4 ms·
"It is getting increasingly difficult to just invest in companies you believe in." You're interpreting that sentence literally. His point is that investing in
by uptown 14y ago
"It is getting increasingly difficult to just invest in companies you believe in."
You're interpreting that sentence literally. His point is that investing in a company used to largely be based on how successful you though that company would be. The market has changed in a way that an overwhelming number of external factors can have a negative (or positive) impact on that company's share price, making the evaluation of
risk far more difficult. At the same time, the barriers to getting into the market have been lowered making it far-easier for anyone to participate. That sentence has nothing to do with how your initial trade was executed.
- harryh 14y ago"The market has changed in a way that an overwhelming number of external factors can have a negative (or positive) impact on that company's share price" Really? In what way has it changed? External factors have always had a huge impact on businesses. I'm sure there were lots of super well run businesses that went under durring the Great Depression (which was, you know, the mother of "external factors").
- whatshisface 14y agoBy external factors, I think he means factors unrelated (or at least not very related) to the success of the company, like wild stock speculation.
- debacle 14y agoAs someone who invests in small caps almost exclusively, I can tell you that 99.99% of the companies in existence today don't suffer from wild stock speculation.
- uptown 14y ago"In what way has it changed?" Two examples: 1. High-frequency algorithmic trading. http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2012/08/06/chart-of-the-day-hft-edition/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2012/08/06/chart-of-th... 3. Repeal of the Glass–Steagall Act, giving government-protected 'too-big-to-fail' commercial banks the ability to incur risks traditionally reserved for investment banks.
- harryh 14y agoAnd how do those changes (especially #2) "have a negative (or positive) impact on that company's share price" ?
- drumdance 14y agoIn the extreme, repeal of Glass-Steagall and resulting shenanigans put the entire market at risk, which in turn put the macro economy at risk, which in turn changed the long term outlook of stocks. That said, I do question the overall premise that HFT affects stock values over the long term.
- harryh 14y agoThat's fair. But I think that's getting pretty far from what Cuban was complaining about. I also don't think that "government decisions can have a big impact on the economy" is a new phenomenon.
- uptown 14y agoIn order to make money on a trade, the share price needs to move. So you've got algorithms whose attributes manage things like how much of an actual order is exposed to the market at one time, or how much they adjust your bid or ask as the order progresses. I've got some algo documentation whose algo "Watch Out For" notes warn "may be too aggressive and cause impact" and "must watch out for order size that adversely impacts market". But maybe you're a trader that decides you want to be "too aggressive" with your trade and now you've moved the market because you've used an algorithm in a way it wasn't intended to be used, and your employer's risk controls didn't care or didn't catch what you were doing until it's too late. Net effect is that your trade may sway the overall market in a way that moved that company, or that company's sector, or maybe the whole market depending on what impact your trade had. And all of that assumes the algorithms behave in a way that they're expected to. I like this example from Amazon's pricing algorithms: http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2384102,00.asp http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2384102,00.asp but you could apply the same concerns to pricing matters of the stock market where the unintended consequences of poorly-conceived strategies have a destabilizing effect on pricing. HFT allows all of this happen so much faster than could have ever been done manually. And when high frequency trading is being done by entities with enormous balance sheets, and an increased tolerance for risk due to assurances by the government that they'll be bailed out should they make a bad bet, it's got the potential to destabilize the entire market.
- btilly 14y agoIf that is really his point, then he does not understand value investing. From the point of view of a value investor, the numbers that you care about are the current price, and how successful you think that company will be. If the current price is below that benchmark, you buy and hold. If the current price is above that benchmark then maybe you want to sell short. (The reason for the maybe is that, the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.) Either way you're aiming to make a profit off of the difference between long-term returns and the price you bought it at. Therefore from the point of view of a value investor, everything that helps people lose track of a company's long-term prospects is good for you.
- chromatic 14y agoBetter than that, an irrational dip in a stock's price due to an analyst recommendation or another factor may represent a good opportunity for a value investor!
- nirvana 14y agoExactly. And we should just stop calling them "Value" investors. This is true for growth investors, any kind of investors, in fact all investors. Investing is about knowing the difference between value and the price. When you can do that-- and when I say "knowing" I mean it, and I have a spreadsheet to calculate it-- then you can buy low and sell high. The problem is wall street is in the business of managing other people's money and most people are ignorant of money, so you have a lot of people who just turn their money over to others to "manage"... and many of those that use other people's money end up gambling with it rather than investing it... this problem is compounded by the moral hazard created by the government bailing these companies out when the gambles turn south (or underwriting the gambling by buying bad securities as helicopter ben is doing right now to the tune of $40B a month.) The problem with wall street is government regulation which is idiotically designed, and intervention-- in the form of bailouts-- that perverts the entire system incentivizing gambling. And the people voting for all this, generally don't even know what money is, let alone how to invest it. (If you think the dollars in your pocket are money, then you're one of those people, and I suggest you read http://mises.org/money.asp http://mises.org/money.asp )
- ryanwaggoner 14y agoThis is only true if you're "investing" on unreasonably short time horizons. And this has always been the case: "In the short run the market is a voting machine. In the long run it's a weighing machine." - Warren Buffet, quoting Benjamin Graham
- RockyMcNuts 14y agoThe market has changed because there are a lot of imbalances that make expected returns bimodal. For instance, either the euro is going to implode, or it's not. Either there's going to be a recession due to [insert Europe/China/Japan/Middle East] or there's not. So in the short run returns might depend on the perceived likelihood of catastrophe (risk-on/risk-off). Also, with interest rates low, return expectations might have gotten low enough that the significant vig of Wall Street is a bigger problem for some strategies.
- meric 14y agoYou can always take out market risk by hedging against the index. i.e buy the stock, short the index and bet the stock will do better than the market overall.