3 ms·
Is this true though? It's easy for everyone for all the armchair CEOs to say that Jobs never would have released such an epic fail, but I'm not so sure. If th
by dasil003 14y ago
Is this true though? It's easy for everyone for all the armchair CEOs to say that Jobs never would have released such an epic fail, but I'm not so sure.
If there's one thing that Apple hates as much as a half-baked UX, it's dependency on another tech company. It seems pretty obvious to me as a casual developer and observer of Google maps over the years that global mapping is really really hard. How could Apple not have known this? I don't think even they have this much hubris.
Now we don't know why negotiations with Google for the maps API failed. Maybe Apple was overconfident, maybe Google was playing hard ball for Android's sake, maybe a bit of both. But regardless of the reason, the contract was not renewed and they had to release something. The iPhone without maps is not the iPhone.
The fact that they used an algorithmic approach to QA says more about the timelines than Apple's beliefs about the overall best approach. There was simply not time to get people on the ground to do a proper QA job. Apple's hands were tied.
- cookiecaper 14y agoAre Bing Maps this horrible? Couldn't they license those if they didn't have a choice? Or what about MapQuest? What about the maps used by GPS units? Couldn't they have made a deal with Garmin or Tomtom or someone like that? It may have taken more work than integration with Google, but it'd almost definitely take less work than starting from scratch. I definitely do not believe that their hands were tied and they were forced into creating their own shoddy, incomplete system. On top of all that, I think Google has more business intelligence than to actually let the contract for iOS maps go. Maybe both sides were just bluffing and never thought the one party would cut the other loose, or something like that, but you'd think with a deal this big at some point someone would come back with their tail between their legs and reopen negotiations. Of course, it's all speculation at this point anyway. It'd be nice if someone with knowledge could come in here and elucidate, though the likelihood of that is really small.
- skeletonjelly 14y agoI thought Apple did have a relationship with Tomtom for this?
- cookiecaper 14y agoYes, you're apparently right: http://www.engadget.com/2012/06/11/apple-tomtom-ios-6-maps/ http://www.engadget.com/2012/06/11/apple-tomtom-ios-6-maps/ I'm not sure what all that deal entails, so it's hard to say whether it could have been better executed upon, other than to say it's clearly not ready yet. I find it hard to believe, however, that all of the incorrect placement of destinations and, in some cases, even the inclusion of destinations that have not existed for decades, also occur in TomTom's car navigation systems.
- skeletonjelly 14y agoSorry I should have found a source for you! It's pretty embarrassing for them too isn't it.
- jrabone 14y agoOne can always use http://routes.tomtom.com/ http://routes.tomtom.com/ as a source for comparison. It would also be good if certain journalists and bloggers did this before shooting their mouths off about data quality, but that wouldn't make a compelling headline.
- glenra 14y agoTomTom is pretty good at directing you to a street address but is just terrible in terms of finding local destinations. I did a ~2000 mile road trip a few months ago and several times that I was looking for something specific I couldn't find it or found the wrong thing using TomTom. It turned out the best workflow was to look something up in Google Maps, get the address from Google, type that address into TomTom, and let TomTom direct me to that address.
- camiller 14y agoFrom the article "2. I suspect that the data and routing functionality that they have from TomTom, while not the best, is simply not the source of their problems. ..." The author of the article is suggesting the problem is the integration of lots of other data in with the TomTom data is the problem. Not the TomTom data
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sethg 14y agoLast I heard, Bing was contracting out to Nokia for their maps, as part of the whole Nokia-Microsoft strategic surrend^H^H^H^H^H^H^Hpartnership. (And I know that for all its faults, Nokia is smart enough to apply human QA to their mapping system, because in my last job I worked on the Web site that those human contractors used.)
- ernesth 14y ago> What about the maps used by GPS units? Couldn't they have made a deal with Garmin or Tomtom or someone like that? They have made a deal with Tomtom (teleatlas). Concerning Garmin, they don't do maps but use navteq (a subsidiary of nokia). Apple should probably have bought nokia, they would have acquired the best mobile maps technology.