocumentLibrary/plantguide/pdf/pg_lu... [2] Sierra Club, https://sierraclub.bc.ca/ecomap/nootka-lupine/ https://sierraclub.bc.ca/ecomap/nootka-lupine/ [3] Plants for a Future, https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Lupinus+nootkatensis https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Lupinus+nootkaten... [4] Wild Flower Web, http://www.wildflowerweb.co.uk/plant/2579/nootka-lupin#:~:text=The%20plant%20is%20often%20used%20in%20land,peoples%20in%20the%20Pacific%20Northwest%20for%20centuries. http://www.wildflowerweb.co.uk/plant/2579/nootka-lupin#:~:te...
- mattwiese 1y agoAnnual lupin (L. angustifolius and L. albus) have been bred for better yields and low alkaloids. There are some existing commercial varieties. Australia is a large producer. From an economic perspective, the yields on perennial lupin are just too low. Something that plant breeding could hopefully address long term. Apparently the Land Institute already investigated it (https://landinstitute.org/our-work/perennial-crops/legumes/ https://landinstitute.org/our-work/perennial-crops/legumes/) and decided on sainfoin instead of lupin. I reached out some time back to ask why, because I was curious if their research found yield or alkaloid content too difficult to control for. Never got a reply.
- araes 1y agoIn terms of commercial farming, it's probably desirable to have the better varieties. Maybe get some of those seeds from Australia then for Iceland. Have variety. Mostly just a suggestion for the issue of "lots of a plants, that we don't especially want." At least it's edible. According to a quick search, it cost apparently $30 to $40 dollars per acre to harvest an existing field (Purdue custom rates survey for combines, obviously no input costs considered, Iceland's maybe different).[1] Maybe add a bit further for cutting, raking, windrowing, and threshing parts. Either way, with an existing field you just want to get rid of, hiring a combine and running it over the field is not that expensive (based on the available prices). Throw it all in a pond, pool, or barrel and let it soak until they're safe to eat. Not horribly expensive. On the sainfoin thing, probably just easier and less work for their objectives. WP says sainfoin's already "highly nutritious plants" used for a long time for forage and nectar production. Frankly, they seem like a trade-off personally, since Lupin varieties grow rapidly in horrible climates and terrain. Sainfoin is apparently finicky. "difficult to establish as pasture, not persistent in grassland, do not recover well from overgrazing." Lupin is probably a better choice for anything in the artic, sub-arctic, tundra, and taiga biomes (which is most of Iceland). [1] https://www.farmprogress.com/harvest/custom-harvesting-could-be-cost-effective-alternative-to-new-equipment-purchases#:~:text=What%20will%20harvesting%20cost?,$34.83%20per%20acre%20to%20$35.94. https://www.farmprogress.com/harvest/custom-harvesting-could...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mallowdram 1y agoRecommend The One-Straw Revolution An Introduction to Natural Farming by Masanobu Fukuoka, it's a mind blower of botanical re-engineering.